4.078947368421052 38
Rothschild Just like all the other Macanudo iv smoke they are great these are goodoing starter sticks nice creamy earthy flavor 5 5 1
Rothschild The flavor of this cigar is very mellow I like the way it smokes 4 5 1
Rothschild Perfect draw. Perfect construction and the smoothness you expect from macanudo. Would buy again. 5 5 1
Rothschild I like the Portofino so I went for this on the auction. The cigar tastes like a Mac. but does not burn as such I understand that they were bought out they should have kept crew. 3 5 1
Rothschild Nice mild silky smooth cigar. Lights nice but have had several plug up. Good chew flavor as well as the smoke. A larger sized cigar smokes nicer but the cafe line is the best 4 5 1
Rothschild This is my 2nd favorite mild cigar with very flavorful notes of almond and milky creamy mild finish 5 5 1
Rothschild Ive had about 4 or 5 of these and the burns are inconsistent. Mild bodied smoke that could use a but more flavor 4 5 1
Rothschild Macanudo hits another homerun with this one. No disappointment here. A well-constructed cigar with spicy to nutty overtones and beautiful aroma. Would recommend to anyone 5 5 1
Rothschild A real treat for a mild cigar smoker. 4 5 1
Rothschild Love these cigars! 5 5 1
Rothschild Very good above average, smooth to the last 2 inches. Pleasant. 4 5 1
Rothschild Macanudo is always a pleasure smoke and this one holds true as well. Great flavor and very consistent. 5 5 1
Rothschild I like the Portofino so I went for this on the auction. The cigar tastes like a Mac. but does not burn as such I understand that they were bought out they should have kept crew. 3 5 1
Rothschild Great mild - medium cigar. Creamy nutty aromas and flavor with consistently even draw even burn and creamy smoke. Love these with a coffee after breakfast. The reviews with too easy draw probably are too dry. Reviews citing uneven burn problems are probably over-humidified. If you pull one of these out of a properly humidified humidor you can be assured of a very enjoyable experience. 5 5 1
Rothschild This is a well constructed all around nice smoke. Good flavor and good til the very end. 4 5 1
Rothschild Good draw no runs and good flavor. One of my favorites for the price. 4 5 1
Rothschild If u buy these expect a experience bit not a good one these are no good and I wouldn't give to a new be so bad 2 5 1
Rothschild Good cigar and the time was a little more then what I wanted but still nothing wrong with trying 4 5 1
Rothschild draw is hard. not like smoking a rope like other Macanudos but not much better. Macanudos have gone down since they were bought out. 2 5 1
Rothschild The cigar is hard and the draw poor although not as bad as I had with Macanudo Ascots. but not much better either. I was a longtime Macanudo smoker until it was bought out but I switched to Romeo and Juliet. I suggest others switch brands too. 2 5 1
Rothschild Like most Macanudo cigars I've had. This one has great construction and draw with pretty decent burn. Also like most Macanudos it has little to no flavor at best I very lite tobacco and that's it. 3 5 1
Rothschild I bought a box of these Macanudos and have been very pleased with their overall quality and flavor with a hint of coffee. They are a very mild cigar. They light easily draw well and burn evenly from start to finish. They are packaged neatly and look great. The wrappers are light brown and free of blemishes. I would recommend these cigars for anyone looking for a smooth mild smoke. 4 5 1
Rothschild Great Macanudo flavor and a nice smooth cigar 4 5 1
Rothschild Awesome Smoke 5 5 1
Rothschild Great cigar! Mild tobacco blends; draws nicely; and.....the price was right. Love Macanudos. 5 5 1
Rothschild Good, consistent!! 4 5 1
Rothschild The Rothchild has long been one of my favorite cigars. It is the perfect smoke while relaxing with your favorite cocktail. 5 5 1
Rothschild I love this cigar it is so smooth, an has a great draw! A Great lazy sunny Sunday afternoon smoke! 5 5 1
Rothschild Great cigar 5 5 1
Rothschild Well constructed, silky smoke with just a hint of sweet on the finish but I find the faint flavor of acorns in there somewhere ruins what would otherwise be a very pleasant mid day or morning smoke. I am straying from full bodied smokes that are now so powerful that they dull my palate. It's a new adventure. I will give these macs some time and stick to Don Diegos while I explore more. 3 5 1
Rothschild I'm still trying to figure out what the big deal is with Macanudo. To me they are decidedly mediocre. They remind me of cheap Dominican bundles, but they cost a bundle. They are poorly constructed, with a tight draw. 2 5 1
Rothschild This is a regal shape and size but it usnt a Rothschild, lancero maybe. I had been smoking cigars for a few decades and always smoked something other than a Macanudo. They were said to be "beginner cigars". Well, returning from years of "cubanesque" (what ever that means anymore), dense, heavy smokes I now enjoy lighter varieties. Macanudo is now among them. I get a little bit more oatstraw flavor up front than I would like, and a don Diego is more creamy but these are nice afternoon or morning coffee accompaniment. I see some other reviewers have draw problems. In nearing two boxes I have had nothing but perfectly wrapped, perfectly rolled, slightly snug draw, just the way I believe thus size stick should perform. Hmm.. one third through and that straw flavor is dissapering. If you are turning away from the fat heavy smokes, pick up a five pack and check these out. 4 5 1
Rothschild Bit harsh. Draw was ok but was tough to smoke 3 5 1
Rothschild They were a gift 5 5 1
Rothschild Liked them. 4 5 1
Rothschild Good, reliable cigar, with few poorly rolled ones. Mild smoke but flavor comes through. Downside is they have been out of stock on the main JR website for some time….. 5 5 1
Rothschild I bid on these whenever they are on auction. Just a consistently good cigar. I’ve never been disappointed yet. The construction is near perfect as is the draw. 5 5 1
Rothschild These are a great smoke and the perfect size. 5 5 1


Rothschild 6.50 × 42 MAR

The creamy smooth flavors come shining through in this this most popular Macanudo Rothschild size. Featuring a gorgeous Connecticut shade wrapper, a thick Mexican binder and filler tobaccos from the Dominican Republic and Mexico. For many, this was their very first premium cigar, and for those who haven’t tried them, you don’t know what you are missing. Order a box of 25 today, and see for yourself why these are one of the most legendary Dominican brands ever created.
Read more



Connecticut Shade


Dominican Republic / Mexico

Dominican Republic



Retail Price
JR Price
You Save
Notify me when this product is back in stock

Buy a select box of Macanudo and get a humidor +10 cigars free!

Customers also bought

Some reviewers may have received JR Insider loyalty program points for their reviews. Click here to learn more about JR Insider.