No. 1 One of the first cigars I have ever smoked but still remains a good go to cigar. A bit on the mild side but great for a beginner smoker or for an early morning smoke. This Montecristo No 1 always delivers consistency and quality. 3 5 1 February 13, 2019 Leo D.
No. 1 Mild to medium Dominican cigar. Very very smooth. I prefer the torpedo size to this one but you can’t go wrong with any of the sizes 4 5 1 February 13, 2019 Matthew D.
No. 1 Certainly follows the Montecristo quality control. Well crafted with a consistent draw all the way to the cap. I prefer a bigger ring size but I'll take the No.1 in a pinch every time! 4 5 1 February 12, 2019 Ron M.
No. 1 This is my favorite cigar of all time. I highly reccomend for a smooth enjoyable smoke. 5 5 1 February 12, 2019 Troy B.
No. 1 Easy draw even burn one of my go to cigars when i have company over and i impressed them on how good they are 5 5 1 February 11, 2019 William G.
No. 1 Had a leathery taste to it medium flavor definitely tastes better I prefer the minte cristo espicial more of a conpkex blend but this hits the spot. I would suggest this smoke. 5 5 1 February 11, 2019 Susana M.
No. 1 Nice everyday smoke! Good draw and flavor. Everything you would come to expect from this brand. 4 5 1 February 10, 2019 Thomas H.
No. 1 It was one of the better ones that I have had. Still trying to learn how to get all those flavor notes. 4 5 1 February 10, 2019 Kelly S.
No. 1 Love this stick such a great smoke. Monte is one of my go too. Churchill is my size for this one. The binder holds great ash. 4 5 1 February 10, 2019 Jack C.
No. 1 It’s a Monty what more do you need to know. Always smokes bigger than the price. Can’t go wrong with this one - ever. Smells great burning. Smokes smooth and feels like a much more expensive cigar on the tongue. 5 5 1 February 10, 2019 Jacob G.
No. 1 Nice chocolate flavors with some kick. Really easy to smoke. A little Peppery but a great smoke for a beginner or seasoned vet. 4 5 1 February 10, 2019 John B.
No. 1 A great any time of the day smoke especially if you have a little time to sit and enjoy it. On the milder side of the spectrum. Solid and also a good smoke for newbies and veterans alike. 3 5 1 February 9, 2019 Glen J.
No. 1 It doesn't get any better ! An Excellent Cigar ......A hour vacation to paradise . All time favorite ! You will quickly be converted if you've never previously had the chance. Can't miss ! 5 5 1 February 9, 2019 Hector M.
No. 1 The smoke was an all around fantastic smoke in my opinion. The taste was good along with a great draw! 5 5 1 February 9, 2019 Barry A.
No. 1 Decent stick I enjoy these when I get them but not a favorite. Try them if you get a chance 5 5 1 February 9, 2019 Seph G.
No. 1 Been smoking this brand for about a year now. My go to any day of the week. Highly recommend enjoy. 3 5 1 February 9, 2019 Benny B.
No. 1 I don't think I've ever been disappointed with MonteCristo Cigars. 5 5 1 February 8, 2019 Abel F.
No. 1 I love this cigar and you can get for a nice price if you look well online. Everything about is nice at the very least. I suggest this one as an old reliable! 5 5 1 February 8, 2019 Lawrence B.
No. 1 Roger Moore will live through this cigar! Elegant smoke smooth and mild but flavorful all the way. Flavors come through with a martini or a coffee depending on the time of day. Definitely hints of coffee in this one. 5 5 1 February 8, 2019 Loren W.
No. 1 This is one of my favorite caramel flavored coffee notes with cedar background. Prefer these with coffee 4 5 1 February 7, 2019 Edward G.
No. 1 Strongly suggest that this cigar be given a try it’s very pleasant and an enjoyable experience 3 5 1 November 1, 2018 Cort M.
No. 1 It's a mellow smoke goes good with wine or a martini. I would smoke it again worth purchasing. 3 5 1 November 1, 2018 Latasha P.
No. 1 I really enjoyed this cigar right down until the final drag. Get yourself one today! 4 5 1 November 1, 2018 Clement ど.
No. 1 Good everyday smoke even though I prefer a more full flavored cigar. 3 5 1 October 30, 2018 Carlton B.
No. 1 Can't go wrong here. Great construction and burn overall. Smooth consistent notes throughout. Earth leather maybe a little dark coffee at times . Very nice indeed. 4 5 1 October 30, 2018 JJ J.
No. 1 I enjoy this smoke completely. Great construction and burn. I like ample smoke output and this delivers. Notes of Earth and leather with a mellow hint of sweetness. Enjoyable from cold draw to nub. 4 5 1 October 30, 2018 Jim J.
No. 1 This cigar is a great smoke when hanging on the patio with friends watching the big game. 4 5 1 October 29, 2018 Brent B.
No. 1 Absolutely amazing Cigar from JR smooth crisp great flavors and priced very well. My favorite so far but I am new.. 4 5 1 October 29, 2018 Patrick M.
No. 1 Montecristo's are always consistent they are flawless with a great taste. Really a go to cigar 4 5 1 October 28, 2018 THOMAS P.
No. 1 I truly enjoyed this cigar and the price was right too. I recommend trying this cigar for yourself you'll be surprised as well. 5 5 1 October 27, 2018 THOMAS M.
No. 1 Not a bad stick. Well constructed and does not unroll. Draw is about right with a great flavor. Goes well with a good whisky. Long and even burning. Have heard that these come unrolled but I have not experienced this. Keep this stick on hand for a good after dinner smoke. 4 5 1 October 26, 2018 Fred S.
No. 1 Smooth smoke but mine Had a tight draw the first half.had a good taste and I enjoyed it.would buy again 3 5 1 October 21, 2018 James M.
No. 1 Didn’t really care for the flavor seemed kinda old maybe normally this type are pretty good but I guess they had a off day 2 5 1 October 20, 2018 Mitchell C.
No. 1 I think its pretty mediocre. Def not worth the price. Not one I'd reach for. 3 5 1 October 16, 2018 Chase T.
No. 1 This is a great stick. All of the Montecristo’s are excellent smokes I would highly recommend them to anyone. I will definitely buy them again 5 5 1 October 15, 2018 Martin S.
No. 1 I’ve only had one so I’ll not call this a review as much as just my experience. Mine had a very tight draw down to the last third. Very minimal smoke output. I did get hints of salty earth maybe with a touch of hay. Flavor wise it was fairly boring. 3 5 1 October 15, 2018 Josh B.
No. 1 This was my first cigar ever and is always my come back too I will always love this classic. Perfect in every way and mild for every day if you haven’t had one try them! 5 5 1 October 10, 2018 Andrew C.
No. 1 It's great if it's the original still pretty good if it's the wannabe. Should have changed names by now 5 5 1 October 9, 2018 Ryan N.
No. 1 Smooth draw. Great taste without being overpowering. Nice slow and even burn. A good smoke when you want to just kick back and relax. Highly recommended. 4 5 1 October 8, 2018 ANTHONY F.
No. 1 Classic montecristo flavor that reminds me of the no 3 but is slightly smoother due to the tightly packed leaves that that give a small draw at first but opens up as you go along to open up is full profile 4 5 1 October 7, 2018 Jose C.
No. 1 Had a nice pepper taste. Notes of vanilla and nice tobacco flavor. Good burn and great draw. V Cut this one and it worked well 4 5 1 October 5, 2018 Michael C.
No. 1 Classic taste with a daily price. These should be in every smokers rotation if not you are missing out 4 5 1 October 1, 2018 Anton J.
No. 1 Always a great smoke all around. Great price. An everyday smoke. Always consistent. Great flavor 4 5 1 September 30, 2018 Shawn K.
No. 1 One of my go to stogies. Always quality craftsmanship and taste. Im ordering now. Get get get 5 5 1 September 29, 2018 MARK D.
No. 1 My top two Monte is always a great smoke and they did it again with the no 1 great flavor consistency and all around construction is solid 5 5 1 September 28, 2018 Shawn T.
No. 1 One mighty fine smoke!! Outstanding in every way! 5 5 1 September 28, 2018 Kenneth R.
No. 1 If you're looking for a nice long smoke this is the one for you. It has a nice draw and is well put together for a long ash. Grab one and sit down and relax. 4 5 1 September 27, 2018 Fred F.
No. 1 Not my cup of tea. It had a great draw and stayed consistent throughout. I wasnt a big fan of the flavor 4 5 1 September 27, 2018 Anthony E.
No. 1 I smooth premium cigar with typical Monte flavors throughout. Very well constructed perfect draw a pleasure to smoke. 4 5 1 September 22, 2018 David S.
No. 1 I first tried this cigar on the golf course. I was too busy golfing to enjoy it. My golf buddies enjoyed the aroma. I then smoked after dinner on the patio and only then did i appreciate the greatness of this cigar. 4 5 1 September 14, 2018 BRON T.
No. 1 One of my favorites. Brings me back to some good times with great friends. 4 5 1 September 14, 2018 Terri P.
No. 1 Great cigar and great value. I would definitely recommend this cigar thanks jr for such an amazing cigar 4 5 1 September 14, 2018 Jolonda R.
No. 1 Have not purchased any of these for myself but was given two from a friend. Very creamy cigar. Hints of oats and oak. Stiff stick with a very even burn. Draw from beginning to end 5 5 1 September 13, 2018 Timothy H.
No. 1 The draw is definitely on the tight side but aside from that construction is top notch. Flavors are very mild and bland. In my opinion there simply isn't enough flavor to justify the price. Avoid. 4 5 1 September 12, 2018 Robert S.
No. 1 The taste is quite the same coffee cocoa and vanilla flavours blended in great harmony with a medium tobacco taste 3 5 1 September 12, 2018 Stephanie S.
No. 1 The draw on this cigar was a bit tight but not tight enough to affect the smoke The burn was perfect never had to touch it and the construction was fabulous. While this wasn’t the most flavorful or complex cigar it was elegant and nuanced. 3 5 1 September 11, 2018 Larry H.
No. 1 This was a good smoke as a transition from acid and drew estates. I really enjoyed it and would recommend to others that smoke acid and drewestates and want to try other cigars you won’t be disappointed !!! 4 5 1 September 11, 2018 Josh L.
No. 1 I've tried the number one twice it was okay still in my opinion I prefer the media Noche 3 5 1 September 8, 2018 Marcus L.
No. 1 this is a top of the line cigar. if I had one complaint the other wrapper is not very strong so you have to baby it a bit. other than that. my opinion it is one of the best you can get. 5 5 1 September 7, 2018 Robert S.
No. 1 Montecristo no. 1 cigars are not my personal favorite I like a cigar with a sweet flavor and these cigars don’t seem to sweet to me 3 5 1 September 7, 2018 Whitney C.
No. 1 The famous Montecristo No.1is a beauty that is packed solid with filler tobaccos covered in a gorgeous wrapper. The result is a medium-bodied smoke that offers an impeccable blend of flavors that are sure to please even the most discerning palates! 4 5 1 September 6, 2018 Jake C.
No. 1 Good consistent smoke. Draws very well and cleanly. Very peppery on the retro almost overpowering for me. Admittedly I prefer medium to lightbodied sticks but this one just didn't find my palate well. 4 5 1 September 5, 2018 Joshua O.
No. 1 Good smoke. Consistent flavor stick to stick. Go ahead and give one a try today! 4 5 1 September 3, 2018 Tracy P.
No. 1 Not usually my vitola but the construction on any Monte I’ve ever had has been top-notch. Nice smoke good draw. 3 5 1 September 3, 2018 Mark H.
No. 1 Sure it's nice but there are much better for less money. I find cigars described as woodsy or nutty like Monte and Romeo taste kind of... bad. These #1's also seem to have a rather loose roll which draws real well but doesn't help kick up the flavor. Most folks love these- i would take Punch or Hoyo Del Monterray any day. 3 5 1 September 2, 2018 MICHAEL V.
No. 1 Solid buy and pretty close to Havana's best! I've found these cigars to be very consistent from cigar to cigar from first drag to last....enjoy! 5 5 1 September 1, 2018 Jason H.
No. 1 I received one of these in my Cigar of the month . I was superised of the flavors an draw . Little price for me but I would mine buying a 5 pack 5 5 1 September 1, 2018 RANDAL T.
No. 1 A favorite on poker night. I can spring for the cigars give an excellent quality smoke and still have cash left to ante-up. 4 5 1 August 30, 2018 Scott A.
No. 1 Great smoke The Montecristo are indeed such a wonderful beautiful Cigars & for me the No.1's are one of the most well rounded cigar. 4 5 1 August 29, 2018 Brandon L.
No. 1 Good smoke decent draw really had nothing to complain about did have some awkwud burning on 2 of them 4 5 1 August 29, 2018 Andrew B.
No. 1 Good consistent smoke from Monticrisco. Can't go wrong with one of these. Good medium bodied smoke to go along for any occasion. 4 5 1 August 27, 2018 Josh K.
No. 1 Mild full flavor and super balanced. You can’t go wrong with this cigar!! 5 5 1 August 26, 2018 Eury S.
No. 1 The montecristo no.1 are good smooth sticks with hints of pepper and fresh wood never had draw issues construction is good sometime had to touch up with torch. Overall quality 7 out of 10. One of my favorite smokes 3 5 1 August 26, 2018 Brandon S.
No. 1 This cigar is very enjoyable with good flavor burns even and constructed very well. I would buy more 4 5 1 August 24, 2018 DOUGLAS S.
No. 1 this monty is a great cigar med body very smooth. no bitter aftertaste one of my favorites 4 5 1 August 24, 2018 Scott R.
No. 1 It's my first time trying it. I am planning on buying some more of this. It's has a good smooth toasty good burn out smoke to relaxing for. 5 5 1 August 24, 2018 Deirdre M.
No. 1 Great every day smoke it’s also very consistent no problem Wright the wrapper this cigar can be smoked beth DJs by the everyday cigar smoke 3 5 1 August 23, 2018 Maciej A.
No. 1 I had these cigars about 2 months ago and they we were not bad. Draw and burn were good. 3 5 1 August 23, 2018 JOSEPH P.
No. 1 Great quick cigar. Is a time saver when you want a quick full smoke. 5 5 1 August 23, 2018 ERIK W.
No. 1 Im not generally a complainer but these Montes were terrible. I assumed that the name meant they were of similar quality as the White Series but they are not. They cost less but it was not worth the savings. Worst Monte Ive ever had and pretty poor out of any cigars. Lesson learned- don't by cheap MCs. 2 5 1 August 20, 2018 ED W.
No. 1 I have recently tried another #1 I got in 2004 on my wedding vacation and man o man it keeps getting better and better. A classic smooth medium flavour and a great constancy throughout the 3 stages. Can't wait to see what another couple years will add. 4 5 1 August 20, 2018 Ryan C.
No. 1 First time my son tried these and he enjoyed the blend and aroma - another good product at a Great price with fast shipping 5 5 1 August 20, 2018 Linda K.
No. 1 Smooth smoke with terrific flavor truly one of my top 10 cigars. 4 5 1 August 20, 2018 PAUL B.
