Most Helpful Reviews for Promos
E.P. Carrillo Reunited
Mazo
Mystery Cigars not in box as advertised
ROBERT D.
05/17/2018
There is no box just a bundle of unbanded cigars can't tell who made them or why they were too embarrassed to put them in a box or with bands to identify the maker. Seem to be low quality overruns. Ripoff.
Social Media Collection
Top 5 Oktoberfest Beer Cigars
Oktoberfest sampler Youtube video is misleading in cigar sizes
Nick M.
10/03/2019
All but the Uncharted are Rubudtos, the Quasada is not even close to what shown in the video, and the Cain is a skinny carona way smaller than the BIG BEAUTIFUL cigars in Nicks video on youtube. It does tell you the sizes in the description when ordering. I missed it. Needless to say I am very disappointed. These cigars smoke and taste very different from what was shown in the youtube video. BEWARE !! It's misleading !!!!!!!!!
Promos
Recurring Subscription
Horrible
William C.
01/14/2020
I placed an order and added the Cigar of the Month club. As JR's website states "First order will ship 1-2 days after order. All other orders will ship on the 3rd Wednesday of the month. I received my order and NO Cigar of the Month club cigars. I sent 2 emails with no response. I called customer service and was told that Cigar of the Month gets shipped between the 15th and 18th of the month. I informed them that is not what the website states. I waited 3 weeks later and had to call again, I was told there was a computer issue and my Cigar of the Month wasn't shipped. The customer service guy had to check to see if the cigars were in stock (wonder what would of happen if they weren't) luckily they were and was shipped. When I receive my cigars there was no humidification pack just 6 cigars (I am JR +) in a ziplock cigar bag. I was not impressed in the selection. When the 3rd week of December rolled around guess what? No Cigar of the Month club sent, I called customer service and they have been having computer issues. Since they couldn't get ANYTHING RIGHT including following their own statement of sending the first order in 1-2 days after order. I politely asked the customer service rep to cancel my Cigar of the Month Club. I have since went elsewhere with a new Club and couldn't be happier. I have been a customer with JR's Cigars since 2000 and I can honestly say they are starting to go down hill.
Promos
Leather Cigar Wallet
Cigar holder
Robert L.
06/25/2020
Haven't figured how to use it yet
Romeo y Julieta Crafted by AJ Fernandez
Belicoso
Fantastic
William W.
12/30/2019
I got a box on auction for about $60, so I essentially got away with highway robbery. I bought this for my boss for Christmas because we both smoke a lot of cigars. I hadn't tried this AJ version yet, so I told him the box was his as long as I could try one! He gave me 2, and I'm glad he did because the first one was simply wonderful. The first thing I noticed is that this is constructed like a Sherman tank. It's perfectly packaged, rolled, and sturdy. It lit right on point, burned perfectly even all the way down to the nub. It was kind of uncanny how perfect it burned with my smoking pace. The flavors were not as "rustic" if you will, as the normal RyJ. Kind of nutty, slightly sweet, but still burly overall. Smoked this for about 70 minutes and probably could have gone another 10-15. Short version... can't go wrong with this.
Romeo y Julieta Crafted by AJ Fernandez
Belicoso
Fantastic
William W.
12/30/2019
I got a box on auction for about $60, so I essentially got away with highway robbery. I bought this for my boss for Christmas because we both smoke a lot of cigars. I hadn't tried this AJ version yet, so I told him the box was his as long as I could try one! He gave me 2, and I'm glad he did because the first one was simply wonderful. The first thing I noticed is that this is constructed like a Sherman tank. It's perfectly packaged, rolled, and sturdy. It lit right on point, burned perfectly even all the way down to the nub. It was kind of uncanny how perfect it burned with my smoking pace. The flavors were not as "rustic" if you will, as the normal RyJ. Kind of nutty, slightly sweet, but still burly overall. Smoked this for about 70 minutes and probably could have gone another 10-15. Short version... can't go wrong with this.
Promos
Recurring Subscription
JR CIGAR OF THE MONTH CLUB
Bill T.
07/01/2019
I am a recurring monthly customer and have had issues with order processing, every month this year since April has been a different issue, I never received my June order.
Promos
Recurring Subscription
the beginning of the subscription was shaky
Christian G.
06/08/2020
When I subscribed, my order was never shipped on time. For the first half every month i had to call in and give them my cc information every month. Since then, the last 3 months, it has been on time and i have not had to call. The smokes have been great. I however would like it if you could list the cigars you send. I have had a few i really enjoy but can't find them on your site.
Accessories
Gurkha Skinner Fixed-Blade Knife with Sheath
Gurkha skinner knife
Peter C.
03/23/2020
This is a great piece to have as part of your cigar accessory collection. Don't let the description or MSRP fool you though! The knife is emblazoned with K. Hansotia & Co. on the blade. The handle grips are actually a dense rubber, not wood. It does have a good hand feel. The handle has just the right amount of grip for any weather and the knife is well-balanced. The included sheath is a bit cheap, but sturdy and the knife "locks" into place securely. Overall, a nice knife.
Promos
Tabacalera Palma Woermann
Horrible
Vince
10/06/2020
Unbelievably loosely rolled. Mushy even. Some wrappers have tiny holes. Was a super sale, and still not worth it.
Promos
Recurring Subscription
Purchased, but nothing has come
Tyler
10/18/2019
Still haven't received my order from 2 weeks ago. I attempted to call their customer service to let them know but no one has attempted to call me back for email me back. Very dissatisfied. I expected more from JR.
Promos
12 Month Pre-Paid Subscription
Delivery is spotty and not always accurate
Tim B.
03/20/2020
This is the second consecutive yearly subscription I have bought. I should have learned with the first one. My first subscription, there were several months where I had to contact JR to receive my monthly pack because they weren't shipped with me as well as several months where I received 5 cigars vice 6 as a JR Plus member. As for the cigar selection. I like trying different cigars
