JRPUR
InStock
4.0
34
Punch Rothschild
In comparison to the name brand this smoke is exceptional. No ligero detected not a bad but delicate flavor and aroma. Careful though oversmoking (heating it up) can destroy that delicate flavor and aroma and make it into a harsh smoke. For someone who likes those expensive Punch Rothschilds this is a good comparable everyday smoke.
4
5
1
March 18, 2017
DAVE O.
Punch Rothschild
Just down right great cigarwould definitely be purchasing some time real soon thanks JR
5
5
1
February 11, 2017
SCOTT H.
Punch Rothschild
Excellent everyday smoke
5
5
1
November 16, 2016
SCOTT H.
Punch Rothschild
a fine every day smoke consistency a little uneven I do buy higher priced cigars but keep coming back when they are good they smoke like an 8 dollar stick
3
5
1
April 9, 2016
KENNETH P.
Punch Rothschild
I have been buying this cigar for over ten years and love it. I sometimes try different cigars but I always wish I had purchased this one !
5
5
1
November 25, 2015
PRENTICE C.
Punch Rothschild
JR hit one out of the park with these babies! Ahh the aroma!
4
5
1
November 10, 2015
JOHN S.
Punch Rothschild
Just to update this cigar where I first said it was ok and you get what you pay for.
This Cigar is really good. JR gives you value for the buck here. Will purchase again.
4
5
1
June 19, 2015
JOHN S.
Punch Rothschild
Far from anything that resembles a Punch or tastes like a Punch. Is this a good cigar for the money? You get what ya pay for.
2
5
1
June 15, 2015
JOHN S.
Punch Rothschild
I have ordered these cigars many times. They aren't exact taste duplicates but they are tasty and well made.
4
5
1
June 13, 2015
PATRICK B.
Punch Rothschild
These are always a great value.
4
5
1
June 8, 2015
ADAM H.
Punch Rothschild
First time buying a JR Alternative. I will say these were a delicious cigar. I've only had two but so far they have been worth every cent. They are very close to the real punch.
4
5
1
May 7, 2015
Thomas F.
Punch Rothschild
Good every day smoke. You have to learn to deal with some hot spots and runs but a good value.
4
5
1
April 2, 2015
JOHN P.
Punch Rothschild
I'm a cigar newbie, so I wanted something that would be decent and was not very expensive to get started. I got a nice deal on a bundle - I buy these for golfing and my buddies and I agree it's a nice stick. The wrapper was kind of dry and crackly when they arrived, so I was a little disappointed about that. But 2-3 weeks in the humidor and these were really nice. I would definitely buy them again.
4
5
1
June 11, 2019
Bosco
Punch Rothschild
I like them .
5
5
1
August 14, 2019
Peter D.
Punch Rothschild
I get them every order for 40 years.
4
5
1
August 20, 2019
DELBERT L.
Punch Rothschild
I enjoy the cigar it is a decent smoke
5
5
1
August 22, 2019
John L.
Punch Rothschild
For the price a very good value
4
5
1
August 31, 2019
WILLIAMH G.
Punch Rothschild
O k for economy smoke.
4
5
1
September 10, 2019
Oscar D.
Punch Rothschild
Good smokes burn pretty good price keeps going up
4
5
1
September 12, 2019
MIKE J.
Punch Rothschild
I was a little disappointed with these. The draw is a bit tough and I've smoked about 8 so far. There are some burn issues also. I'll probably try a different JR alternative next time.
2
5
1
July 4, 2018
Greg J.
Punch Rothschild
Tough to draw on some but great flavor and a very consistent burn. I love punch but can't afford to smoke them everyday this is a great alternative.
3
5
1
May 12, 2017
George S.
Punch Rothschild
I have been buying this cigar for over ten years and love it. I sometimes try different cigars but I always wish I had purchased this one !
5
5
1
November 25, 2015
Prentice C.
Punch Rothschild
They were as good as I expected.
4
5
1
March 30, 2020
GEORGE F.
Punch Rothschild
Good smoke at a good price; what else would you want?
4
5
1
August 17, 2020
William H.
Punch Rothschild
good smoke.
4
5
1
March 13, 2021
Lee B.
Punch Rothschild
Good yard cigar for price
4
5
1
May 21, 2022
Thomas L.
Punch Rothschild
Good smoke burns good great value
Smells good. And the flavor is right in
5
5
1
May 25, 2022
Jimmie S.
Punch Rothschild
Always the right smoke anytime of the day at a price you can't beat. A staple in the humidor.
4
5
1
March 6, 2023
herbertrtarlekjr
Punch Rothschild
I've had better alternatives
3
5
1
March 21, 2023
COURTNEY A.
Punch Rothschild
Excellent
4
5
1
March 30, 2023
JIM T.
Punch Rothschild
This cigar is a staple in my humidor. Great burn, construction and flavor. Worth every cent
4
5
1
April 29, 2023
Gregory M.
Punch Rothschild
All the above. Exceptional
5
5
1
June 23, 2023
Mark B.
Punch Rothschild
Can't say great but if I cant get Nub Alternative these aren't bad.
4
5
1
October 4, 2024
Dan R.
Punch Rothschild
Nothing worth complaining about, but will probably never order these again. Very “ meh”.
3
5
1
January 27, 2025
Gordon
JR Nicaraguan Alternative
Punch Rothschild 4.50 × 50 JRPUR
The JR Alternative to the Punch Rothschild cigar is the perfect choice if you’re looking for a really great top-quality premium cigar for much less. Handmade with the long-filler clippings from some of the best smokes in the world such as Macanudo, Montecristo, and Excalibur, these cigars are close in size, flavor, and strength to those big-name brands. Buy a bundle of 20 at JR Cigar and see whyJR Alternative cigars have been our best-selling brand for decades.
Read more
4.50
50
Parejo
Various
Various
Various
Nicaragua
Medium
EMS
Bundle of 20
Retail Price
$87.20
JR Price
$32.99
Member Price
$29.69
You Save
$57.51
Get Up to 65% Off on Select Bundles!
Customers also bought
Some reviewers may have received JR Insider loyalty program points for their reviews.
Click here to learn more about JR Insider.