No. 1 Great after dinner smoke. Goes well with a nice scotch. Very consistent. Probably my number 3 Monte choice after the AJ and Epic versions 4 5 1 August 19, 2018 Chris D.
No. 1 As with all montecristos you are paying for the name and the consistency. There are better values out there but with montecristo no. 1 you know you will get a good stick every time. 4 5 1 August 16, 2018 Derek H.
No. 1 Not too bad was only my second monte tho so not much to compare it to 4 5 1 August 16, 2018 Shawn S.
No. 1 Over all a great cigar. Monte never upsets me. Not my favorite or go to but id smoke it again. Everything you'd expect for a quality cigar flavor well constructed and nice draw. 4 5 1 August 14, 2018 William O.
No. 1 Its ok not the stogie that brought me this brand... Kinda trailed a bit poor draw id smoke it again just wouldn't buy it 4 5 1 August 14, 2018 Wesley M.
No. 1 I cannot say enough good things about this stick. Especially ordering from JR they were delivered to my door perfectly humidified and I smoked one right out of the box. Smooth fluffy smoke with a creamy sweetness unparalleled in other cigars. There is a little spice in the end to wrap it up. All in all one of the best smokes I have ever had the pleasure to enjoy! 5 5 1 August 13, 2018 JEFFREY P.
No. 1 The Montechristo is the perfect cigar for wine. Has a very smooth pull and flavor. It is not too hard or over powering at all. You’ll love this cigar for all occasions. 3 5 1 August 13, 2018 Phillip W.
No. 1 These is a heck of a smoke. Very mellow but not flavorless! I get a subtle sweetness and easy creamy smoke. Pick one up if you got a couple hours of free time and love easy creamy mild Dominican! 3 5 1 August 13, 2018 Nicholas H.
No. 1 awesome cigar great draw nice mellow to medium bodied cigar I would really recommend these cigars and will be buying more 4 5 1 August 13, 2018 Albert M.
No. 1 This is as good as it gets if the flavor and construction you seek is not here it's never coming. 5 5 1 August 11, 2018 Thomas W.
No. 1 Wonderful mild stick an great with morning coffee... Box worthy for sure I always have in my rotation. 5 5 1 August 11, 2018 Joshua C.
No. 1 Good even burn with a smooth draw. I keep these handy for an after work smoke. 4 5 1 August 10, 2018 Tonya A.
No. 1 These cigars are top notch in every category taste draw and consistency! Will definitely buy again! 4 5 1 August 9, 2018 Jeromy H.
No. 1 Wow this is a tasty treat! Love the draw size full bodied flavor. Burned great not hot at the end. 5 5 1 August 8, 2018 MICHAEL H.
No. 1 A nice mild smoke ! Great for the golf course. A very nice draw that stays lite even when you set it down 3 5 1 August 5, 2018 Ken J.
No. 1 Got one of these from a friend. Had to get some right away. Truly amazing smoke with an exceptional draw and slow even burn 5 5 1 August 5, 2018 Michael V.
No. 1 A cigar that is made very well burns even. Has great flavor and last for hours. 5 5 1 August 3, 2018 GIOVANNI A.
No. 1 The construction is amazing the flavors are mellow but very pronounced smooth creamy smoke excellent overall cigar will purchase more 5 5 1 August 3, 2018 Thomas C.
No. 1 I really enjoyed them maybe the one I had wasn't really good. 4 5 1 August 1, 2018 Paul S.
No. 1 I really enjoyed them 4 5 1 August 1, 2018 Paul S.
No. 1 If not cut right has a rough draw that males it rough to start with. Flavor is good with a nice spice and a very creamy spicy aftertaste. 3 5 1 July 30, 2018 Joe H.
No. 1 By far one of my favorite smokes. Always good and consistent with great quality and flavors. 5 5 1 July 30, 2018 Michael V.
No. 1 Not a bad cigar for the cost. I won them for free or I would of never tried them. Worth the small price for them for sure. 4 5 1 July 30, 2018 Steven F.
No. 1 I received one of these from a friend. Loved it and went out and bought a box. Even better with a small rest. 5 5 1 July 29, 2018 Reginald D.
No. 1 Old reliable comes to mind when it comes to the Montecristo no.1. The draw was a bit snug to start but opened up in the second 3rd. Hints of leather and earth with some spice on the retrohale along with a milk chocolate and espresso. 4 5 1 July 29, 2018 Scott T.
No. 1 A good cigar would highly recommend great draw and taste. Never had a bad one. 4 5 1 July 29, 2018 Nick R.
No. 1 It's a great starter smoke lights well and smokes just as goo has a nice nutty taste and pairs well with bourbon and scotch 3 5 1 July 29, 2018 Mike N.
No. 1 Ty he flavors started with a nutty taste and an earthy flavor snd a little spice towards the end. Construction was decent no real burn or draw issues I did however get some cracking which would have been a non issue if I had let it rest in my humidor for a few weeks. To sum it all up this Monticristo is a real nice medium-full flavor and med body cigar I'll order more. 4 5 1 July 28, 2018 Thomas P.
No. 1 classic med smoke nice morning stick great fishing stick i loved the draw nice and smototh 5 5 1 July 25, 2018 Robert M.
No. 1 Elegant not too bold and refined the popular Montecristo No. 1 is one sexymamma Lonsdale! beautifully assembled and brimming with smooth and creamy flavors lots of fun involved a single for your sampling enjoyment. 4 5 1 July 24, 2018 MEGAN S.
No. 1 This is not my favorite monticristo but it is like my #4. Decent draw and flavor good for a starter. 3 5 1 July 23, 2018 Brian B.
No. 1 I love everything about this cigar smooth flavor great easy draw definitely my go to cigar 5 5 1 July 23, 2018 Rick H.
No. 1 Wonderful flavor in a consistent cigar. Burns straight as a razor is sharp. Not a single disappointment in the whole box. 4 5 1 July 22, 2018 Mark S.
No. 1 There really isn't much you have to say about Montecristo. You're paying for a high-quality smoke and that's what you're gonna get. I prefer the No. 2 but you can't go wrong with any of the number Montecristo line 4 5 1 July 22, 2018 Riley H.
No. 1 I won a 5 pack bundle on your rapid fire and love this smoke. It seams the RJ smokes taste really good. 5 5 1 July 21, 2018 Matt S.
No. 1 Received some 15 year old sticks as a gift. They have been meticulously maintained and are a great smoke. I imagine they are not this good out of the box. I'm excited to get the order of these I ordered for a comparison. 4 5 1 July 19, 2018 BRADLEY C.
No. 1 This is a well made cigar nice draw great flavor I often smoke them down to the stub there a little pricey so try to get them on one of JR's auctions. 4 5 1 July 19, 2018 STEVEN H.
No. 1 Received one from a friend. Had a good draw with leather flavors. First light was smooth and flavorful nice even burn. Second half was a bit harsher than I would have expected from such an expensive stick 4 5 1 July 18, 2018 William H.
No. 1 Just what you would expect. A very good cigar nice draw solid construction. 4 5 1 July 17, 2018 DOUGLAS Z.
No. 1 Great flavor i like the Churchill the most and the flavor you get lasts a long time . These are for cigar lovers like myself and not for infused lovers though i like my infused cigars also. hay notes raw leaf notes smooth tobac feel almost silky 4 5 1 July 15, 2018 Donald M.
No. 1 It’s not too cheap but i always keep one in my humidor! Definitely one of my favorites! 5 5 1 July 14, 2018 Eduard B.
No. 1 Monte says it all. Although it wasn't the best I've had. Draw was great and burn was even. The problem was it was really dry. 3 5 1 July 13, 2018 Scott N.
No. 1 Good classic Montecristo always amazing construction good draw. Flavored is good but doesn't stand out to me. Would buy again if I got a deal 4 5 1 July 12, 2018 Brendan G.
No. 1 I love this smoke. Only a special buy because it is more expensive but well worth it. 4 5 1 July 12, 2018 Emily S.
No. 1 These were decent. I actually got sick after smoking one due to not having ate all day. I tried another and it was a real smooth cigar for a beginning hobbyist 3 5 1 July 12, 2018 Mark P.
No. 1 Very disappointed about Monte Cristo of late. The AJ Fernandez offering in my opinion one of the best cigars around. I love the No. 2 but have not been impressed with others. The White Series is a give away as far as I am concerned. 3 5 1 July 10, 2018 Dan T.
No. 1 Smooth and creamy stick great quality and construction. Everything expected from a Monte Cristo. Would recommend to a friend or acquaintance 4 5 1 July 10, 2018 Justin H.
No. 1 Nice feel between the fingers The draw before lighting it promised a solid smoke. Prefect draw with great flavors. The first 2/3rds provided plenty of smoke although it didn’t have much depth. The final 3rd picked up in spice but also started to get a little hot. In a pinch I would smoke again but certainly not in my top 10. 3 5 1 July 9, 2018 RICHARD R.
No. 1 This is a consistently good cigar. Great Construction draw taste. Perfect for special occasions or when you just feel like treating yourself. 4 5 1 July 8, 2018 RANDALL D.
No. 1 I was not a fan of the flavor. It seemed to be dual but ok draw and burn. 3 5 1 July 7, 2018 Eric F.
No. 1 The Montecristo no. 1 is a fabulously constructed cigar. It has all the quality and consistency you expect for Monte Cristo. I typically prefer medium full to full flavored cigars but when I'm in the mood for something more mild or medium nothing beats a Montecristo. 4 5 1 July 7, 2018 Ryan S.
No. 1 The #2 is always my favorite but a friend gave me one of these to try and I was impressed great smoke for sitting poolside! 4 5 1 July 5, 2018 Scott G.
No. 1 great buy nice and smooth you would want to keep some on hand i enjoy them anytime of the day 4 5 1 July 5, 2018 Robert H.
No. 1 Great smoke perfect construction excellent draw great flavor one of my favorite smokes definitely will keep these stocked. In my humidor 5 5 1 July 5, 2018 Michael E.
No. 1 This is an interesting cigar. The smaller ring gauge contributes to tighter but not unpleasant draw and it also show cases the creamy nutty flavor of the Connecticut Shade shade wrapper. This is a medium body low strength cigar that provides the same easy smoke every time. 4 5 1 July 3, 2018 Ex I.
No. 1 Elegant and refined the popular Montecristo No. 1 is one sexy Lonsdale! Solidly packed beautifully assembled and brimming with smooth and creamy flavors The No. 1 is a masterpiece! The Montecristo No.1 sold as a single for your sampling enjoyment. 5 5 1 July 3, 2018 Jimmy H.
No. 1 This is a very smooth and mellow smoke. Not as good as the white label but still awesome 5 5 1 July 2, 2018 Michael M.
No. 1 It's the most awesome delicious most crisp succulent smoke in the whole wide world must have 5 5 1 July 2, 2018 Jonathan S.
No. 1 I did enjoy this stick it not my fav but it is not bad at all. It went very good with my morning tea. 4 5 1 July 1, 2018 Frank T.
No. 1 Very easy draw. Smooth flavor and very enjoyable. A must have for my mornings on my front porch 5 5 1 June 30, 2018 James D.
No. 1 another monte great. this is a any occasion cigar. enjoyable at any time with excellent flavors 4 5 1 June 30, 2018 Chance M.
No. 1 This is one of my favorite smokes. Very good draw and mellow flavor while still giving some discernable tastes. 4 5 1 June 29, 2018 Matt L.
No. 1 A buddy gave me one to try out on the boat and man are these puppies good 10/10. 5 5 1 June 28, 2018 robert y.
No. 1 Montecristo is hands down my favorite. Excellent draw. Great aroma. Outstanding flavor. Good burning. 5 5 1 June 24, 2018 Chris T.
No. 1 I really enjoy smoking the Monty #1. It has a smooth draw with a unique rich flavor. 4 5 1 June 22, 2018 Jake B.
No. 1 Good smoke very good burn and construction I used a v cut to smoke this stick 4 5 1 June 20, 2018 miguel m.
No. 1 A great cigar Was sitting with enough time to enjoy a good scotch and a warm summer evening the level of cigar as is good as expected. A winner in my book 4 5 1 June 19, 2018 Robert B.
No. 1 Decent stick but nice worth the price in my opinion. Performance and taste are fine. Ok if you get them on sale. 4 5 1 June 16, 2018 Jose P.
No. 1 Great for a bigginer and mid level smoker. Been smoking cigars for years and I still buy them at least twice a year 4 5 1 June 15, 2018 Jason C.
No. 1 Montectristo number 1 is a very delightful cigar. It goes well with a nice whiskey. 4 5 1 June 15, 2018 Jeff D.
No. 1 What a great cigar ... you will not go wrong smoking one of these ...nice flavor 4 5 1 June 12, 2018 Andrew C.
No. 1 I enjoyed this cigar with a nice glass of whiskey. It was a nice long smoke. I would definitely consider purchasing again. 4 5 1 June 11, 2018 John C.
No. 1 Monticrisco makes a great cigar. I prefer the number 2 but if this is on a deal then i am plenty happy with it. 5 5 1 June 10, 2018 James M.
No. 1 One of my favorite smokes. Great flavor and draw. Long burn time and no heat at the end. 5 5 1 June 8, 2018 Kyle C.
No. 1 Tight draw consistent burn flsvor it is a montecristo. Great buy if you get then on sale but try the white label platinum or classic for a better draw and flavor 4 5 1 June 5, 2018 Jeremy E.
No. 1 I love it creamy with nutty and a hint of hickory to me. 4 5 1 June 4, 2018 Joe A.
No. 1 A medium bodied cigar with predominant tobacco flavor with a hint of a cocoa. These for many will become a goto stick with good reason. 4 5 1 May 28, 2018 Vince A.
No. 1 Where should I start? Good medium-strong body cigar bold smooth taste and light flavors almost of butter on inhale. Mixed will with cognac 4 5 1 May 27, 2018 Jacob A.
No. 1 Not a great cigar and definitely overpriced but if you're looking for something you don't have to pay attention to and that's not very offensive this is a good choice. 3 5 1 May 27, 2018 Zander H.
No. 1 Good cigar lacks flavor though compared to other high end cigars. But still a classic. Good to share as a gift. 3 5 1 May 26, 2018 Norbert N.
No. 1 Great cigar but prefer the #2M flavor and taste are consistent burns smoothly with good structure. 4 5 1 May 23, 2018 JOHN M.
No. 1 A decent smoke I like more of a rebuto flavor. It's not bad though. 4 5 1 May 22, 2018 James C.
No. 1 This is my favorite Montecristo I've smoked to date! Pure-light draw was a little tight but delicious with hints of cocoa and leather. The first third was buttery and a little spicy eventually smoothing out and finishing really creamy with some leather notes 4 5 1 May 20, 2018 Kurt M.
No. 1 A smashing good light . It's right on the cusp of medium closer to the bold side. 4 5 1 May 19, 2018 Stone S.
No. 1 Delightfully complex full body flsvor. Burned evenly and had a good draw. Will certainly throw into my rotation 4 5 1 May 13, 2018 Douglas B.
No. 1 Montecristo 1 was one of my first cigars. Great craftamanship and a nice gentle smoke. Not my favorite smoke but definitely a good one. 4 5 1 May 6, 2018 Eric W.
