All Brands  ›  Cigars  ›  Handmade Cigars  ›  JR Alternative Cigars  ›  JR Honduran / Nicaraguan Alternative  ›  Punch Rothschild
JRPUR3
4.122448979591836 49
Punch Rothschild Been smoking these for twenty five years. A consistent satisfying smoke. They burn well. Not really comparable to the Punch brand in favour (these are Nicaraguan not Honduran) but for the money they are the best value. 5 5 1
Punch Rothschild I tried these before and decided to reorder since I really liked them. Ordered these on Friday evening and lo and behold they were here Sunday. Way to go JR. 4 5 1
Punch Rothschild It seems this is typical of all the cigars I purchased in this price range. Nothing great but smokable. Burned fair the draw was good a bit of uneven burn though. The taste was OK not harsh. Flavor was slightly flat with nuance of pepper and cedar. I will continue to hunt for a very good $2 cigar. I'm sure they are out there. 3 5 1
Punch Rothschild Absolutely wonderful ! Smooth and consistent. Great flavor with spicy finish. Will buy again. Great cigar for the price! 5 5 1
Punch Rothschild Just received these cigars. Wonderful! Regularly smoke Brick house mighty mighty . Slow consistent burn. Slightly spicy on the tounge. Great value. Would pay another dollar per cigar for a 6 x 60 version (hint hint). Was worried about construction at this price but held together like a $12 smoke. 5 5 1
Punch Rothschild I must tell you that I was very surprised and happy with this cigar. The quality and taste are fantastic and it really makes for a great smoke lasting 45 minutes or so. You can't beat this one. Thanks JR! 5 5 1
Punch Rothschild The real Punch Rothschild maduro is my absolute favorite cigar. I'm not sure these taste like them but they're a good smoke. Good taste good aroma good morning after flavor. I like these better than some of the Rocky Patel cigars I tried with this same order. 4 5 1
Punch Rothschild Compared to the Puch Rothschild Maduro this smoke is a little over the top. A little more intense flavor (maybe a little too much pepper) than the Punch but the aroma is spot on the original. If you can get past that this is a good affordable smoke. 4 5 1
Punch Rothschild Last order was not the same as all of my previous orders of this cigar. Different ring size length and taste. I am reordering to try again . Loved all my previous orders but this one is not up to my taste preference. 2 5 1
Punch Rothschild Cheap cigar. But flavor is top notch. I had a 20 pack of these and the burn isn't always the best. Some are perfect. Others have veins in them that make it burn uneven. But the flavor is perfect! I'll continue to buy them! 3 5 1
Punch Rothschild Extremely close to the original Punch enjoy this smoke very well balanced excellent draw. Thanks JR 5 5 1
Punch Rothschild The JR Alternative maduro-wrapped Punch Rothschild cigar is my favorite every-day cigar...I’ve tried ‘em all. I always appreciate the fast shipping service! 5 5 1
Punch Rothschild Overall a nice cigar but not as good as a real Punch Rothschild Maduro which has been my long time favorite morning cigar with my Colombian coffee. But all in all still a nice tasting cigar. I have found a few very tight with hard draw which I hate with any cigar. They get better the longer they age in a good humidor. They are still a bargain for your money compared to what my local cigar shop's garbage sold at this price. 3 5 1
Punch Rothschild A good cigar for the price. Small but fierce; very full-bodied well constructed. Occasionally I'll get one that seems a bit off but at this price point that's not really the end of the world. 4 5 1
Punch Rothschild Great cigar for the money! Lot of full bodied flavor and great draw. 4 5 1
Punch Rothschild I enjoy one or two every evening while sitting and enjoying the quiet outdoor sounds of nature or enjoying a cold beer and grilling a great steak. Great smoke! Great flavor! 4 5 1
Punch Rothschild Great stick for the price. What a great money saving alternative to the real thing. I would highly recommend these and that you try other or alternatives. I have never bee dissatisfied. Nothing like a good punch cigar and a hard cider 5 5 1
Punch Rothschild A very good everyday cigar. They had a good draw very good consistency a nice even burn & a Great price. I would definitely buy these cigars again. 3 5 1
Punch Rothschild Great cigar for the price 4 5 1
Punch Rothschild These are perfect just. Like the real punch I've always loved. 5 5 1
Punch Rothschild Smooth smoke very nice flavor 4 5 1
Punch Rothschild Great cigar for the money! Very consistent through the pack. Will buy again 3 5 1
Punch Rothschild GOOD CIGAR EVEN BURN. GREAT EVERYDAY CIGAR.FOR A SHORT SMOKE. 5 5 1
Punch Rothschild This is an inexpensive stick and is ideal for people that need 3 or more cigars a day and need to watch their expenses. A good cigar overall. I always have 40 in my humidor at a given time 3 5 1
Punch Rothschild Overall a nice cigar but not as good as a real Punch Rothschild Maduro which has been my long time favorite morning cigar with my Colombian coffee. But all in all still a nice tasting cigar. I have found a few very tight with hard draw which I hate with any cigar. They get better the longer they age in a good humidor. They are still a bargain for your money compared to what my local cigar shop's garbage sold at this price. 3 5 1
