All Brands  ›  Cigars  ›  Handmade Cigars  ›  JR Alternative Cigars  ›  JR Honduran / Nicaraguan Alternative  ›  Excalibur I
JREX1
4.078260869565217 115
Excalibur I Disappointingconsistent tough draw! Liked the El Ray Delmundo much better! 3 5 1
Excalibur I I found the draw on this to be inconsistent. Some were impossible to get through without modifying with a probe. Great smoke after that. 3 5 1
Excalibur I Tried these and found at least half would not stay lit outer wrapper would peel off hard (like a tree branch in the inside). Read all the pluses but my batch was not worth the price. 1 5 1
Excalibur I Great cigar for everyday when I have the time for a long smoke. Definitely will continue ordering. Agree that there is some inconsistent draw but that's true of others at more than double the price 4 5 1
Excalibur I Been smoking these for years and always found them a good value with consistent quality. I go through about 2 to three bundles a month. Over the last six months the quality has been inconsistent with frequent tough draws and thin wrappers. May have to find another regular smoke. Too bad. 2 5 1
Excalibur I Excalibur number one (alternative) has become very hard to draw. 2 5 1
Excalibur I A good cigar for those who like me are without deep pockets and enjoy a good tasting cigar 4 5 1
Excalibur I if its a hard draw use a wire ...if its 1/2or 3/4 finish we can throw it awaynot a $8.00 cigar 3 5 1
Excalibur I Somewhat inconsistent. Some burn nicely with a tapered ash at the lit end. Others open upon lighting like a budding flower and continue to unwrap as the stick burns. 3 5 1
Excalibur I Good tasting cigar but draw is a problem. Cut 2 off end and fixes the draw. Overall it is a good smoke and to me it is better constructed than a true Excaliber. Too many flaws in the real Excaliber. Buy these off and on and only complaint is the draw. I will continue to buy them but always cut off a couple inches. For the price they are execellant and are long enough that the 2 cut still makes it a good deal. Very good medium strength. 3 5 1
Excalibur I For the price the JR Alternative to the Excalibur I is generally a good deal. Rich full bodied flavor when you have the time to fully enjoy a good cigar. The only drawback to this cigar is the occasional inconsistency which causes it to burn unevenly. This is a great disappointment when you have settled in for a good smoke and find half of it gone because it has burned down one side. It doesn't happen so often that I have stopped ordering them but just enough to be annoying. 4 5 1
Excalibur I Great flavor just like the real stuff! Bundles are consistent overall with good construction and burn. Jr alternatives are an excellent everyday smoke. Can't go wrong trying your alternative favorite! Always worth the money. 3 5 1
Excalibur I the alternative series is a great value. Well made tasty and a good consistent draw. But I don't think the alternative names really mean anything. All cigars of the same size and wrapper seem to be the same. 4 5 1
Excalibur I If like me you have some expensive tastes but a limited cash flow you might like these as much as I. Excalibur I is a tremendous stogie with a great draw full (medium) flavor and consistency. The JR Ex. 1 is close to exactly like the original but it much easier on my wallet. I've smoked them for years and have seldom run into a poorly made one. This is a consistently pleasing smoke always fresh and the price can't be beat. 4 5 1
Excalibur I These are pretty good, but not quite as good as the original. The cigar is well constructed and the draw is just a little tight. I've only smoked about 8 of these so far but probably 4 were just a bit tight. I have a cigar saver that I had to use to open them up, but the flavor is pretty good. 4 5 1
Excalibur I I have smoked these for years and have been pleased with the value. However, the batch that I smoked ( before the batch I have now) had about 5-6 cigars that were packed so tight that they were almost unsmokable. Thankfully the batch I have now smoke fine 4 5 1
Excalibur I A very good alternative. Have smoked many bundles . 3 5 1
Excalibur I Ive previously expressed my dissatisfaction with these cigars, that being said, i must also now give credit when due. Last few bundles have been excellent, restored my confidence. Very good !! 5 5 1