No. 1 Smooth draw consistent burn great flavor. Nutty and caramel like taste with a hint of pine towards the middle of the smoke. 4 5 1 May 5, 2018 Mike F.
No. 1 My number 1 go to cigar. I love to smoke on the golf course and this is my favorite hands down 5 5 1 May 3, 2018 Evan C.
No. 1 I have really come to like the Montecristo lineup and this is no exception. Feels like you're smoking a much more expensive cigar. 4 5 1 May 2, 2018 Thomas T.
No. 1 Dark oily wrapper perfect draw rich medium bodied cocoa flavor. Montecristo has ever been known for making delicious and well-constructed sticks and the number one does not fail in any of these attributes. 4 5 1 April 27, 2018 A C.
No. 1 Montecristo are one of a few cigars worth the high price. I always enjoy Connecticut wrapped with Dominican filler. Everything about this cigar is five stars. Complex flavor mix of toasty grains and tasty nuts. So smooth. Construction is top notch. Burn is slow cool and dead even. Next time you want a treat try one. 5 5 1 April 27, 2018 Marc L.
No. 1 Very smooth cigar love em. Great construction great taste. Very good cigar for the price 4 5 1 April 25, 2018 Richard J.
No. 1 Montecristo is by far an all around great stick . Beginner or aficionado 5 5 1 April 24, 2018 James H.
No. 1 Not a bad cigar. I like the no 2 better. Would smoke this cigar again. 3 5 1 April 24, 2018 Dan M.
No. 1 Good cigar. Not the best Montecristo I’ve had but still a good smoke 3 5 1 April 23, 2018 Joe F.
No. 1 Good quality nicely smokes. Just not my flavor or aroma profile. Although my friends loved the free gifts when i gave the other 4 away at our cigar club 4 5 1 April 22, 2018 Andrew K.
No. 1 I loved it its one of my new personal favorites I can't think of a better one ice had 3 5 1 April 15, 2018 Will R.
No. 1 A good flavorful cigar that you won't want to miss. Good draw mellow flavors can't beat the price on these 5 5 1 April 12, 2018 Vicente G.
No. 1 One of my favorites for a regular smoke. Always keep these on hand 5 5 1 April 12, 2018 John T.
No. 1 Monte Kristoff is a good cigar to have with the scotch and to be around good friends and have a smoke with them it is one of the best cigars to smoke 5 5 1 April 10, 2018 DOUGLAS T.
No. 1 It's deserving of the montecristo name I very much enjoyed this cigar. Not a disappointment at all. 5 5 1 April 9, 2018 Christopher A.
No. 1 It burned a long time and the draw was strong at first then it mellowed out. 3 5 1 April 8, 2018 Gregory C.
No. 1 I'd recommend this cigar to everyone. Great to have in the humidor. Nice smoke 5 5 1 April 4, 2018 Joseph W.
No. 1 Very good! I like the flavor and smell of this one! Burns very evenly and nicely 3 5 1 April 4, 2018 Dan S.
No. 1 Nice smoke. Got this in a sampler but will buy again. Balance flavor. Burned all the way and kept a good ash. 4 5 1 April 3, 2018 Robert H.
No. 1 I'm changing my name to Mr motecristo. I'm just a big fan smooth draw good flavor well constucted. 5 5 1 March 30, 2018 Christopher P.
No. 1 I absolutely love this cigar! A great mellow smoke hints of cedar leather and coffee. A must try! 4 5 1 March 29, 2018 Mark B.
No. 1 Like most of the others non-cuban Montecristo are a terrible knock off of the original. Don't waste your money. 2 5 1 March 25, 2018 Michael L.
No. 1 Smooth flavor good draw and construction. One of my favorites. Try if you get a chance. 4 5 1 March 25, 2018 D F.
No. 1 Great draw but in my experiance will blow up rather quickly and really nice flavor but it was hard to smoke due to the end blowing up 3 5 1 March 20, 2018 Michael E.
No. 1 Bought in a sample pack. As usual good smoke that doesn't break the bank. Enjoy most MC has to offer 4 5 1 March 19, 2018 Lyndi J.
No. 1 very great cigar one of my go to smokes i recommend people to tey if havent 4 5 1 March 18, 2018 Brandon S.
No. 1 Great taste coffee cocoa and vanilla flavours blended well with a medium tobacco taste. The taste is very similar to the Month 3 and 4 it's a classic. I got my first Monti #1 from my mistress. 5 5 1 March 18, 2018 John L.
No. 1 Nicely constructed with a decent draw. Flavor was nice and consistent. Found it great for a relaxing mid day or evening smoke. 3 5 1 March 16, 2018 Jerry S.
No. 1 Its has a nice earthy smell and light smoke body that becomes fuller after half way overall good smoke 5 5 1 March 15, 2018 Jake H.
No. 1 This one was on the lighter side for me and for the price wouldn't purchase again. If i had more of these they would be dedicated for handouts to noobs that only know the name. Just my opinion.. 4 5 1 March 15, 2018 Nazareth A.
No. 1 Montecristo #1 cigars move the renowned blend of well-aged Dominican tobaccos to a compact Corona size; though lighter in the hand Monte #1 is still medium in body amazingly complex and rich in flavor. The CT shade wrapper is icing on the cake imparting a mild sweetness. 5 5 1 March 14, 2018 Vincent D.
No. 1 Great cigar. Lomg smoke and puts off a lot of it. You have to try these. I may buy a box soon 5 5 1 March 13, 2018 Michael J.
No. 1 Monte comes through in a pinch. Awesome flavor and smooth. Reminds me of a walk down easy street. 4 5 1 March 3, 2018 Marcus S.
No. 1 Really enjoyed these cigars of course I have rarely had a bad Montecristo well made and a good smoke. 4 5 1 February 28, 2018 MARK D.
No. 1 I prefer the No.2 over this stick but still a decent cigar. I do keep a couple in the humidor for friends. Great beginner smoke that burns well. 4 5 1 February 26, 2018 Nick S.
No. 1 This is always in my Humidor. Goes great with a nice bourbon or cup of coffee. Sit back relax and enjoy the flavor. This cigar has a great draw. Smooth silky flavor. I've never had a bad white yet. 5 5 1 February 24, 2018 Ernie A.
No. 1 Great smoke smooth burns well. Tastes great from beginning to end. A great medium bodied cigar. 5 5 1 February 23, 2018 MICHAEL S.
No. 1 Great cigar. I've had many of these and they're always good.. Draw is great construction is great. Would recommend 5 5 1 February 23, 2018 Brian G.
No. 1 It's no #2 but still a very good cigar. You can't go wrong with this brand. 5 5 1 February 22, 2018 Travis A.
No. 1 It is nice cigar specially for the construction I just touch one time and for a Churchll it's great the flavor is straight but good and in the last inch kick in my pants xD 3 5 1 February 21, 2018 Maxwell R.
No. 1 A truly magnificent Monte Paired with a glass of wine and great convo good for the price 4 5 1 February 19, 2018 Bryce M.
No. 1 Montecristo number 1 was a wealthy Choice as far as I was concerned. Full feeling after a hard day I'd say pick you up some if I was you 4 5 1 February 19, 2018 Jesse G.
No. 1 Classic monte taste and flavor. Doesn’t change much at all until the very end but the flavor is great. One of my go-to cigars. Never disappointed. This is my favorite from the Montecristo line. 5 5 1 February 16, 2018 Sam E.
No. 1 The cigar has decent profile. It burns well. The taste was good. Hints of cedar and leather 3 5 1 February 15, 2018 CLAUDIO R.
No. 1 The perfect draw of an average stick. Definitely doable on an ongoing basis but nothing to write home about. Yeah I buy them but I buy a lot of stuff I don't necessarily like. I'm funny that way. 4 5 1 February 13, 2018 Gerald W.
No. 1 This is a great mild smoke. These are always consistent in flavor draw and burn. 4 5 1 February 8, 2018 Robert R.
No. 1 What can I say? It's a Montecristo. A little tight on the draw but other than that just as smooth and silky as any other Montecristo I've ever had. 4 5 1 February 8, 2018 JASON P.
No. 1 Mediocre at best. But work if you sharing with your buddy's or don't like to spend money 3 5 1 February 7, 2018 Seth P.
No. 1 Full body near perfect draw aroma enticing one of the best ever don't miss out nutty after taste 4 5 1 February 6, 2018 Joseph O.
No. 1 The benchmark of consistency 4 5 1 February 6, 2018 Patst S.
No. 1 This was the first cigar I ever smoked to completion. This review is biased based purely on nostalgia... This cigar single handedly made me fall in love with cigars. I do not smoke it enough but I still relish the MC1's! 4 5 1 February 6, 2018 Damon H.
No. 1 Solid construction even burn. Keeps well in humidor. Long lasting and consistent. Normally go for robustos but would buy this again 4 5 1 January 31, 2018 Chris M.
No. 1 Looking for a mild yet tasty cigar? Look no futher. Smooth and creamy blend and very enjoyable. Great with a beer or heck even kool-aid. 3 5 1 January 29, 2018 Keven L.
No. 1 Had my first one a little while ago. Was not disappointed. Great mellow flavor with a nice thick smoke. Burned even from start to finish. Would buy again 4 5 1 January 26, 2018 Ben B.
No. 1 Cheap but great smoke smooth and nice to smoke with a nice glass of whiskey. 4 5 1 January 26, 2018 Joe D.
No. 1 This is a very good smoke. Flavorful and a easy draw. Basically everything you would expect from Montecristo. 4 5 1 January 25, 2018 Sean W.
No. 1 I love it it was better than the acid blend I perfer it more than the acid blend 5 5 1 January 23, 2018 Chris W.
No. 1 I found a very smooth and not too complex stick. Took me back to the days of my Navy days when a good Monte Cristo cigar was a luxury while at sea. Smoke em if you got em 4 5 1 January 21, 2018 Donald C.
No. 1 Not bad good flavor and construction. I would definitely buy these again for the price. 4 5 1 January 20, 2018 aldo c.
No. 1 One of the best smokes outside of Cuba. Expatriates farm blend and roll for same product they made in Cuba. Yummy. 5 5 1 January 14, 2018 RONALD N.
No. 1 This is really a brand you can trust. I have liked every monitcristo I have smoked. 4 5 1 January 12, 2018 Lance C.
No. 1 when first drawing from this smoke I detected a hint of oak as well as a touch of spice. Toward the midpoint the cigar burned well and I picked up hints of earthy elements. At the finish it was well crafted with peppery endings. 4 5 1 January 9, 2018 Michael k.
No. 1 Draw was perfect for me. Flavor was alright but wasntind blowing. It went out once but I was smoking it pretty slow. 3 5 1 January 9, 2018 Matthew M.
No. 1 The two that I smoked both had draw issues. One had a knot that worked out eventually the other was a lost cause. 3 5 1 January 8, 2018 Justin T.
No. 1 Excellent cigar. If you haven't smoked this montecristo then your missing out. Draw flavor looks and smells are everything a cigar is supposed to be. 5 5 1 January 7, 2018 Nic S.
No. 1 Good smoke after a long day. Not to strong to enjoy after dinner. Easy draw burns true. 3 5 1 January 1, 2018 CASEY S.
No. 1 #1 Montecristo is number one in my book great everyday cigar with your coffee after dinner or with a round of 9 4 5 1 January 1, 2018 John 1.
No. 1 Very good smoke. Excellent construction. The flavor goes from mild to creamy. For the price this is a great smoke with great draw and burn. 4 5 1 December 31, 2017 Nick M.
No. 1 This was a great little Cuban cigar was my first Cuban it didn't live up to the hype that people say about Cubans 5 5 1 December 31, 2017 Andrew M.
No. 1 I just knew this was going to be an awesome smoke but it turned out to be only mediocre. I had to keep relighting and the draw was indifferent. 3 5 1 December 30, 2017 Cindy S.
No. 1 I really like this style of cigar. Very smooth cool smoke. Not a bad flavor either. 3 5 1 December 29, 2017 Christopher H.
No. 1 One of the first cigars that I had ever smoked. The Monty #1 has been a staple in my cigar rotation for quit some time. Nutmeg earth and spice it's hard to beat this cigar. Well maybe if it was a Cuban 4 5 1 December 28, 2017 Mike M.
No. 1 Caught these on sale and tried them. Very good burn and great taste another must have for the humidor 5 5 1 December 28, 2017 JERRY R.
No. 1 The KING of mild premiums. Montecristo is a name you can count on for the best in cigar quality. Montecristo is a name you can count on for the best in cigar quality. I love this long lasting pleasure of smooth creamy smoke with flavor throughout the party I m my mouth! 5 5 1 December 28, 2017 Adam L.
No. 1 Nice crispy delightful smooth drawing cigar one of my favorites among the very many different cigars out on the market 4 5 1 December 28, 2017 Steve C.
No. 1 Not a big fan of these. Just a mass produced knockoffof a popular Cuban brand. Much better cigars out there 3 5 1 December 27, 2017 Randy L.
No. 1 What can I say that hasn’t already been said about this one? It’s a legendary cigar that lives up to the legend. Just one of the best! 4 5 1 December 24, 2017 DAVID B.
No. 1 The monteycristo number one is one of my favorites! Great flavor and amazing draw. Great classic! 5 5 1 December 21, 2017 Anthony R.
No. 1 Always a favirite these never disappoint. Solid smoke and great construction...enjoyed by seasoned smokers and newbies alike. 4 5 1 December 20, 2017 Rob V.
No. 1 love all montecristos but number 12 was a bit better tasting than white. maybe i have been partial to white but 12 is a great bench player. highly recomend. 4 5 1 December 16, 2017 Dean H.
No. 1 Sooo good one of my fav. Hay smell. Tatse nutty and toasty. Wil smoke again. 3 5 1 December 15, 2017 Paul T.
No. 1 One of my favorites cigars. This is a great after dinner time for relaxing cigar. Robust flavor smooth draw and a usually perfect burn. 4 5 1 December 12, 2017 Marc P.
No. 1 Light in flavor but a good smoke would recommend to any friend or co worker 3 5 1 December 11, 2017 Matt M.
No. 1 Nothing to not like about this cigar. Consistent burn warm flavors easy smoke. 4 5 1 November 30, 2017 Michael B.
No. 1 Awesome stick. Very smooth with a great draw and burn. Definitely a classic stick and one every humidor should have. 5 5 1 November 27, 2017 Tony M.
No. 1 All said it is a well built cigar with a smooth draw and a reliable flavor and nice aroma. It's not one of those sticks you have to worry about consistency. 4 5 1 November 24, 2017 Steve B.
No. 1 When you want to enjoy a great cigar while doing nothing or playing golf on a hot sunny day you can't go wrong with a cigar that domes as well as this on. 5 5 1 November 23, 2017 MICHAEL B.
No. 1 A nice smooth pull with great flavor. I highly recommend as a good cigar to enjoy at any time of the day. 5 5 1 November 23, 2017 Nicholas K.
No. 1 This cigar is excellent. Nice draw. Smooth smoke while hanging out with your buddies drinking a neat scotch or bourbon. I recommend it. 5 5 1 November 21, 2017 Daniel S.
