All brands in Humidors
Most Helpful Reviews for Humidors
Cigar Humidors
JR Glass Top Wood Humidor With Hygrometer
This is a humidor that does not hold humidity!
Robert B.
10/31/2019
After seasoning the humidor to 80%, I loaded it with cigars and was not able to get it to hold humidity. I filled out the on-line customer support form, explaining the problem and asking what to do. The form said I should expect a reply within two business days. That was 5 days ago. I have not had any form of reply! Using the propylene glycol insert provided, the humidor held about 50% humidity. I achieved 68% humidity with 10 cigars that had been in another humidor at 70% after a week by adding two small half full water glasses. It appears a 70% humidity reading would require another small glass of water. Unfortunately, the water glasses take valuable storage space and limit movement of the humidor to avoid water spills. The top has minimal friction and opens very easily. And, it appears there are air leaks around the hygrometer hole. The box is attractive. Unfortunately, based on my experience as presented above, a score of one star is generous. A humidor that does not hold humidity supported by unresponsive customer service is an indication to me that I need to shop elsewhere to find an acceptable product.
Humidifiers
Cigar Oasis Excel 3.0
Ruined my Cigars
iK
07/01/2019
First of all what they don't tell you here is that the app requires a monthly subscription. Otherwise the wifi is pointless. Secondly, my unit just caused an entire box of Cuban Padron Serie D to be thrown out due to mold. The cigars are so damp they are almost wet. The unit is set to default of 70%. My other cigars would be ruined as well had they not been in wrappers. It was working fine for a couple of months and now it's over humidifying. Just caused me to lose about $300 or more.
Prestige Cigar Humidors
Valencia Digital Cherry
Will not hold humidity
Newcomer 3.
01/05/2020
I have tried several things to correct the humidity. Nothing works. I have lost over $100 in cigars with this box. Looks great and thought this was a great quality.
Prestige Cigar Humidors
Chateau Glass Top Cherry
It’s a $16 Humidor
Patrick
04/27/2020
Listen folks it does the job. It holds cigars and looks pretty good. Construction was a pleasant surprise. For a $15 buck get a decent humidifier and it’s still a bargain. If you want a first quality Humidor spend the dough.
Cigar Humidors
Bally
Bally Humidor
IM
02/06/2020
Hygrometer does not work, nor calibrate. I'm using with a digital hygrometer instead. JR cannot send a replacement hygrometer, so advised I return the whole humidor.
Prestige Cigar Humidors
Chateau Glass Top Cherry
You get what you pay for.
mattgarlough
10/13/2019
This box looks nice but that is about where it ends. It is not effective at keeping my cigars properly humid despite following instructions to the letter. The hygrometer doesn't appear to do much of anything so once the interior wood dries out so does everything else inside. I suspect that maybe the lid does not seal properly. What's odd is that there are little spots of mold growing around the outside desspite the fact that the box is almost always dry.
Prestige Cigar Humidors
Chateau Glass Top Cherry
Does the job
Adam C.
07/10/2019
I got one of these for $5 with a cigar pack and I bought another one for $16 so I could try my hand at infusing some cigars. It is well made however, the humidifier is an awkward shape and size. If you have cigars that are longer than 5 inches you won't be able to fit 20 due to the humidifier taking up space for about 3 of them. Placing the humidifier onto the glass obscures the view and also does not allow the lid to close all the way. I have some coffee oil that I rubbed into one of the boxes. The seal is so nice, a friend told me that he could not smell a hint of coffee when it was closed. The box without the oil has a very pleasant cherry wood smell. I think it is worth it even at the $16 price.
Cigar Humidors
JR Glass Top Wood Humidor With Hygrometer
Poor Quality
Dutch
01/10/2020
Won this box on Beat The Dealer. Box has numerous cosmetic flaws on outside. Looks like it will keep your cigars just fine but definately not a show piece.
Cigar Humidors
Romeo y Julieta Logo Glass Top Humidor
Great quality
Joe B.
06/27/2019
This humidor is of great quality! It shuts snug and comes with everything you need to keep your cigars fresh! Highly recommend this humidor.
Humidifier Solutions
Paradigm 16oz
Great Deal
X. G.
12/29/2019
This was a great deal. The formula works as well as the more expensive name brands.
Humidifier Solutions
Paradigm 16oz
Great Deal
X. G.
12/29/2019
This was a great deal. The formula works as well as the more expensive name brands.
Prestige Cigar Humidors
Chateau Glass Top Cherry
NOT GOOD !
george s.
03/09/2020
Received this humidor as part of a promo buy a box of Montecristio Anejados and get an ashtray -lighter , and humidor valued at $ 49.95 . The ashtray was very nice haven't opened the lighter , the $ 49.95 humidor turned into a $ 16.95 humidor which is $33.00 cheaper than what I was told ,the $ 16.95 humidor advertises that it has a hydrometer included and it shows a humidifier in the picture of it . JR shouldn't state that the humidor is $ 49.95 if they are going to send you a $ 16.95 humidor, they could have at least sent a 5pk. of decent cigars to make up the difference . This no way to keep customers .