Excalibur I Perfect 5 5 1
Excalibur I While the cigar is fine the service has become horrible. Your order sits for days. You contact customer service and they don’t even respond. I won’t be ordering again. This is not a one time event. 1 5 1
Excalibur I Compared to the name brand, this cigar has a firmer draw. The name brand is not as dense. This cigar lasts longer. Flavor wise, it is pretty close. In some aspects I prefer the jr brand and others the name brand. I will definitely keep buying these. 4 5 1
Excalibur I Great cigars. 5 5 1
Excalibur I Sometimes the cigars are a little old. This time after 2 bundles good! U have to give a few better deals on the alternatives once in a while! 5 5 1
Excalibur I Great smoke for the money.................................. 4 5 1
Excalibur I Consistently great cigar 5 5 1
Excalibur I Nice tasting smoke 4 5 1
Excalibur I First this is not a light brown or tan wrapper. It is not quite a true Maduro but closer to a maduro than a tan wrapper. Some smoke better than others. Overall a very enjoyable cigar. Like the size. 4 5 1
Excalibur I Been smoking these alternates for years and rarely get a bad one! 5 5 1
Excalibur I Strong flavors, long smoke. Might be too much for some. 4 5 1
Excalibur I Unfortunately the cigars were stale; outer wrapper flaked off. 1 5 1
Excalibur I I smoke this cigar regularly. Sometimes they burn very irregularly, but the price is good. 5 5 1
Excalibur I I have bought these several times. The last two bundles have been very disappointing. They are dry and split open when you cut them. I let them age a bit in my humidor hoping they would improve but no. Th shipping from JR has gone downhill. I doubt I will be ordering from JR again. 2 5 1
Excalibur I My favorite JR Alterhative. 5 5 1
Excalibur I Great mellow draw. Even burn with darn few (if any) "canoes" in your bundles. You can't beat this cigar for the price. This is definitely NOT the typical inexpensive offering that you find loaded with scrap fillers. 5 5 1
Excalibur I These are enjoyable. Not as easy draw as the original. I also prefer the wrapper on the original. I have gone through many bundles of these. I smoke these almost daily. 4 5 1
Excalibur I Really good day smoker been buying them for 10 years + 4 5 1
Excalibur I I've long smoked Hoyo de Monterrey Excaliber Churchill's so I was a bit trepidated trying the JR. Brand of these fine cigars. I've smoke a number of them in order to gain a good insight into these private label cigars and needless to say that I'm impressed! From the initial cut and light through the entire smoke I wholeheartedly recommend these cigars as a ready substitute to the Excalibur I's especially if you are smoking at least one a day. I would have given them a five star rating cross the board but there are very minor issues. The draw is normally very consistent but on two of my first ten smokes there was a noticible variation in the intensity of the draw needed to keep the smoke flowing. Very minor but know that this might happen to you as well. The only noticible difference in the construction of the JR is that the wrapper is noticibly darker than the Excaliber. Nothing serious but it is noticible. Flavor is outstanding in comparison to the Excalibur! The real bonus here is the price difference between the JR and the Excalibur! A third of the cost with nothing sacrificed makes these private labels well worth the time and cost! 4 5 1
Excalibur I Somewhat inconsistent. Some burn nicely with a tapered ash at the lit end. Others open upon lighting like a budding flower and continue to unwrap as the stick burns. 3 5 1
Excalibur I Good tasting cigar but draw is a problem. Cut 2 off end and fixes the draw. Overall it is a good smoke and to me it is better constructed than a true Excaliber. Too many flaws in the real Excaliber. Buy these off and on and only complaint is the draw. I will continue to buy them but always cut off a couple inches. For the price they are execellant and are long enough that the 2 cut still makes it a good deal. Very good medium strength. 3 5 1
Excalibur I This is a great cigar for the price. Also want to say that JR is now the only place I shop for cigars. My order only takes 2 days until it's in my mail box. others take over a week or two. 4 5 1