No. 1 Great cigar with a nice smooth draw... A nutty richness that reminds me of a walk in the park on a sunny day.. 5 5 1 November 21, 2017 Gerard C.
No. 1 Great classic cigar for anyone looking for a nice smooth creamy nutty delicous treat. Have a few in my humidor at all times. 4 5 1 November 18, 2017 Dennis B.
No. 1 This is a great smoke for beginners. Not too strong but big on flavours. I would definitely recommend this to anyone. 4 5 1 November 17, 2017 abdool s.
No. 1 Excellent smoke. Warm full flavors. Great for a road trip. I would recommend this smoke to anyone who likes a medium-bodied stick 5 5 1 November 17, 2017 Seth W.
No. 1 I love this stick. It's a great smoke and a good one for special occasions with family and friends. 5 5 1 November 15, 2017 Josh G.
No. 1 The consistency of the draw and flavor is remarkable. It is a very tight roll but has an even draw. The prep and build of montecristo is great 4 5 1 November 15, 2017 Arthur H.
No. 1 very smooth and creamy medium bodied smoke. every monte ive smoked ive enjoyed. great stick when playong a round of golf. not too complex but still tasty 5 5 1 November 13, 2017 Michael A.
No. 1 Just what you would expect from a Montecristo. I only wish I could smoke these all the time but a little too pricey. 5 5 1 November 12, 2017 Jason B.
No. 1 Decent smoke. Not flavorful. Waited 4 months and revisited. Still the same. I've always had good luck with Montes in the past. 3 5 1 November 12, 2017 Preston W.
No. 1 Smooth smoke. I like mine a little spicier but overall a great cigar. Good celebratiin cigar that suites anyone's palette 4 5 1 November 11, 2017 Mike M.
No. 1 The Monte no. 1 has a good flavor works well with beer and food not an overpowering smoke 4 5 1 November 11, 2017 paul h.
No. 1 Just ordered a few more for the humidor. It's a great smoke. I've always enjoyed Montecristo cigars. Some are a little on the higher side as far as price but the quality and taste is well worth it. The No. 1 is a medium smoke and gives out a great taste and aroma. You won't go wrong with this cigar. Lasts about an hour and a half without imperfections. 5 5 1 November 10, 2017 Alex G.
No. 1 Good draw not complex not too strong. Not.mt favorite 3 5 1 November 10, 2017 Randy R.
No. 1 Can never go wrong with a Monte! Excellent construction great draw full of cream and spices 5 5 1 November 9, 2017 Joshzilla S.
No. 1 You can never go wrong with any Monte. I am partial to the number 2 but this will not disappoint. 4 5 1 November 6, 2017 Dewey A.
No. 1 Not so tasty. If u try these do what it takes to not eat the tobacco... Fyif 3 5 1 November 5, 2017 Dave M.
No. 1 nice smoke on the porch or golf course especially with a nice scotch or cognac 4 5 1 November 2, 2017 Sergio C.
No. 1 Good mid smoke. Nice for weekend coffee. Sit out back and enjoy these. Construction is always top notch. 5 5 1 October 25, 2017 Michael S.
No. 1 Creamy smooth flavor and the consistency that makes Monte Cristo a sure bet is what makes this cigar a must buy. Razor sharp ash with nice slow burn. Excellent look. This is not an overly complex cigar bit satisfies the taste buds. 4 5 1 October 25, 2017 BRIAN P.
No. 1 Have neve had a bad Montecito. #2 my favorite but#1 a bar smoke. Mild to medium always consistently good. 5 5 1 October 24, 2017 TIM S.
No. 1 Great cigar my favorite brand. Prefer the #2 but like all Monte 's excellent smoke. 5 5 1 October 23, 2017 WIL O.
No. 1 Had picked one up for a wedding. Just a great all around stick paired with bourbon. Going to pick up some more for my box. Have a golf outing. 4 5 1 October 23, 2017 Jonathan A.
No. 1 I am a novice smoker of 4 months. This cigar lives up to the brand's name. I smoked one yesterday morning. Its smoke is as smooth as water yet super flavorful. I highly recommend it. 4 5 1 October 22, 2017 Matthew M.
No. 1 Too long for me hard to draw at first got better halfway then flavor came out last third.medium gar 3 5 1 October 21, 2017 Tony M.
No. 1 Not a bad smoke. It's a montecristo but with the price tag one would think it would be a little more 4 5 1 October 20, 2017 CHRISTOPHER B.
No. 1 This was a good cigar.i prefer the first half to the rest of the cigar.would definitely try again over time.not my go to 3 5 1 October 18, 2017 Steven R.
No. 1 What more can you say about this staple of the cigar world. Always consistent and always very good. Smooth till the end 5 5 1 October 16, 2017 Peter M.
No. 1 Wonderful stick. Rich flavorful nice draw a pleasure to smoke. Never disappointed with any of the Monticristo. 4 5 1 October 16, 2017 LEWIS H.
No. 1 This cigar is absolutely the best of the best it is what Al Pacino smoked in Scent of a Woman Monte Crisco number one it doesn't get any better than that 5 5 1 October 13, 2017 John D.
No. 1 Great draw and construction. The flavor starts with lots of pepper and spice and mellows to a very light bodied smoke for the first third. The second third changes with every draw paper a little leather and cream. Great summer stick but beware if you are a fast smoker you will have Ash line issues. 4 5 1 October 13, 2017 Mike M.
No. 1 Good cigar but not one of my favorites. Nothing bad to say about any Monticristo. It's smooth and creamy but I need more flavor. 4 5 1 October 12, 2017 Kent T.
No. 1 A nice smooth consistent smoke. Look forward to smoking these again. Montecristo as usual didn't disappoint. 4 5 1 October 12, 2017 Caleb M.
No. 1 Consistent smoke great construction. Nothing like it's cuban brother but worth a try. 4 5 1 October 11, 2017 jake p.
No. 1 These are a very nice cigar.had a good draw and nice flavor. I would definitely recommend this cigar if you have not tried it already 4 5 1 October 10, 2017 James D.
No. 1 There's a reason this one is so popular. Always a go to when I've got some $ to burn 4 5 1 October 10, 2017 Michael R.
No. 1 Nice draw used a PUNCH worked out quite well enjoyed this after a long day at work 3 5 1 October 8, 2017 David S.
No. 1 Draw was a little tight. Would recommend using a punch. Flavor was great. Would smoke again. 3 5 1 October 8, 2017 Kaiti S.
No. 1 I thought it was a good smoke. New to cigars so my knowledge is not professional. I keep looking for great cigars. This is worth the purchase. My New favorite is Rocky Patel. 4 5 1 October 7, 2017 Eric W.
No. 1 So this is my second review so take it for what it is. Very solid construction. Very little flavor on the cold draw. The 1st 3rd is a mild flavor of leather with a hint of brown sugar or caramel. Had to touch up once due to an early canoe in the first 1. Possibly due to my novice toasting skills. As tight as the roll seems to be I am impressed with the ease of draw. Through the nose there is a strong pepper with a sweet finish. Great smoke production in spite of the slow burn.. by the end of this smoke I had to do 1 more minor touch up but can say that out of the 50 or so smokes thatI have had (new to the hobby) this one is the lower 1/2 of the top 10. A great 90 min. Smoke with lots of character. SMOKEMIFUGOTEM 4 5 1 October 7, 2017 DAVID C.
No. 1 I still have a few in my humidor. Its not a bad smoke but for the price of them I'd go with something else 3 5 1 October 7, 2017 Dennis K.
No. 1 This was a great tasting cigar. Enjoyed it with a nice glass of whiskey. 3 5 1 October 5, 2017 Eric W.
No. 1 This one is one of my favorites to smoke on the water with my friends 4 5 1 October 4, 2017 Aaron D.
No. 1 Flavor fit in pretty well with my palate and thr contruction wasnt half bad unraveled a bit but due to my poor cut would definitely try this stick again after a bit of age. 3 5 1 October 4, 2017 Kyler K.
No. 1 Very good cigar. Very mild and mellow great filler and wrap. All around a great smoke..... 4 5 1 October 4, 2017 Will E.
No. 1 I was hoping it would have a bolder flavor but overall I couldn't be mad about it 4 5 1 October 3, 2017 jonathon w.
No. 1 well built as all of them are but a little light on flavor as far as my palate goes. 4 5 1 October 3, 2017 Willie D.
No. 1 Smooth and delicious Monte makes some of the best and this is no exception 5 5 1 October 3, 2017 Michael V.
No. 1 The Monte 1 was pretty delicious. It had a nice mild flavor. Usually not a fan of lighter smokes but I enjoyed this one. 4 5 1 October 2, 2017 Carey T.
No. 1 One of the best smokes out there gpod flavor draw and a good consistent burn 5 5 1 September 29, 2017 Brandon S.
No. 1 Montecristo is obviously an amazing choice when it comes to a cigar. The leaf was very tasty this filler was incredible 5 5 1 September 29, 2017 Tom L.
No. 1 An excellent smoke for any level cigar lover. A mild to medium smoke with a touch of sweetness. Nicely constructed beautiful natural color and an even burn. I highly recommend this one. 4 5 1 September 26, 2017 Nathan L.
No. 1 Decent cigar some had an even burn and some did not. Somewhat spicy flavour as well. 3 5 1 September 21, 2017 Quinn D.
No. 1 One of my favorite cigars is perfect and the flavor is amazing. I love Mobtecristo 5 5 1 September 17, 2017 Eduardo P.
No. 1 I love all the months. This one is no exception great construction medium flavor and amazing taste I highly recommend 3 5 1 September 16, 2017 Andrew C.
No. 1 This is perfect in the morning with a cup of coffee. Last anywhere between 30 minutes to an hour depending on smoker. This is my favorite small cigar 4 5 1 September 14, 2017 Jason D.
No. 1 Solid draw and construction. Very mild body not a lot of flavor. I prefer something with more robust flavors. 3 5 1 September 14, 2017 Brent B.
No. 1 Best cigars I've smoked. Nice balanced flavor. Good draw. Well constructed and always burns evenly 5 5 1 September 10, 2017 William D.
No. 1 Great stick. Awesome consistent flavor. Medium body. Montecristo is always phenomenal. Just wish they were a bit cheaper 4 5 1 September 9, 2017 Jack D.
No. 1 What else is there to say about a great Monte? Classic flavor perfect draw a dream to smoke . Do yourself a favor and grab a box of these bad boys you won't be disappointed. Flavors of cedar leather and just a great smoke for everyday. 4 5 1 September 9, 2017 John W.
No. 1 To start off with this was a really nice cigar the first Montecristo that I've tried. It turned out to be on the dry side nothing that a bit more time in the humidor couldn't have fixed. Draw was perfect and good taste. Would definitely smoke one again. 4 5 1 September 8, 2017 Martti H.
No. 1 Great flavor burnand smoke output. Good cigar to have conversations with over sitting down to really focus on the flavors 4 5 1 September 6, 2017 Johnny G.
No. 1 Smooth sailing cigar's I love every puff making life easy 5 5 1 September 6, 2017 Natasha O.
No. 1 Tried this a few years back thanks to a good friend. Ended up enjoying it on a nice summer day. A nice easy smoke. 3 5 1 September 5, 2017 Jonah S.
No. 1 Overall a nice clean smoke but not sure if I'd purchase it again. Nothing about it knocked my socks off. It's def worth picking up and trying. 4 5 1 September 5, 2017 Jason S.
No. 1 really good for the price. Cheap but lots of flavor. Will buy these cigars again 4 5 1 September 5, 2017 Lisa C.
No. 1 I really enjoyed this stick the flavor of creamy coffee and hint of ceder was nice and the leathery taste at the end I would recommend to anyone 4 5 1 September 4, 2017 Travis R.
No. 1 I love this longsdalea smooth Cuban cigarlong asheasy drawa nice nuty pepperya light earthy backgroundif you haven't tried one you should 5 5 1 September 3, 2017 Mike E.
No. 1 The last box i got i was very disappointed. The draw was very easy at first then half way through it got very gummy and unplesant. I thought that maybe it was just a bad couple of cigars but it happend with most of the cigars. I ussually love montys. I guess it was just a bad group of cugars. 3 5 1 September 2, 2017 Steven M.
No. 1 Dissappointingly mediocre. I had expected a great smoke what I received was 5 mediocre smokes. Burned hot got acrid fast and I didn't finish 2 of them. Great smelling cigars that didn't live up to the hope. 3 5 1 September 2, 2017 Matthew K.
No. 1 The flavor is great but the draw is a little firm for my own liking. It burned straight the whole way down. 4 5 1 September 2, 2017 Frank F.
No. 1 Excellent cigar from start to finish with great draw burn and incredible flavor from this classic. 5 5 1 September 2, 2017 Lourance K.
No. 1 This monte was not as good as others but still it was the type of stick I like: thick smoke cool draw pleasant aroma and taste. Not leather or wood or harsh. 5 5 1 September 1, 2017 MARK B.
No. 1 I have only had 1 of these but I enjoyed it made a nice poker night smoke draw was good taste was good and didn't fall apart 4 5 1 August 31, 2017 Daniel H.
No. 1 Nice taste and good draw nice flavors with a good wrap pretty good I would definitely try again. 3 5 1 August 30, 2017 chris b.
No. 1 I enjoyed the flavors of the #1. Haven't had a bad one yet 3 5 1 August 28, 2017 Eric C.
No. 1 Love love love the montecristo. By far a great top notch cigar. Smokes very well. Need to stock up on these 5 5 1 August 28, 2017 Brian N.
No. 1 What's not to like!? I really like them with early morning coffee. Flavors are great together. 5 5 1 August 26, 2017 James M.
No. 1 One of the best cigars I have had hands down love the smoke and flavor 4 5 1 August 26, 2017 Manuel M.
No. 1 Tried the monte 1 it was good but not my taste i can see other people liking it its a classic great smoke output good draw consistant throughout good burn line and ash held on long. 3 5 1 August 25, 2017 Robert K.
No. 1 This is a great smoke with a smooth draw. This smoke has a medium taste with a woody finish. 4 5 1 August 25, 2017 MICHAEL B.
No. 1 Very smooth nice draw good flavor and an excellent smoke to relax with friends and family. Highly recommended this one to anyone 5 5 1 August 24, 2017 Alex T.
No. 1 Consistently a montecristo. I love them. Half my humidor is monte. It's what it should be smooth simple and consistent 4 5 1 August 24, 2017 Brandon B.
No. 1 This is not a bad stick at all. I enjoyed it throughout and I would definitely purchase again. 3 5 1 August 22, 2017 Chris M.
No. 1 A really nice cigar by Padron that's affordable to smoke often. I don't believe it has the same volume of smoke nor the flavor of it's higher priced brothers but burns well! 4 5 1 August 20, 2017 William V.
No. 1 Smoth well made cigar great flavor consistent Burn great draw a favorite of mine on my days off 4 5 1 August 17, 2017 Don M.
No. 1 Full bodied smooth flavor great draw Dominican cigar that i would definitely recommend to all of my friends 4 5 1 August 17, 2017 Mike B.
