HMR
InStock
4.321428571428571
28
Rothschild
Pretty good smoke loads of smoke with every drawwhich the draw itself was perfect with good flavor that got especially good after the first third of the stick... would definitely buy again.
4
5
1
December 13, 2018
Bob V.
Rothschild
Questions and may be a more to you a very nice and easy for a year of a year of a year of a
5
5
1
December 29, 2016
SHAWN B.
Rothschild
This is very similar to the Robusto but a littlr wider. A good average smoke cor your daily needs.
3
5
1
December 7, 2016
Garron F.
Rothschild
Nice thick cigar that is easy to smoke. Medium to full body with a load of flavors like pepper and spice.
4
5
1
October 17, 2016
JASON S.
Rothschild
One of the best Hoyo's around. Great draw. Flavors of nut and leather. Let them age a bit and the ceader with hints of spice merry well.
4
5
1
October 16, 2016
BRIAN J.
Rothschild
If you like a mild to medium strength cigar that is good. Don't look any further. Has to be one of the best you can get.
5
5
1
October 2, 2016
Peter N.
Rothschild
This is my go to smoke. I try other sticks but always come home to this one.
5
5
1
August 25, 2016
LOU D.
Rothschild
Love Hoyas wrapper and finish Not as powerful as some others but this means it's a great day smoke
5
5
1
August 21, 2016
GLENN M.
Rothschild
This was one of the very first cigars I ever had and let me tell you that the experience was good
4
5
1
July 8, 2016
Jonathan H.
Rothschild
I enjoy these and the Punch version. Never had a bad one and smoked them for more years than I have digits on my hands and toes! You can't go wrong with these folks!!
3
5
1
April 12, 2016
Yehuda A.
Rothschild
I prefer this size of cigar. I has a great draw and even burn. I had one that the construction was off. Pretty much think that was a fluke.
4
5
1
December 2, 2015
Matthew M.
Rothschild
This was not too bad for a relatively cheap cigar. I smoked it new right out of the cellophane wrapper. I am certain it will benefit from some aging in a find humidor. I like the size and think that something larger would be too much.
4
5
1
September 22, 2015
Shawn T.
Rothschild
Like a full bodied cigar and these are definitely in the medium to full range. Good construction with few problems. Nice burn. Taste similar to Punch or Rocky. Not a big cigar but can always smoke two, especially when you can get them on sale. The Rothschild is becoming a staple n my humidor.
4
5
1
September 19, 2019
Brian Rothenberger
Rothschild
A very pleasant smoke on light-up. Full of 'sweet' smoke almost mellow. W/me the beginning of a cigar is always better than the 'end'. Superior to the comparable Punch robusto. I used to buy these for $99/bx of 50!
4
5
1
October 5, 2018
Cecil W.
Rothschild
Good medium bodied cigar. Had a couple of burn issues but no big deal. Good draw. A pretty good cigar at this price
5
5
1
July 20, 2017
Jason H.
Rothschild
Very nice smoke. Rich oily wrapper. Burns perfectly. Flawless construction and consistency. A personal favorite
5
5
1
July 10, 2017
Josh S.
Rothschild
Yeah man sides it's just smooth it's got a good taste to it the deeper you go in like the better to taste good I would highly recommend this my brother
5
5
1
December 30, 2016
Michael H.
Rothschild
I love all the Hoyas I have tried and I love this one . It is exceptionally smooth and very well made . I love it
5
5
1
October 15, 2016
Troy F.
Rothschild
These are nice but need a great deal of ready to be a really good stick but nice no matter what great buy
3
5
1
June 30, 2016
David J.
Rothschild
This is a very good short smoke. Well made and full of flavor Hoyos have been consistently good for the 20 years I've been smoking them.
4
5
1
March 29, 2016
Bob D.
Rothschild
I've had two of these now and they strike a remarkable balance between sweet and spicy. They burn well right down to the last inch or so. Great with coffee. Worth a try!
4
5
1
December 21, 2015
Patrick B.
Rothschild
I tend to smoke maduros but when I want a little change of pace this is always a fine choice. Great smoke with a earthy touch. I'd recommend it for a milder smoker looking to take it up a notch. Nice tight draw and even burn all the way down. Can't go wrong with this fine middle of the road smoke.
4
5
1
June 16, 2015
William L.
Rothschild
Much easier draw than comparable Punch Rothschilds. Like better!
5
5
1
May 24, 2021
Bill w.
Rothschild
One of my first box purchases, 30 plus years ago. The cigars have always been consistent, and mellow. Hard to get them on sale, but still a great treat.
4
5
1
May 16, 2022
Jimbo
Rothschild
I purchased this cigar in a 5 pack because I've never smoked this one before. I was pleased with the flavor and construction of these fine Cuban style smokes. I enjoy trying out new/old cigars and buying them in 5 packs makes it easier to try without spending the money on a full box. All in all for $4 a stick it is a bargain.
5
5
1
August 8, 2022
Scott S.
Rothschild
Hoyo's Rothschild's are consistent. Decade after decade. Plain good old tobacco flavour. No fancy blending to achieve chocolate coffee toffee with a creamy filling.
Yeah no. Not here. Tobacco. Plain. Good old fashioned medium strength cigar with a heady finish. Providing you smoke your cigar down to less than an inch.
Lovem. Thank you!
5
5
1
September 7, 2022
IficanUcan2
Rothschild
Medium-full bodied with notes of earth, wood, & leather. Can get bitter, if smoked too fast. Great construction, draw, burn, & consistency; with a firm & uniform, white & darker gray ash. The medium brown & oily, Ecuadoran Sumatra is smooth and well finished. A well-constructed cigar, best enjoyed with slow smoking pace and balanced with a sweeter drink.
4
5
1
November 7, 2022
WYO_Guy
Rothschild
I can get real Cubans when I travel to Europe but I like these more!
5
5
1
September 10, 2024
Wizdoc
Hoyo de Monterrey
Rothschild 4.50 × 50 HMR
A classic Honduran smoke, the Hoyo de Monterrey Rothschild is a delectably bold, premium cigar. With a medium-to-full body profile, this golden-brown delight is skillfully dressed in an Ecuador Sumatra wrapper, bound with a Connecticut Broadleaf, and filled with a rich blend of Dominican, Honduran, and Nicaraguan tobaccos. For enthusiasts with an earthy palate, pick up boxes of 50.
Read more
4.50
50
Parejo
Ecuador Sumatra
Connecticut Broadleaf
Dominican Republic/Honduras/Nicaragua
Honduras
Medium - Full
EMS
Retail Price
$359.50
JR Price
$285.99
You Save
$73.51
Buy a box and get 5 cigars free!
Customers also bought
Some reviewers may have received JR Insider loyalty program points for their reviews.
Click here to learn more about JR Insider.