Excalibur I JR Alternatives in any shape and size never disappoint. Gave less than full stars on consistency just because lately there have been 2-3 per bundle that were a little tight. Certainly doesn't stop me from making this my go to everyday stick! 4 5 1
Excalibur I Worst cigar I ever had, Does not burn even. The end crumbles.Hard to draw. Take me off your e mail list as I get too many and will not buy. 1 5 1
Excalibur I Solid everyday smoke 4 5 1
Excalibur I Excellent smoke for the price. 5 5 1
Excalibur I These cigars have a medium strength and a very pleasant flavor. They burn very well and are very satisfying. A good long smoke. 4 5 1
Excalibur I Smooth smoke, burns well. 4 5 1
Excalibur I Up to you Cigar Aficionado's! You can smoke a HOYO Excalibur 1, or the JR's Alternative Excalibur 1. $8 - $10 a smoke, or $2.50 a smoke. I for one have a VERY difficult time telling them apart. I have a 500 Cigar Humidor, and though I have many "Name Brand" Cigars, most of my collection are from the JR's Alternative. v/r Gunny 5 5 1
Excalibur I Always have been satisfied 5 5 1
Excalibur I Well made, easy draw, medium to full body, price is right, a good every day cigar 5 5 1
Excalibur I I have bought these several times. For the most part I like these. Some of them are more bitter than I care for. Some tough draw. Overall I enjoy these. 4 5 1
Excalibur I I order these repeatedly. I am satisfied with the exception of getting a few in every order that burn very unevenly or throw out small bursts of burning ash. But overall a pleasant smoke. 4 5 1
Excalibur I Great cigar at a great price! 5 5 1
Excalibur I Customer service was excellent. I have ordered from JR Cigar for decades and if anything goes wrong they quickly take care of it. Like these cigars, the first 4 broke apart while smoking and JR sent me replacements. 5 5 1
Excalibur I Very good for the money. Every now and then I will get one that is packed too tight 4 5 1
Excalibur I Great smoke for the money. 5 5 1
Excalibur I Lovely cigars thank you 5 5 1
Excalibur I When you get a good bundle, they are a great smoke. Unfortunately, every bundle is not consistently rolled. This review is solely based on the bundle I have now - which is excellent. So far, 14 of the 15 have been great. For reference, I am not a newbie to cigars. 5 5 1
Excalibur I A good cigar for a change of pace. 5 5 1
Excalibur I I normally by Remidos but substitute these when not available. They’re a good alternative. 4 5 1
Excalibur I A good cigar for a good price 5 5 1
Excalibur I Good draw and burn. Nice smoke 5 5 1
Excalibur I It has been so long since the JR Alternative Excalibur I with natural wrap has been available, I don't even know why I keep checking. I have moved on to another source for the size and strength of cigar I like, that is as close to this Excal as I can get. It was a good run..... 4 5 1
Excalibur I Wonderful Smoke. Was disappointed when they were out of stack. I am referring to Excalibur 1 5 5 1
Excalibur I Enjoy the size and flavor. A smooth smoke. 4 5 1
Excalibur I Flavor was what I had expected and the strength was just right , the burn was a little uneven. All in all it was what I expected from JR knock offs. 4 5 1
Excalibur I hard to keep lit 3 5 1
Excalibur I Good Cigar for the price 5 5 1
Excalibur I Priced right 4 5 1
Excalibur I Great 5 5 1
Excalibur I GOOD CIGAR. TASTE GOOD AND BURNS EVENLY. 4 5 1
Excalibur I great price for a great smoke 5 5 1
Excalibur I Great cigar ,have bought since 1973 5 5 1
Excalibur I Great all around knock around Cigar’s this turns out to be my favorite day-to-day Cigar it’s not exactly in Excalibur number one but it’s pretty darn close up and for half the price how can you go wrong 5 5 1
Excalibur I Very nice alternative to the HDM Excalibur. 4 5 1
Excalibur I Excellent cigar and great price. 5 5 1
Excalibur I Excellent 5 5 1
Excalibur I jr has become my supplier over best.jr alter is a better cigarthen the m1 4 5 1
Excalibur I JR Excalibur is a great smoke. Full flavored cigar and really good smoke after lunch. 5 5 1
Excalibur I Very pleasant with good draw, last few orders have been shipped on time and quality has improved. Very happy with purchase. 5 5 1
Excalibur I Very good cigar. 4 5 1
Excalibur I Great cigar. Has a really nice flavor, put together well and a great smoke. 5 5 1