No. 1 It is a very mild well-constructed and slow burning cigar. It has an excellent aroma and a lot of flavor. the. I wouldn't recommend Montecristo is a very cigar enoughtaste 4 5 1 August 17, 2017 LokChe L.
No. 1 Smooth and creamy. Great flavor. Draw is usually good. Sometimes you have to battle with one a little bit. All in all a favorite 4 5 1 August 16, 2017 matt g.
No. 1 Typical montecristo build and flavor but this one had pretty severe tunneling with tar build up in the head. Made for an extra tasty stick. 3 5 1 August 15, 2017 James M.
No. 1 Montecristo #1 was a really good smoke if you like a spicy cigar. I liked it paired with a cup of Black Rifle Coffee expresso blend. Go bold with your drink. This is a perfect after dinner cigar. Others around you will appreciate the aroma! I highly recommend this cigar and will buy some more when the time comes. 4 5 1 August 15, 2017 Kaleb K.
No. 1 Long cigar for a long draw. Good for new and old cigar smokers cannot go wing with any Monte. Love this cigar. 4 5 1 August 14, 2017 Katie C.
No. 1 The Montecristo number one was truly a superb cigar. I would recommend it to anyone from an olive smoker to most experience. 4 5 1 August 12, 2017 Joel L.
No. 1 Really good cigar I buy them by the boxes here in town really easy smoke love them 3 5 1 August 11, 2017 Paul M.
No. 1 Consistent and well constructed smoke. Love to keep these stocked in my humidor for any occassion. 4 5 1 August 10, 2017 Ryan V.
No. 1 Very smooth very well structured. Easy to draw. First cigar I have tried and very please with the results. 4 5 1 August 10, 2017 Nikki C.
No. 1 The 5 pack I recieved was good but not great. 2 out of five cigars were a little tight on the draw and struggled to stay lighted. However the flavor was full and delicious. I would try them again hoping for a better quality build. 4 5 1 August 10, 2017 James S.
No. 1 One of my favorite smokes! This is a go to cigar for me. 4 5 1 August 9, 2017 Carlo Z.
No. 1 This isn't my normal go to ring size I was surprised at how good the draw was! These cigars are not normally in my price range for an everyday smoke but somehow I couldn't resist smoking one EVERY DAY until I ran out. I plan on ordering some as soon as I regained my self-control 4 5 1 August 9, 2017 Shelton M.
No. 1 This cigar will take plenty of your precious free time. What do you stand to gain? Only a relaxing respite from a crazy world! Let the delicious smooth flavor of a Monte No.1 work it's magic and be transformed! 4 5 1 August 9, 2017 JIM S.
No. 1 The taste is good and I enjoyed the full range of flavor. Definitely is a return stick for me. 4 5 1 August 8, 2017 Jonathan M.
No. 1 This cigar has a nice draw a great and consistent ash and smooth flavor. Easy to smoke and enjoy with your favorite beverage or just alone. 4 5 1 August 7, 2017 Michael D.
No. 1 Great mild cigar! Good for beginners that are just getting into cigars. Can't go wrong with monte's. 4 5 1 August 7, 2017 Frank P.
No. 1 Theses cigars are a great taste for a great deal. Well made and long lasting 4 5 1 August 6, 2017 Tony V.
No. 1 Montecristo never fails me. Everytime JR Cigars have good deals. I always grab them and always stock up my humidor 4 5 1 August 5, 2017 Roderick A.
No. 1 I was indifferent with this not impressed or disappointed . The draw was goodt until the last 1\4 where it got pretty hot. It's a good cigar but not one of my top ones so far. I don't think that I will buy this again any time soon but would smoke it again. 4 5 1 August 4, 2017 Chria S.
No. 1 I've found montecristos to be mild in flavor but very consistent across the board in draw and construction. Very mild creamy flavors that montecristos have to offer 5 5 1 August 4, 2017 David M.
No. 1 This cigar is one of my go to everyday smokes. The quality is trust through the name itself it's a montecristo after all. For me it's mild smoke consistently throughout. Not a bad smoke at all for the price. 4 5 1 August 1, 2017 Daniel G.
No. 1 These are a bit to long for me. They are robust and burn pretty slow. Need to be able to put a strong puff on these because of their length. 4 5 1 July 31, 2017 Terry D.
No. 1 Creamy and a little woodsy. It's a medium bodied cigar that is good for most but nothing exciting. 3 5 1 July 28, 2017 Chase A.
No. 1 The montecristo no1 was the first cigar I ever smoked. Super smooth great flavour. It has a very nice clean burn that is very consistent. I highly recommend this cigar to anyone. Just starting or seasoned smoker. This is a great cigar. 4 5 1 July 28, 2017 Morgan E.
No. 1 I thought it was a nice smoke. The construction was something I didn't like verry much. But it may be the case this one I had was bad. Definitely worth getting. 4 5 1 July 28, 2017 MILOS L.
No. 1 I was pretty impressed with this cigar from the construction to the way it smoked. I got notes of hay cidar and wood out of this cigar. 3 5 1 July 28, 2017 Jessica O.
No. 1 Super nice construction. Great flavor. Seems to last forever. Would definitely recommend to all levels of cigar smokers. 5 5 1 July 27, 2017 Amber H.
No. 1 I really enjoyed the construction of this cigar. Nice draw in the front end and fairly consistent tgruout the smoking time. 4 5 1 July 24, 2017 Everet A.
No. 1 Top 5 all the way. I really look forward to enjoying a Monte! 5 5 1 July 23, 2017 Brent A.
No. 1 Good cigar not great. Decent construction with a slightly loose draw. Medium body at best. 3 5 1 July 22, 2017 Matt M.
No. 1 This was a good stick to have in your collection if you're new or already in the game. I never did get a lot of flavor out of it besides cedar and leather with some mineral tastes but that doesn't mean it was a bad smoke. Easy to handle very mild body. 3 5 1 July 21, 2017 Brian C.
No. 1 This was a smooth taste. Real easy draw. The build of this cigar was pretty impressive. How many times you get interrupted trying to smoke a nice cigar. Whilst relighting this baby held together brilliantly. 4 5 1 July 20, 2017 Patrick M.
No. 1 Not a bad cigar. The flavor was good and the texture as well I recommend this cigar to others to try 3 5 1 July 20, 2017 Jeremy C.
No. 1 Montecristo #1 is a great smoke. Great draw and flavor. I would definitely recommend them. 4 5 1 July 19, 2017 Trey S.
No. 1 Got one from a friend. Wasnt a bad smoke but ive had other montes id go for over this one. Id give it another try if i had the chance but wouldnt feel broken hearted if i didnt. 4 5 1 July 19, 2017 Alan j.
No. 1 What a great medium bodied cigar. Full of flavor and it doesnt hurt the pocket either. Give it a try because you will like it. 5 5 1 July 18, 2017 Grant M.
No. 1 Overall a pretty good smoke. Monte always is a party favorite. Gotta say I've tried a few better but for a good weekender its hard to beat. 4 5 1 July 17, 2017 Ricardo R.
No. 1 Great medium body stick always performs well and will not break the bank. Very consistent burn amd performance. 4 5 1 July 16, 2017 Leslie J.
No. 1 Great flavors of coffee and cream which are not typical in my experience of cigars of this style. Very good and would not hesitate to buy again. 4 5 1 July 15, 2017 Garrett R.
No. 1 Consistent smoke with a good draw. Well constructed. Not my go to but very good 4 5 1 July 15, 2017 Nick I.
No. 1 Great smoke! Rich flavor with a very cool and creamy smoke! Can be a good after dinner smoke or morning smoke with coffee. The last third has a nice coffee end to it very enjoyable 4 5 1 July 15, 2017 Duvawn W.
No. 1 I thought this cigar had a great draw and flavor. The strength was just right. Overall good cigar. 5 5 1 July 14, 2017 Christie C.
No. 1 Strong but fair not over the top. Solid stock really. Extravagant aroma on ye nose hair and deep dark chocoloto on this thing. Make me want to eat brownies and coffee 5 5 1 July 14, 2017 Manasseh R.
No. 1 I appreciate this smooth and flavor full smoke it's a great morning smoke 5 5 1 July 13, 2017 Adam H.
No. 1 This is the best cigar I have ever smoked like how it makes me feel when smoking it. 5 5 1 July 12, 2017 Agustin T.
No. 1 Good flavor tired before it's done even burn all the way through will smoke again just too dang long 3 5 1 July 12, 2017 Kevin G.
No. 1 Solid smoke. It's a little but harsh at first but it milds out after the first could draws 3 5 1 July 11, 2017 William S.
No. 1 Very very good. Very long in size and alot of my friends and family are pleased with it. 5 5 1 July 10, 2017 Tonya E.
No. 1 Good smoking cigar. Little long for my liking but real good flavor to it. Overall decent cigar. 3 5 1 July 10, 2017 Alex K.
No. 1 Great smoke. Perfect construction but the flavor is just ok. Notting really special about the cigar. 4 5 1 July 7, 2017 Brian B.
No. 1 I used smoke them all the time. I tried one recently and it was exactly the same. I like it when cigars are Consistant from year to year. 3 5 1 July 6, 2017 Matthew K.
No. 1 You can't really go wrong with Montecristo. This is one of the first cigars that I was introduced. I always go back to it. 4 5 1 July 5, 2017 James A.
No. 1 Excellent smoke! Great flavor strong but not overpowering. Insanely smooth. One of the most consistent smokes around. Gets even stronger towards the end but still maintains it's smooth blend 4 5 1 July 5, 2017 RICHARD D.
No. 1 Ovaerall the Monticristo is always great. The most recent one had an issue with the draw early on in the smoke but after that great as usual. I would buy it again and again 4 5 1 July 4, 2017 Bryan H.
No. 1 I am a huge fan of montecristo cigars and this cigar is and affordable medium bodied every day smoke! 4 5 1 July 3, 2017 Bryan C.
No. 1 I really like these Monty's. Good taste smoothe smoke and slow even draw. A regular go to gar. 5 5 1 July 1, 2017 JACK R.
No. 1 Light and crisp. Good cigar to relax and end the day with. One of my favorites 4 5 1 June 29, 2017 Bonnie C.
No. 1 By far one of my favorite smokes. Complex and robust flavor. These cigars are consistent and extremely well constructed. 5 5 1 June 28, 2017 Cody W.
No. 1 I am glad I bought these. Good looking firm and a perfect tight draw. Not too tight but enough to help out to get a cool draw. Almost perfect burn. Easy to find each 3rd. Very good tobacco flavours. Not classic Montecristo No. 2 taste. The ending leaves you with burning fingers and a mouth that wants more. Now on my top 10 list. 5 5 1 June 28, 2017 Zach F.
No. 1 The montecristo no 1 is a really good smoke and a nice and relaxing cigar 4 5 1 June 26, 2017 Dennis G.
No. 1 Great cigar in my opinion there is a reason there is called number one one of my new favorites 5 5 1 June 26, 2017 Victor L.
No. 1 It was a good cigar for the price. Definitely a top one for a newer smoker. Recomond if looking for one. 4 5 1 June 26, 2017 Alex J.
No. 1 Nothing but the best Monte is it always satisfying always good a can't go wrong smoke from a can't go wrong brand try em you won't be disappointed 5 5 1 June 24, 2017 EUGENE T.
No. 1 What can you say about a Monte that hasn't been said. A true 5 star cigar in my book. Great flavor draw and construction. I really enjoy thus cigar on a Sunday watching a football game. 5 5 1 June 24, 2017 JASON S.
No. 1 This was a great cigar. I had to relight it twice because of a knot or two but overall flavor was a rainbow of spices as well as leathery notes. Cardamom light chocolate and coffee like finish. 4 5 1 June 24, 2017 Richard P.
No. 1 The draw was bad. Taste and construction was on point. But draw did it in for me 4 5 1 June 23, 2017 Brad D.
No. 1 Always a pleasure to have one of these bad boys. I've always been very satisfied with them. 4 5 1 June 23, 2017 Melissa L.
No. 1 I have been skeptical about montes but a recent run of good montes have turned me around. This happens to be one of them. Good mild med smoke 4 5 1 June 22, 2017 Ted K.
No. 1 Easily the best Montecristo I've smoked. Smooth draw always well constructed. The flavour is great to the finish and just a little peppery at the end. 5 5 1 June 22, 2017 Tomas B.
No. 1 Not one of my favorites not to good of flavor. Crafted quite nicely but st the end fell apart easily 3 5 1 June 22, 2017 Ron W.
No. 1 You can always count on a great smoke with montecristo. Great flavor. Good draw. Perfect on a warm evening. 5 5 1 June 22, 2017 JAMES C.
No. 1 Great smoke very consistent even burn. I keep these in the humidor for special occasions. 4 5 1 June 22, 2017 Glenn N.
No. 1 I like it it's very good cigar iam not big smokes so I like mini cigar and so far this the best one I try. 5 5 1 June 21, 2017 Amer J.
No. 1 Smooth draw very consistent mild yet robust enough to satisfy. A great 9 hole smoke. 4 5 1 June 19, 2017 Jeff R.
No. 1 I love montecristo period. Every cigar by them hasn't failed me. I have at least 4 of the No. 1s in my humidor. Even burn. Full of flavor. Drink it with your favorite whiskey. Drink it with a Dr. Pepper. 4 5 1 June 19, 2017 Reuben H.
No. 1 Monticristo no. 1 is a great cigar. I have given as a gift many times and would recommend. If you have a change I would say give this a try. 3 5 1 June 18, 2017 Anthony V.
No. 1 Top of the line smoke . Been awhile since I smoked this one . But I do rememer I enjoyed it very much 4 5 1 June 18, 2017 Jason H.
No. 1 The aroma out the box the construction & draw all great:) Creamy with notes of coffee with extra cream. Billowy smoke and simply a delicious smoke as one expects from my favorite cigar brand:) Though Monte Cristo #2's are my all time FAVORITE I thoroughly enjoyed the Monte #1! 4 5 1 June 16, 2017 Bernice U.
No. 1 These are one of my favorite smokes. Not as good as the #4 Cubans but an overall good quality smoke. 5 5 1 June 16, 2017 Justin M.
No. 1 One of my favorite cigars ..smooth mellow smoke..easy draw . Never a hot spot always consistent smoke. What a pleasure. 4 5 1 June 16, 2017 Patrick S.
No. 1 I thunk they are awesome. Quality for good price. I wish I could get some free every once in a while. 3 5 1 June 15, 2017 Eric W.
No. 1 Great stick for the golf course. Bold but subtle flavor. Dont miss out on this one for your monthly stock! 3 5 1 June 14, 2017 nick p.
No. 1 Its a really great imitation of cuban grown and has a very solid all-through burn. I would recommend getting perfectos if you can spend the extra bucks on it as the draw is better. 4 5 1 June 11, 2017 Anthony P.
No. 1 This cigar that I first smoke when I started someking cigar. I love it. 4 5 1 June 9, 2017 Jonathan B.
No. 1 Off the back i tasted a good smokey flavor it had a great draw! Flavor was consistant till close to the end when i started tasting a little pepper! Held together nicely and produce a great ash! 4 5 1 June 9, 2017 Catherine C.