Punch Rothschild Great tasting little cigar. Good daily smoke very consistent. It's listed as a medium cigar very smooth not harsh at all. Great value. 4 5 1
Punch Rothschild They came fast and they we just what I ordered. The smoke is nice and smooth and the burn true. A great smoke for a great price I will be getting more. Jim 5 5 1
Punch Rothschild I have been doing punch alternative for many years. I’m over 70 and have lit more than most of you. This is a great cigar but lately it has been inconsistent. One batch I had to throw away because it was impossible to draw. The last two batches have been amazing so hopefully JR will continue to use this vendor as its source.I will keep buying is this is one of the best cigars I’ve enjoyed. 5 5 1
Punch Rothschild Had a chance to smoke a few sticks. A little milder than the punch but pretty good overall. Construction is good, taste isn't punch but good for the price. Overall happy with the purchase. 4 5 1
Punch Rothschild This last bundle of smoke are rolled very tight and hard to draw. which is unusual for these. 3 5 1
Punch Rothschild Nice smooth smoke priced rite quick delivery I’ll be back 5 5 1
Punch Rothschild Jr ruthless child all the best and they save me a lot of money thank you Jr 5 5 1
Punch Rothschild Very good cigar for this price point. Built well, holds up with some notes of Punch Rothschild. 4 5 1
Punch Rothschild Totally a great smoke for the price my go to cigar after work. Mellow with a even burn. 4 5 1
Punch Rothschild Good smoke for a good price. 5 5 1
Punch Rothschild Great alternative! Construction and flavor are spot on! I like these little gems! 4 5 1
Punch Rothschild Came dry. Leaf peeling off. 2 5 1
Punch Rothschild I like everything about this cigar nice Draw great for a 20 minute to 30 minutes smoke on you lunch break are morning smoke I will buy again 5 5 1
Punch Rothschild Punch Rothschild has always been one of my favorites. These are comparable in construction and flavor profile. I might actually prefer the JR Alternative. 5 5 1
Punch Rothschild Good smoke. One of my regulars 4 5 1
Punch Rothschild Good smoke burns good 5 5 1
Punch Rothschild Good taste. Perfect size for a quick smoke. 5 5 1
Punch Rothschild Decent smoke for the price most of the time. 4 5 1
Punch Rothschild These are hard to beat. If you like a Punch rothschild, you won't be disappointed. Smoked these for 25 years and always keep on hand. These are not ultra-premium cigars, but I give them a 5 across the board for what they are: a good smoke at a great price that taste just like a Punch. 5 5 1
Punch Rothschild I don't write reviews because they are always subjective. March 2023 I ordered two packs of JRPUR3. Been smoking them for years. Always good but this last batch out of Burlington was out of this world. Best sticks I've ever had (and that includes countless with ratings in the 90's). I'm in my mid 70's and know a good cigar from a great cigar. My fear is that you will change the vendor over time. Suggest you big boys at JR light one of these sticks and tell me I'm wrong. Whoever is making these is a jewel. Stay with them. The only problem with them is I burn them so low I burn my finger. 5 5 1
Punch Rothschild I really was apprehensive about these... but they rock. I freaky enjoyed them with some coffee in the morning. 5 5 1
Punch Rothschild One of the worst cigars I’ve ever had. I bought a bundle of 20 based on mostly good reviews. Unfortunately, these were really bad. 1 5 1
Punch Rothschild Very easy smoke and great flavor! Highly recommend. Burns even as well. 5 5 1
Punch Rothschild Good construction, good draw, slightly stronger than expected. Definitely Not Mild LOL. Will smoke them but stronger than my luking 3 5 1

JR Nicaraguan Alternative

Punch Rothschild 4.50 × 50 JRPUR3

The JR Alternative to the maduro-wrapped Punch Rothschild cigar is the perfect choice if you’re looking for a great tasting, wallet-friendly premium cigar. These top-notch cigars are meticulously handcrafted using the same or similar premium tobacco as the original blends, and many times they are made in the same factory. The difference being, is that we pay for the packaging, marketing, and advertising, thus cutting out the middleman, and passing the savings onto you. They've been our bestselling cigars by far, for over 50- years, and standout as a first in the industry that has never been copied. Order a bundle of 20 today, and enjoy those savory Punch Rothschild flavors for a very affordable JR Cigar price.

Read more
Choose the delivery option
Tip: You can cancel or edit your smart refill orders at any time
4.50

50

Parejo

Various

Various

Various

Nicaragua

Medium

Maduro

Bundle of 20

Retail Price
$83.00
JR Price
$51.99
You Save
$31.01
InStock

For a limited time, get 10 free cigars!

Customers also bought

Some reviewers may have received JR Insider loyalty program points for their reviews. Click here to learn more about JR Insider.