Excalibur I Good alternative Excalibur cigar 4 5 1
Excalibur I A great quality cigar. Has a nice flavor and smokes really well. It's my go to cigar. No overly expensive and a great everyday smoke. 5 5 1
Excalibur I Great cigar. Smokes really good and is well built. Has a great flavor and not expensive. 5 5 1
Excalibur I Nice smokes. Great price 5 5 1
Excalibur I Great cigar and a very good smoke. 5 5 1
Excalibur I Excalibur 1 is always a good cigar. Great smoke and burns really well. Love the flavor and the even burn. 5 5 1
Excalibur I Very good cigar 5 5 1
Excalibur I 1/2 of them were wrapped so tight could not smoke them!!! stay away 1 5 1
Excalibur I Not fresh 25 % of the time I receive a bundle 5 5 1
Excalibur I Good cigar for the money. 5 5 1
Excalibur I great tasting cigar for the price wrapper shreds off too fast 3 5 1
Excalibur I I like this cigar but sometimes the draw and burn is inconsistent. I find it a very good value. 4 5 1
Excalibur I Very good cigar. Like all of JR cigars, they are put together very well and are a great smoke. 4 5 1
Excalibur I Good value for the price 4 5 1
Excalibur I The draw is smooth and long, burn is somewhat uneven on the 2 I've smoked so far, strength is medium to me. I recommend these! 4 5 1
Excalibur I Good price, good cigar 5 5 1
Excalibur I Always a go to cigar. Excellent flavor, put together well and a smooth smoke. 4 5 1
Excalibur I Excellent cigar with good draw and taste 5 5 1
Excalibur I One good one bad. Some difficult to drag. Not consistent . 3 5 1
Excalibur I I ordered. I paid. You shipped. I received. Didn't know I had to take out a full page add in the Wall Street Journal promoting you. 3 5 1
Excalibur I Great tasting cigar 5 5 1
Excalibur I I regularly smoke JR's Gloria Cubanas Cuban. JR has been sold out of them for some time. I only use the Excalibur as a back-up. They are a little harsher. 3 5 1
Excalibur I Excellent smoke. Really enjoyed flavor and burn was even down to the label. For the cost (low) the value is higher than expected. Will get these again! 5 5 1
Excalibur I Terrible cigar. The first 3rd of cigar gives off a fouls aftertaste. 1 5 1
Excalibur I Very good 5 5 1
Excalibur I Good, reasonably priced smoke. 4 5 1
Excalibur I Love it! Rich taste, smooth draw, good burn -- Excaliburs are a great value and my daily smoke 5 5 1
Excalibur I Always a great cigar. Reasonably priced, great flavor, put together very well and smokes great. 5 5 1
Excalibur I Very good cigar for a good price 4 5 1
Excalibur I the last few times i placed my order i was disapointed in the quality of my cigars and also the people working the phones had no knowlage of cigars.i will try one more order and if its the same,back to best. 3 5 1
Excalibur I Had some problems with burning on one side more than the other. I tried to understand if it was the wrap leaf or other part of the cigar causing it? The quality seemed good. I felt there could be more aroma while resting? The smoke was easy and I enjoyed the feel of the cigar in my hand. 5 5 1
Excalibur I I have been ordering these cigars for YEARS! The last order the wrapper was darker - not liking it at all! Very harsh! Tried speaking with Customer service, the woman was RUDE! 3 5 1
Excalibur I The new jrex1 bundles are not nearly as good as the previous ones 4 5 1
Excalibur I I have one of these when I really want to treat myself. 5 5 1

JR Nicaraguan Alternative

Excalibur I 7.25 × 54 JREX1

The JR Alternative to the Excalibur I cigar is the perfect choice if you’re looking for a really great top-quality premium cigar for much less. Handmade with fillers from some of the best smokes in the world such as Macanudo, Montecristo, and Excalibur, these cigars are close in size, flavor, and strength to those big-name brands. Buy a bundle of 20 at JR Cigar and see why JR Alternative cigars have been our best-selling brand for decades.
Read more
Choose the delivery option
Tip: You can cancel or edit your smart refill orders at any time
7.25

54

Parejo

Various

Various

Various

Nicaragua

Medium

Natural

Bundle of 20

Retail Price
$114.00
JR Price
$47.99
You Save
$66.01
InStock

For a limited time, the JR price has been reduced by 25%!

Customers also bought

Some reviewers may have received JR Insider loyalty program points for their reviews. Click here to learn more about JR Insider.