No. 1 Had my doubts about monte cristos. They have not been up to par in recent years. This one is very consistent on its construction. Flavor wise its fairly decent paired with a scotch. 4 5 1 June 7, 2017 Ted K.
No. 1 Decent cigar nice while doing yard work me and my neighbor enjoy them with a bourbon on the patio relaxing 4 5 1 June 7, 2017 Steven I.
No. 1 This is an industry standard for smoothness. The montecristo is a mils cigar with a very consistent smooth mellow smoke. It has great consistency! 4 5 1 June 5, 2017 Stoney C.
No. 1 I've never had a bad Montie Cristo. They always are my go to cigar. At the right price of course. 5 5 1 June 5, 2017 JOE M.
No. 1 These are always a great choice. Burned beautifully to the end without getting any bitterness. The draw wasn't as easy as some but was excellent. My only criticism is that they had a tendency to split the wrapper a little near the end 4 5 1 June 4, 2017 John P.
No. 1 Great smoke. Nice and relaxing. Good draw subtle note a good 30 minute smoke to end the night ! 5 5 1 June 4, 2017 Barry S.
No. 1 Has good flavor but burns to fast. Great for the long summer days and to just chill by the lake or pool with a good whisky. 4 5 1 June 4, 2017 AJ G.
No. 1 One of my favorite cigars. Always get one when I'm on vacation. Great flavor and finish. 4 5 1 June 3, 2017 Mike T.
No. 1 Great smoke with a smooth draw. Light wrapper and not too strong. A great smoke for the avid cigar enthusiast 4 5 1 June 1, 2017 Devin W.
No. 1 A classic cigar. My very first real cigar and one I still occasionally go back to today! Doesnt have as much bite as what I prefer these days but still enjoyable 4 5 1 June 1, 2017 Drew L.
No. 1 A very robust cigar that is very fragrant. Perfect for after dinner smoke with a nice cocktail 4 5 1 May 30, 2017 Jeremy H.
No. 1 Good smoke but the #2 is better...would rather have the Cuban. Hopefully we cam lift the embargo and get a trade deal going. 4 5 1 May 30, 2017 John L.
No. 1 Great cigar good flavor all the way through. Nice long smooth smoke good draw. 5 5 1 May 30, 2017 Matt H.
No. 1 Love this cigar has unique draw with a bold taste reminds me of unsweetened dark chocolate. 3 5 1 May 28, 2017 Jackson C.
No. 1 Very good smoke and reasonable price d enjoyed very much like being in heaven all my friends enjoyed them 4 5 1 May 27, 2017 ROBERT G.
No. 1 Good smoke for a day on the patio. Nice strong flavor with a smooth draw. Second half of cigar is a little lacking ft me dissapointed 3 5 1 May 27, 2017 Scott M.
No. 1 Good every day smoke. Not as consistent as I would prefer. The construction has always been spot on. 4 5 1 May 26, 2017 Robert H.
No. 1 Excellent cigar. Flavor is great and the pull is not bad. 4 5 1 May 25, 2017 vincent h.
No. 1 Fairly good sticks. A bit on the boring side but great construction with a nice even burn. Starts out creamy and turns earthy. 4 5 1 May 25, 2017 AJ H.
No. 1 You wanna know why Richard Petty won all those Nascar races? It's cause he raced old #1! No wait he raced number 34. Never mind. This is #1 MonteCristo cigars! You wanna win? Smoke this! 5 5 1 May 23, 2017 TIMOTHY F.
No. 1 This is my second time smoking the brand and since I only smoke big ring cigars I was very impressed with the entire experience 4 5 1 May 23, 2017 TROY M.
No. 1 This is the first montecristo i ever smoked. A great anytime smoke light body medium smoke output with the nutty. 4 5 1 May 23, 2017 Cam P.
No. 1 The construction of the cigar is not good enough for it's size. All 5 I got unravelled half way down. Not a bad taste just poor cinstruction 4 5 1 May 22, 2017 David M.
No. 1 A creamy smooth cigar a perfect smoke for when you just want to relax and enjoy a tame yet complex stick 5 5 1 May 17, 2017 William r.
No. 1 The taste is consistent and gets smoother as you work down the cigar. it a great conversation cigar that goes well with any beverage. 4 5 1 May 17, 2017 Laura G.
No. 1 Draw and construction on this stick were good had no issues after using a punch. The cap didn't unravel and there were no splits. 4 5 1 May 14, 2017 Steph S.
No. 1 I have smoked this cigar and it's one of my favorites brand. This cigar have a excelent flavor. 5 5 1 May 14, 2017 Miguel C.
No. 1 Love montecristo number 1 even burn great flawless construction with medium body peeper notes enjoy this with a nice bourbon 5 5 1 May 13, 2017 BRENDAN G.
No. 1 I was pleasantly surprised when i troed the monticristo no 1 excellent flavor with a great draw . These cigars have a good constant draw from start to finish. This is a cigar to be enjoyed ny everyone!! 5 5 1 May 13, 2017 Jackie F.
No. 1 This is one my my most consistent go-to daily smokes. Despite the size this is a fairly quick smoke. One of my to 10 4 5 1 May 11, 2017 Matthew D.
No. 1 Smooth cigar great draw and nice finish on the tongue. It is a quality smoke at a even better deal 4 5 1 May 11, 2017 Keith D.
No. 1 I bought a box off of auction few months ago. Very light and smooth draw. Would recommend it. Not the most flavorful but a good cigar for a daily smoke 4 5 1 May 10, 2017 Justus B.
No. 1 This cigar is an excellent smoke. The flavors are delecious. It has an excellent draw beautiful construction and a sweet earthy aroma. 4 5 1 May 9, 2017 Connor M.
No. 1 This stick is one of my favorites and provides a great tast and draw. 4 5 1 May 9, 2017 WAYNE H.
No. 1 Nice long body effortless draw. Even burn with nice cappuccino like flavored with notes and hints of leather cedar and pepper. 5 5 1 May 9, 2017 Jahmal G.
No. 1 Awesome smoke great with a cocktail or wine bonfire a bonus plus the smoke is puffy and plentiful @ 3 5 1 May 8, 2017 Richard B.
No. 1 I really enjoyed this one it was one of the best I have had in years. 3 5 1 May 7, 2017 Jacob B.
No. 1 I'm partial to the #2 torpedo myself but the #1 is great for longer conversations. Besides anyway you shape it it's still a monte. 5 5 1 May 6, 2017 Byron R.
No. 1 Just another consistent smoke from montecristo. Nothing overly exciting but everything you would expect. More mild than expected. 5 5 1 May 5, 2017 Jordan D.
No. 1 Awesome cigar great burn great snoke. It's a Monte cristo part of the top. 5 5 1 May 3, 2017 Edgar F.
No. 1 It was a smooth smoke. Have 6 in humidor now. For first time smokers or women this and will be a come back to smoke. A slow even smoke. 4 5 1 May 2, 2017 Melissa C.
No. 1 Excellent smoke. Great flavors. Clean burn. 2 hour smoke for me. Highly recommend to anyone looking into montecristos. 5 5 1 April 30, 2017 erik m.
No. 1 Decent cigar got in a sampler pack like most Monte still a good smoke definitely age first with some red cedar chips first pops flavor. 4 5 1 April 30, 2017 Elliott M.
No. 1 It was a good middle of the road cigar with a good draw and a good flavor profile. I would recommend it to a frien 3 5 1 April 29, 2017 Mike K.
No. 1 very good for the price. smells very nice to get a lot of compliments. I would definitely keep smoking this cegar. 4 5 1 April 29, 2017 GARY D.
No. 1 Such a great smoke and easy on eye....Im a Fuente fan...but love these!!! 4 5 1 April 26, 2017 sean s.
No. 1 What else can you say about a masterpiece? This is one of the best cigars I've ever had the pleasure of smoking. 5 5 1 April 26, 2017 Sean G.
No. 1 Not as full as I like but still enjoyed. Nice draw & even burn. Would do again. 4 5 1 April 25, 2017 Joseph C.
No. 1 Very nice flavorful smoke good nutty taste particularly if you have some time to sit and enjoy 4 5 1 April 24, 2017 Stanley U.
No. 1 Good draw with a slight woody undertone. Burns great and pots off plenty of smoke. Solid smoke. 4 5 1 April 22, 2017 Elan P.
No. 1 Its a ok smoke i have had better montes got a nice coffee wood flavor tons of foot smoke id buy again for a morning smoke 4 5 1 April 21, 2017 Robert G.
No. 1 Great cigar..... well made. Love it. Fast shipping from this company. Well be ordering again 4 5 1 April 20, 2017 MARC P.
No. 1 This one took about 45 minutes to smoke I really enjoyed the flavor solid 4 out of 5 4 5 1 April 19, 2017 Thomas Z.
No. 1 I've been on a panatela kick and this Monte #1 did the trick. The smooth draw sweet flavor and steady burn are all signs of good quality. 4 5 1 April 18, 2017 Stephen C.
No. 1 This is a well constructed cigar with great flavor and great draw. I usually am a Madurai smoker but I will be keeping a few of these in my humidor 5 5 1 April 16, 2017 William P.
No. 1 Great cigar. Fantastic flavor throughout can never go wrong with a Monte... one of my favorites 4 5 1 April 16, 2017 Gino B.
No. 1 Just bought a box and don't regret it. They can be a bit expensive but still worth it. I prefer to age mine for at least 2 years. 5 5 1 April 14, 2017 zakari k.
No. 1 Not a bad smoke over all. Ive had better but ive definitely also had worse. Would smoke em again 3 5 1 April 12, 2017 Charles W.
No. 1 Great after dinner with a nice single malt. Construction was excellent and consistent throughout. Best to let them settle in your humidor for a couple of months. 4 5 1 April 12, 2017 Richard S.
No. 1 Monte is the way to go! Great stick to enjoy. Picked this up at tinder box a few days ago. 4 5 1 April 11, 2017 Brad B.
No. 1 Love the taste of this stick!! Smoke one every chance i get 3 5 1 April 11, 2017 GARRY C.
No. 1 A very nice cigar mild on the palate. Just a little weak for my taste . 4 5 1 April 11, 2017 RUSS T.
No. 1 Awesome smoke enjoyed the consistency! The flavor was easy to handle and smooth all the way through. 4 5 1 April 11, 2017 Sherman C.
No. 1 Good slow burner a little to strong and harsh bad mouth flavor not a favorite 4 5 1 April 10, 2017 Anthony E.
No. 1 Beautiful looking cigar. Notes of coffee with cream. Nice looking cigar to hold. You won't be blown away by full bodied flavors just mellow smooth consistancy. 4 5 1 April 9, 2017 Chris C.
No. 1 One of my favorite go to cigars. Not too harsh on the wallet. Montecristo is what got me into cigars. 4 5 1 April 8, 2017 Rick D.
No. 1 The draw is amazing burn is even and the taste exceeded my expectations. Went well with Woodford Reserve! 5 5 1 April 8, 2017 John R.
No. 1 One of the nicer smokes I have indulged in and would smoke more but this is slightly more expensive smoke 4 5 1 April 8, 2017 ROY W.
No. 1 This gar was perfect for the golf course. Burned evenly and remained burning throughout the round. I will buy again. 5 5 1 April 8, 2017 Donny N.
No. 1 Was not a big fan of it taste wasn't for me. May try asecond time to see if it was just the one I had. 3 5 1 April 6, 2017 Thomas H.
No. 1 Well it wasn't best cigar I smoked the burn line was really poor the taste was a smokey woody taste that didn't change thru out the whole stick 3 5 1 April 6, 2017 Joe M.
No. 1 Not a bad smoke at all but rather light so if you're looking for a light smoke this will got well for you. 3 5 1 April 5, 2017 Justin A.
No. 1 Have never been a fan of Montecristo cigars. This one was no different for me. I think it is overpriced for the stick. 3 5 1 April 3, 2017 TYLER S.
No. 1 One of the best cigars ever! Smooth draw great flavor can't go wrong! 5 5 1 April 3, 2017 Timothy G.
No. 1 Thus stick always delivers a rich flavor without breaking the bank. I've always felt monte cristos were underpriced. 4 5 1 April 2, 2017 Tommy C.
No. 1 If you're looking for a mild bodied smoke this is the one in my opinion it stay consistent thru our the entire stick! My only problem is I'm not a church hill guy. Highly recommend 4 5 1 April 2, 2017 Steve R.
No. 1 Best cigar I've tried so smooth and. Pleasant . I am extremely please with it 5 5 1 April 2, 2017 Carl H.
No. 1 1 of my favorite Monte Cristo on the market today. A bang for your buck. 4 5 1 April 1, 2017 robert k.
No. 1 I've smoked several Cuban Montes before I tried this. Not nearly as complex and found myself wanting to spit often from the bitterness. There are better choices in the Monte lineup. 4 5 1 April 1, 2017 Richard C.
No. 1 Very coplex and flavorful mild draw well rounded. The Dominican filler and binder make it a nice enjoayable smoke. 4 5 1 March 31, 2017 Zachary W.
No. 1 Very very nice marvelous I would recommend to anybody looking for a very nice smoke it has a very nice hit burned very well 5 5 1 March 31, 2017 Joe A.
No. 1 Are absolutrly great for anyrime great for afterbdinner meals never would have thought they were so smooth 5 5 1 March 31, 2017 Antonio P.
No. 1 Definitely a must try. Great mild flavor all the way through. Not as bold as I prefer but tasty none the less. Excellent construction 3 5 1 March 30, 2017 TRAVIS L.
No. 1 One of my favorites! I always keep at least one in my humidor! But I have to have at least 15 words in this review to get bonus chips so there they are! 5 5 1 March 29, 2017 Jesse H.
No. 1 Bolder flavor. Smooth smoke. I use this one for fun nights out. I get the most comments. One woman came up to me begging to know what the name of this cigar was and said she was ordering a box for her husband right then! 4 5 1 March 25, 2017 Susan S.
No. 1 This is one of the better Montes I've smoked. Paired well with a Macallan 15. Good flavor and draw. The burn was even as well. Will definitely smoke again. 4 5 1 March 25, 2017 John S.
No. 1 Blow me blow me blow me blow me blow me blow me blow with a nice consistency and smooth finish. 3 5 1 March 25, 2017 THOMAS K.
No. 1 The Montecristo NO.1 is not a favorite of mine but it's smooth woody flavor still makes it a great cigar and it will be added to the list of stogies that I would purchase in the future. 4 5 1 March 24, 2017 David G.
No. 1 One of my go to cigars consistent from stick to stick and simply put I always enjoy them. 4 5 1 March 24, 2017 Charles P.
No. 1 This was one of the nicest smokes that I have ever smoked. Smooth and easy to smoke; it felt like I was smoking air 4 5 1 March 23, 2017 BRIAN M.
No. 1 This stick is one that is near perfect for me. The construction flavor and even burn make it an awesome smoke. Was a bit weak in flavor for my taste but excellent nonetheless 4 5 1 March 22, 2017 Steve S.
No. 1 Smooth and mild. Love it on a early spring morning with a cup of coffee. Don't smoke it after something stronger or you'll miss the nicer flavors. 4 5 1 March 18, 2017 DAVID W.
No. 1 Awesome smoke great flavor! Never been let down by Padron binder filler and wrapper are all fantastic. Great blend 4 5 1 March 17, 2017 Spencer L.
No. 1 Pretty nice flavor and consistency nice slow draw but on point I love it with a nice single malt scotch 3 5 1 March 16, 2017 Jeanpaul B.
No. 1 My first Monticristo and didn't really care for this one. Didn't like flavor kind of weak in taste. 3 5 1 March 13, 2017 Shawn E.
No. 1 Was a pretty good cigar overall. It's been some time since I smoked one but you can always expect a good cigar from them 4 5 1 March 13, 2017 JEREMIAH E.
No. 1 Not a flavor bomb but you can rely on it to be a solid stick for the money. Enjoy! 4 5 1 March 12, 2017 Jeremy F.
No. 1 Very enjoyable not normally they type of cigar I go for. I enjoyed every bit of it. I think there are better cigars for the price but i still liked it. 4 5 1 March 12, 2017 Noah B.
No. 1 Smooth draw I've had better though. Nice flavor until the end. Good relaxing cigar 3 5 1 March 10, 2017 KEVIN R.
No. 1 If I had one cigar to smoke the rest of my life this would be it. Always reliable like a best friend. 5 5 1 March 9, 2017 GERALD P.
No. 1 It was a very smooth cigar and shipped promptly. I would definitely buy it again. 5 5 1 March 8, 2017 HARLEE P.
No. 1 Excellent smoke I would have liked a harder draw a bit too easy to overheat. 4 5 1 March 8, 2017 Zach B.
No. 1 This is definitely my go to smoke on the golf course. I also enjoy it while grilling. 4 5 1 March 7, 2017 Ted P.
No. 1 Very well put together cigar the blends was superb had this cigar after dinner and its was very smooth and burned evenly all the way to the end will buy again 4 5 1 March 7, 2017 Sonya H.
No. 1 Slightly earthy taste with a nutty undertone. Burns great and draw is almost flawless. Really love this stick at night after a great dinner. 3 5 1 March 5, 2017 Chris H.
No. 1 Great tasting cigar. One of my favorites. The draw was consistent. Would definitely recommend this cigar. Can't go wrong with a Montecristo! 1 5 1 March 2, 2017 Steve A.
No. 1 Not a bad example of what a Montecristo should be but certainly not what it could be. Plugs seem to plague this segment of the brand and while that's understandable given its popularity it's never acceptable. Check out the '93 Club Cabinet line (if you can find them) -- I recommend the #10. 4 5 1 March 1, 2017 T.J. K.
No. 1 This is a classic go to cigar when you're looking for just something nice for the night 4 5 1 February 28, 2017 Dylan T.
No. 1 The money number one is a great cigar especially if you could let it age for more than a year. The sweet flavors really come out after it sits for a little while 4 5 1 February 28, 2017 Nick P.
No. 1 This is the gold standard for large churchill cigars. Smooth draw. Warm oak notes without a hot or spicy taste. Monte #1 should be a staple in your humidor. 5 5 1 February 26, 2017 Mark M.
No. 1 I bought this on a whim to smoke something with my friends. I didnt regret it had great taste and a smooth draw 3 5 1 February 24, 2017 Carlos G.
No. 1 Well it's a cigar. Doesn't really do much for me. Boring smoke. I think they depend more on their namesake then being a great cigar. 3 5 1 February 22, 2017 Ryan G.
No. 1 Draw was a bit harder than I usually prefer. But burn was razor sharp and good consistent flavor throughout until maybe a slight shift in the last third. Definitely worth the money if you can swing it. A good break from my 2$ everyday sticks. 4 5 1 February 18, 2017 Luke C.
No. 1 The number onebis in my opinion a mild smoke but full of flavor. Its well built. Good starter in my opinion 4 5 1 February 16, 2017 Jiri V.
No. 1 I love me some Montecristo. Classic flavor even burn draw not too tight not too loose. Overall always a fantastic smoke. 5 5 1 February 16, 2017 John S.
No. 1 Over all a good cigar very relaxing and flavor full look forward purchasing some more 3 5 1 February 15, 2017 Juan J.
No. 1 This was a very good cigar with a great job. I would suggest it for anyone. 3 5 1 February 14, 2017 Justin T.
No. 1 Great! Did not disappoint truly quality built cigar can't wait to try out more from this maker 4 5 1 February 13, 2017 Jonathan B.
No. 1 Very nice cigar in which I come back to often. Excellent flavor with a spicy finish. You will want to have these in your humidor. 5 5 1 February 12, 2017 Robert R.
No. 1 The Montecristo No. 1 is a great cigar both in taste and quality. Nice draw and finish. 4 5 1 February 10, 2017 Frank J.
No. 1 This was a mellow consistent smoke. I wish I had a few more to keep in the humi. I would definitely recommend this cigar to anyone. 4 5 1 February 10, 2017 Shawn A.
No. 1 Monticristo never dissapoints. Not the same caliber as their big brother's from Habana are but a very good well rounded smoke. Good burn smooth draw excellent flavor. You wont ever regret toasting the foot of this one. 4 5 1 February 10, 2017 Marty C.
No. 1 One of the classics. Consistent stick to stick. A little spicier than the white label. 4 5 1 February 9, 2017 Greg A.
No. 1 Always a very nice mello smoke. I love the taste and they draw very well. One of my constant go to smokes. 5 5 1 February 8, 2017 TIM C.
No. 1 It had great smoke. Out put great for smoking while bbQing . Checking out hot women in the park. Taste and medium 4 5 1 February 5, 2017 Kam R.
No. 1 I'm smoking one right now. It arrived with some plume on it so I thought I would smoke it first. I am very please with a cigar and I'm really enjoying it. I will definitely buy more 5 5 1 February 3, 2017 Brian S.
No. 1 I tried the money Crystal one and three the flavors were almost exactly the same I found that the longer these cigars set in my humidor the better they tasted Unfortunately they never last long enough. 4 5 1 February 1, 2017 KEN P.
No. 1 It was a wonderful cigar. It burned super even and the flavor was a nice smooth mellow flavor that I think anyone would enjoy 4 5 1 January 31, 2017 Christopher C.
No. 1 Smooth draw with wonderful notes of rich leather any time of day this would be my go to stick also always a great value at JR CIGARS 5 5 1 January 30, 2017 Michael C.
No. 1 These are an excellent choice of cigar I recommend these to everyone who want an excellent smoke for an unbeatable deal 5 5 1 January 29, 2017 Brian B.
No. 1 Full bodiedgreat taste. Great cigar to relax with or watch to a game. Draw is easy and comfortable. A great cigar all around. 5 5 1 January 28, 2017 Karl A.
No. 1 Delicious down to the core well constructed and well balance straight burn and evenly subtle 2 5 1 January 28, 2017 kevin p.
No. 1 Love montecristo cigars great flavor and very easy to smoke you can't go wrong with these or the White series 4 5 1 January 27, 2017 jared c.
No. 1 the draw was a little tight a couple of these Alana like good full flavor smoke. Satisfied customer. 4 5 1 January 26, 2017 SHAD C.
No. 1 If you're looking for a relaxing smoke to leave a crisp complex taste on the palate you've come to the right place 4 5 1 January 23, 2017 Christopher T.
No. 1 I find this to be a good after dinner cigar goes great with an after dinner drink also 4 5 1 January 23, 2017 Jenice W.
No. 1 Great cigar that you will enjoy from the time you light it. Great taste and burn to the end. 5 5 1 January 21, 2017 Andrew M.
No. 1 Decent cigar if you like a milder flavor but still a full smoke. If you smoke more than one cigar a day then this will satisfy you. 4 5 1 January 21, 2017 Bryon G.
No. 1 Was always one of my favorites but a little pricey for me as of late here in eastern Carolina by smooth creamy sometimes nutty with a few hints of leather 4 5 1 January 19, 2017 Mark H.
No. 1 What a wonderful smooth smoke this is. If you haven't tried it I highly recommend it! 5 stars on draw flavor construction consistency and I judge for smoothness as well! It's definitely a smooth smoke! 5 5 1 January 17, 2017 Gretchen C.
No. 1 It's an alright cigar. Kind of harsh and I don't really care for the flavor but my fiance loves them. I can't smoke them. Could be constructed better. 2 5 1 January 17, 2017 Billie D.
No. 1 What a great cigar. Very pleasurable and relaxing. Smooth and mellow no harshness or bitter aftertaste. 5 5 1 January 17, 2017 Matthew R.
No. 1 Always a good quality cigar. Whether golfing camping walking toe dog or whatever it's a smooth draw and aromatic smoke. Monticello does it up the right way. 3 5 1 January 16, 2017 RIC B.
No. 1 Great cigar! Volumes of creamy smoke with a complex flavor profile. Snow white ash that hangs on impressively. Consistent burn with no need for touch up. 5 5 1 January 16, 2017 James S.
No. 1 I love everything montecristo but the no. 1 is one of probably my top 3 favorites from montecristo. Great smoke must try. 4 5 1 January 16, 2017 William J.
No. 1 Montechristo cigars are always a great choice for the humidor Can't go wrong with this cigar on a regular basis. 4 5 1 January 16, 2017 Robert C.
No. 1 Great cigar. Easy to stay lite. Stayed together. Very fresh. Did not taste old at all. 5 5 1 January 15, 2017 Ken E.
No. 1 What can u say about the original Monte! Smooth easy draw mellow. Always consistent!! A go to smoke. 4 5 1 January 13, 2017 FRED R.
No. 1 This Monti is a true classic...never had a bad one...packed with tobacco that just melts in your mouth..a true classic 5 5 1 January 13, 2017 C C.
No. 1 This was a very good cigar to start but gets very very earthy at the end and it was a bit too much for me but I enjoyed the first half. 3 5 1 January 13, 2017 Mike O.
No. 1 Nice draw on this one not tons of flavor but consistent and didn't taste like ash at the end 3 5 1 January 13, 2017 Frank O.
No. 1 As with many monte cristo's the draw and the quality is always decent. Flavor is mild to medium which works with any after work scotch or beer. Cheers. 4 5 1 January 13, 2017 michael l.
No. 1 consistent smoke I always find myself coming back to these. they suit my taste 4 5 1 January 12, 2017 Chad S.
No. 1 Good for a mild smoke. Good draw a little light. A classic smoke from back when I smoked more mild cigars. 3 5 1 January 12, 2017 Jared P.
No. 1 One of my go to cigars for anyone new. Simple and enjoyable not to play down the quality and consistency a great beginner. 4 5 1 January 12, 2017 Richard G.
No. 1 Mild flavor light smoke output. Wish it had more flavor but it was good nonetheless. May try aging one to see if it improves. 4 5 1 January 9, 2017 Tyler P.
No. 1 Honestly I don't think I'd buy a box or a 5 pack at full price. I would however snag a 5er on sale. Decent stick. 3 5 1 January 8, 2017 Kenneth B.
No. 1 Nice even burning cigar good flavor. Mild not to strong . Consistent smoke for a monte. 3 5 1 January 8, 2017 MARTIN S.
No. 1 An absolute consistent cigar in my humidor. Always enjoy lighting one up with the guys. Draw is easy flavors subtle and easy. 4 5 1 January 8, 2017 Ryan M.
No. 1 What else do you say about MonteCristo #1 it is a very smooth and flavorful cigar. I like just about every cigar that MonteCristo makes and look forward to smoking them. The MonteCristo # 1 is a good smoke for a beginner and aficionado's and if you like a smooth or a stronger cigar you can't go wrong with this 1 most will like and enjoy this classic. 5 5 1 January 8, 2017 Joshua J.
No. 1 I tried one it was different them what I likehow ever it had a m9re robust taste 3 5 1 January 7, 2017 Jenifer S.
No. 1 This cigar I didn't like as much as some of the other I have tried. It seemed to come unraveled in the middle a little bit as I was smoking it. The favor was not what I have come to expect from this brand. So over all not impressed. 2 5 1 January 6, 2017 Eric M.
No. 1 I've smoked one of these that I got trading a few cigars with a friend I like the Monte whites 3 5 1 January 6, 2017 Chris C.
No. 1 My first cigar I truly tasted anything other than burnt tobaccoo A whole new experience for a enexperienced cigar smoker. I always have a few in my humidor now. Love the smoke and aroma. Must try. 4 5 1 January 5, 2017 jorge r.
No. 1 Excellent all around smoke. Always consistent. Great monti flavor. One of my favorite cigars 5 5 1 January 4, 2017 Christian M.
No. 1 Very smooth and mellow. Creamy smoke with a bit of nuttiness and cedar 4 5 1 January 4, 2017 Cedric C.
No. 1 Very consistent. I had a good draw with this one. Very good construction. Over great smoke 4 5 1 January 3, 2017 Peter N.
No. 1 Exactly what you would expect from montecristo. Very consistent burn very smooth draw. One of my favorite from monte. 4 5 1 January 3, 2017 Tonda C.
No. 1 I happen to love Montecristo cigars. This one is no exception. It's flavorful and smooth yet has a kick to it. I would recommend this stick. You won't be disappointed. 5 5 1 January 2, 2017 LORI S.
No. 1 The cigars were beautifully box pressed by age and even had a few slight curves each cigar has a rustic appearance to them and the filler is evenly distributed... The smoke had a pleasant taste to it with a rich harmony of flavor to it. I would consider this a medium bodied cigar.. 5 5 1 January 2, 2017 Jonathan T.
No. 1 This is a fantastic smoke. Smooth draw and perfect construction. This is a great smoke for new smokers and experienced smokers. Lots of wood and toast flavors. 5 5 1 January 1, 2017 Jessie W.
No. 1 The no. 1 is a very elegant cigar it has great flavor of smooth drawl that can't get much better. A definite must have. 5 5 1 December 31, 2016 Thadius F.
No. 1 Great smoke. I am hooked on the #2 but the #1 is just as good. 4 5 1 December 31, 2016 Adam T.
No. 1 Nice construction and mild flavor. Not strong enough for me. Would recommend to those who enjoy a mild smoke. 4 5 1 December 31, 2016 Jon L.
No. 1 Good smoke. Wrapper a bit papery but otherwise a fine build. Even flavor thruout the burn. 4 5 1 December 31, 2016 William R.
No. 1 Like all montys this is a great smoke. The draw was excellent and the flavor was not over powering. It has hints of cedar and tastes great from start to finish. The number one is great cigar for any occasion and I paired mine with a meiomi Pinot noir and they complemented each other nicely. 4 5 1 December 30, 2016 BRUCE J.
No. 1 This is a excellent slow bring cigar. From one of the best brands in the business. 5 5 1 December 30, 2016 Mark D.
No. 1 All around great stick from the beginning to the end. Smooth creamy flavor leaving you wanting more. 4 5 1 December 30, 2016 Justin P.
No. 1 Been a little while since I've had this one but I do remember that it was put together very well and had very good flavor during the entire smoke. If you. Haven't tried on yet I would defiantly recommend this one. 3 5 1 December 30, 2016 Travis S.
No. 1 Enjoyed the flavor consistent burn even draw no taste of twigs being burned in it like some montecristos 4 5 1 December 29, 2016 Stan M.
No. 1 I loke these they are quality and montecristo is a name ypu can trust buy from jr a whole box and always get free stuff qith your order 3 5 1 December 27, 2016 James P.
No. 1 This was a good smoke. A bit one note for me as it didn't really evolve for a smoke of its size. A good cigar though if you like mild smokes. 4 5 1 December 26, 2016 Levi L.
No. 1 Great construction and flavor. Not a flavor bomb but so creamy and good. If I was only allowed to smoke this that would be just fine. 4 5 1 December 26, 2016 Colin A.
No. 1 For a daily cigar this has great draw. At times the flavor can be a bit harsh but overall an enjoyable cigar 3 5 1 December 23, 2016 John M.
No. 1 Monticristos always have a flavor that I enjoy. I've only had one of these and my only complaint was the draw wasn't the best. I cut a pretty big hole and I had to drag pretty hard to keep a lot of smoke. Overall nice though. Don't know why it won't let me post this review though :/ 4 5 1 December 15, 2016 Richard G.
No. 1 Great cigar for the money and good flavor. Perfect gift for any occasion or the holidays 4 5 1 December 12, 2016 Tony V.
No. 1 Five stars I missed these cigs after I smoked them. I prolly order some more in the foreseeable future. 5 5 1 December 12, 2016 MATTHEW D.
No. 1 A classic quality smoke. Smooth and mellow. Great for anytime of the day or night. 5 5 1 December 11, 2016 DAVID B.
No. 1 A generic monte. Montes are one of my favorite brands but this one didnt meet my expectations. I will spend more and buy a better one 3 5 1 December 11, 2016 karl s.
No. 1 I love this draw and flavor of this stick. I love the monte Cristo 1 haven't been disappointed with one yet. A very good construction with this stick the notes of flavor are there 4 5 1 December 9, 2016 Kevin L.
No. 1 Kind of boring in terms of flavor profile but good for the price. 3 5 1 December 8, 2016 Matthew T.
No. 1 Not quite what i expwcted but very enjoyable. Great burn good construction and good consistent flavor. I plan on buying these again very soon. 4 5 1 December 8, 2016 MICHAEL E.
No. 1 Pretty good cigar. Construction and consistency are pretty spot on. Good flavors always a good cigar to have. 4 5 1 December 7, 2016 Jeff F.
No. 1 One of my favorites I love the medium to bold richness of this cigar. Montecristo never let's me down. 5 5 1 December 6, 2016 Marshall M.
No. 1 Theres a reason montecresto is know for their quality. This cigar is no exception. Wonder flavor and nice room note. 4 5 1 December 6, 2016 Anna R.
No. 1 This was one of my first cigars. I really enjoyed the flavor mostly just tobacco but I'm a newbie. Great draw no burn issues. 4 5 1 December 5, 2016 Bryan B.
No. 1 Not one of my favorites so don't let my review stop you from trying this montecristo just not a fan myself. I am a newer cigar smoker and spoiled with some of the newer blends and flavors. 3 5 1 December 5, 2016 Daniel C.
No. 1 Really love this cigar. What is not to love? Lovely mellow smoke. Not too strong bit too weak. Great all day smoke. 4 5 1 December 4, 2016 Adam R.
No. 1 Really great smoke. It was a little hard of a draw. After the first smoke I cut the next in half. It did the trick nicely!! 4 5 1 December 2, 2016 RAMSES M.
No. 1 Good cigar. I got one stick I would buy a fiver or box next. Nice daily smoke 4 5 1 November 23, 2016 Garrick R.
No. 1 In my younger days all I wanted was full bodied cigars. 10 years later I tried the montecristo no 1 and am loving the mild yet flavorful smoke. Moderately priced this is a great cigar for the novice as well as the seasoned smoker. 5 5 1 November 23, 2016 Chris M.
No. 1 This is a true classic! Good draw..flavor. ..and consistency. A gentlemans cigar known for its fantastic draw 4 5 1 November 21, 2016 John S.
No. 1 I have always been a fan of the Montecristo cigar both domestic and Cuban. As always a nice smooth great transitioning cigar. 5 5 1 November 21, 2016 Eric H.
No. 1 Fine cigar overall had some burn issues. Flavor profile is similar to other Montecristo's slight pepper and earthy flavors. 4 5 1 November 20, 2016 William O.
No. 1 Nice easy start gets a little more full bodied after the half way point. Well made and consistent good draw 4 5 1 November 12, 2016 Paul C.
No. 1 This cigar is a bit longer than I normally like but it was a good smoke. It had some pleasant hints of flavor that I enjoyed. 4 5 1 November 6, 2016 Eric S.
No. 1 Nice smooth cigar. Perfect for a Friday night relax. Cant wait to try the white series 4 5 1 November 5, 2016 Laura A.
No. 1 Solid nutty flavor with an awesome finish. Hard to put down at the end. I always keep some in my humidor for variety. 4 5 1 November 4, 2016 Charlie R.
No. 1 This cigar is constant every time. Starts mild and finishes strong. Never harsh. Not sure but might be my favorite Monte. 4 5 1 November 3, 2016 JOE F.
No. 1 It was okay good draw smooth taste but I've tasted better I would give it a second chance 4 5 1 November 2, 2016 Joshua B.
No. 1 Great smoke. Slow consistent burn and flavor throughout headed home to pull one out of the humidor. 5 5 1 November 2, 2016 Jonathan S.
No. 1 One of my favorites but it's been quite some time since I've had one. I love darker wrappers they seem to give a sweeter taste. 4 5 1 November 1, 2016 Adam M.
No. 1 Smoke is you have plenty of time. The nutty flavor intensity increases thru the cigar. Enjoyed it on a day outing 4 5 1 October 31, 2016 Michele M.
No. 1 Decent cigar with good flavors on the retro hale. Had no issues with the draw but did need to touch up once or twice. 4 5 1 October 30, 2016 Chris B.
No. 1 Like it's Cuban namesake this cigar looks and performs like a heavyweight champion. Long burn time nice balanced flavors. Can't go wrong with this one. 4 5 1 October 27, 2016 Andrew M.
No. 1 Even though MCs have a big brand name from their CC counterpart they are good smokes. Just don't pay full price and you won't be disappointed. 4 5 1 October 25, 2016 Joey S.
No. 1 Quality cigar. Nice balance of strength and flavor. Can't go wrong grabbing one of these. 4 5 1 October 25, 2016 TIMOTHY M.
No. 1 This is exactly what you would expect from Montecristo. Smooth draw and exceptional burn. 4 5 1 October 24, 2016 Michael O.
No. 1 Great cigar nice draw burned even down to the nub however for the money I prefer the Jr Alternative 4 5 1 October 23, 2016 MANDY W.
No. 1 What an awesome full flavor smoke. Perfect draw and burn all the way to the stub. A favorite stogie that's well worth the price. 5 5 1 October 22, 2016 Skip D.
No. 1 How can you go wrong with a Montecristo? Always a great smoke. But if you're budget conscious...you can also try the JR alternative without much compromise in taste but a better bargain 4 5 1 October 21, 2016 MICHAEL C.
No. 1 Best cigar I have had so far draw was great and it doesn't burn up fast I think everyone should try them i think u too will like them 5 5 1 October 21, 2016 monte S.
No. 1 It is a pretty decent smoke. I have had better. For the price it can not be beat. 3 5 1 October 21, 2016 Joshua B.
No. 1 Wow what can I say? This amazing cigar always has me coming back to it. Montecristo is always top notch. 5 5 1 October 20, 2016 Luis T.
No. 1 This was a nice smoke. Milder flavor than I normally smoke but definitely enjoyable! 4 5 1 October 20, 2016 Marc E.
No. 1 Smooth smoke from start to finish. Great consistency and good smoke time. Solid beginner cigar. 3 5 1 October 17, 2016 Jonathan K.
No. 1 Not a bad cigar. Pretty well constructed and pretty good taste. Burned pretty evenly and lasted a good length of time. Would definitely buy them again. 3 5 1 October 16, 2016 Justin P.
No. 1 One of my favorite brands. I prefer the white series but this is by no means a bad cigar. Would recommend montecristo to anyone. 4 5 1 October 14, 2016 Frederik C.
No. 1 Good light bodied cigar. Has a smooth taste smooth draw. Burns well. Towards the end you can get a bit of pepper. 4 5 1 October 14, 2016 Richard S.
No. 1 This is a decent cigar definitely not one of my favorites but if a cheap sale is on I don't mind it. 3 5 1 October 14, 2016 Michael H.
No. 1 It was pretty good. Good consistent creamy flavors throughout. Burn was sharp too. There. 15 words. 4 5 1 October 14, 2016 CHARLES B.
No. 1 It was a consistent smoke with flavor very smooth and tastful and paired great with tenn honey whiskey. 3 5 1 October 13, 2016 Edward B.
No. 1 By far one of my favorite!!!! A smoke that can be enjoyed anywhere anytime! I highly recommend this to anyone novice or experienced smoker! 4 5 1 October 13, 2016 Andrew H.
No. 1 Mold body with mold strength. A solid choice for a novice smoker. Not a lot of transitions going on but not bad. 2 5 1 October 13, 2016 Nick B.
No. 1 Its a Monte. There isn't a bad thing that can be said about this stick. It looks great and its a great smoke. 5 5 1 October 12, 2016 Randall E.
No. 1 Very mellow cigar with great teaser taste. Very nice bodied. Great to try and Mix and match. definitely recommend to anyone looking for a mellow cigar. 5 5 1 October 10, 2016 Bryan R.
No. 1 Great cigar. One of my favorites. Can have this cigar with any drink. A must smoke for any cigar smoker 5 5 1 October 10, 2016 david g.
No. 1 This is a very good stick. Very good draw and flavor profile. I would recommend it. 4 5 1 October 10, 2016 Paul L.
No. 1 The #1 is a smooth smoke that is not too harsh on the pallet. Cubanesque flavor profile with not too many transitions. A mild to medium body with no strength 3 5 1 October 9, 2016 Paul L.
No. 1 What an awesome smoke full flavor range. Would definetaly recommend to anyone. Buyem and enjoyem 4 5 1 October 9, 2016 CoachKevin C.
No. 1 Whether you're playing a game of golf with old friends. Or sitting at home relaxing with some 18 year old scotch this is a cigar that goes with any occasion. 5 5 1 October 9, 2016 Eric T.
No. 1 Usually keep a few of these in my humi! 5 5 1 October 8, 2016 Joshua H.
No. 1 I was lucky to get an older montecristo 1 from my father as he got a deal on them from Jr's. This is one of the first cigars I really enjoyed and I remember it tasting leathery and was a smooth smoke. 4 5 1 October 8, 2016 Brittany S.
No. 1 Pretty good stick easy to draw and good flavor notes when you get a quarter to halfway through it. Would have it again when relaxing and having a drink 4 5 1 October 6, 2016 Miguel P.
No. 1 Monte Cristo are good cigars..the draw wasn't too great but the flavor was nice and smothered. 3 5 1 October 5, 2016 David C.
No. 1 This is a tightly packed cigar it took a lot of pull to get this started. The flavor was pretty good but the difficulty pulling was a distraction 3 5 1 October 3, 2016 Brett M.
No. 1 One of the first brands I explored back in the day. They make good cigars. Doesn't disappoint. 4 5 1 September 30, 2016 BRIAN D.
No. 1 Montecristo never disappoints me. I absolutely love the flavor and is one of my favorites. It burns evenly and draw is great. You will not be disappointed. 5 5 1 September 30, 2016 Anthony U.
No. 1 Probably the perfect cigar.great draw flavored and construction. Can't go wrong with this section. It's a good excuse to spend a little extra. 5 5 1 September 30, 2016 Jarrad W.
No. 1 Monte cristo cigar was the very first cigar that I have ever smoked and I loved it very much so. 5 5 1 September 29, 2016 Pat D.
No. 1 Way to lite for me. This is a newb cigar. Very mild. Coffee in the morning cigar. 3 5 1 September 28, 2016 David L.
No. 1 Montecristo never disappoints classic brand and great cigar. Pick some up and enjoy the smoke 4 5 1 September 27, 2016 Anthony C.
No. 1 Great draw and consistency along with construction. Just not my cup of tea. Pretty mild with little flavor.. 4 5 1 September 23, 2016 Zachary R.
No. 1 I love both this and the No. 2 both well crafted and great smoking cigars. 5 5 1 September 23, 2016 A C.
No. 1 These are one of my favorite cigars amazing pull and great construction all around great cigar 4 5 1 September 20, 2016 Luis M.
No. 1 Great stick smooth draw and well constructed. Notes of pepper and spice with bus if cream 4 5 1 September 18, 2016 Aric D.
No. 1 Great cigar good draw nice flavor and consistent. I like them when I'm golfing. It will last a long time 4 5 1 September 18, 2016 Jason W.
No. 1 This cigar is flavored and has a smooth draw it's a great cigar to unwind it 1 of my favorites 4 5 1 September 18, 2016 JusSo W.
No. 1 Montecristos are by far one of my favorites. They draw perfectly. They aroma is spectacular and the flavor is one in a million. 5 5 1 September 18, 2016 Adam M.
No. 1 Got this in a sampler and loved it. Good flavor medium body and food draw 5 5 1 September 17, 2016 Robert G.
No. 1 Fantastic cigar it's probably one of the best ones I've smoked highly recommend 3 5 1 September 17, 2016 Nick M.
No. 1 My go to cigars when enjoying a dram of macallan. Can't go wrong with this classic cigar. Smoothe and enjoyable 5 5 1 September 17, 2016 Tim S.
No. 1 An amazing smoke! Had the Cuban while in Jamaica. Flavorful and a nice draw. Definitely worth the price. 4 5 1 September 15, 2016 Nicholas P.
No. 1 Montecristo No 1 i smoke on my weding!!! My wife by for me in one tabaco shop in Belgrade and make me happy! 5 5 1 September 14, 2016 Goran D.
No. 1 Not a dark cigar lighter and more sweet . Burned for a while and the draw was not bad however began to fall apart by the end. 3 5 1 September 13, 2016 Joe N.
No. 1 Great cigar delivers a low hint of spice paired with cocoa leather and nut for a truly great flavor combo 4 5 1 September 13, 2016 Tony P.
No. 1 Good smoke nice notes throw out not what I expected from this stick 4 5 1 September 11, 2016 Niko S.
No. 1 Ģreat cigar from beginning to end. Highly recommended for a relaxing evening! 4 5 1 September 9, 2016 Camron H.
No. 1 This is a good call any time Very well constructed The whole box smoked consistently eell 4 5 1 September 9, 2016 Stephen S.
No. 1 Great cigar one of my favorites to smoke when I'm on the back porch relaxing. 4 5 1 September 8, 2016 Jose Z.
No. 1 With a bit of a tight draw the flavor notes are sure to please with a creamy nutty start. The full experience is yet to come. The draw becomes nice with an Earthy Carmel with nodes of spices and finishes with a smooth and consistent burn to the nub. I have a serious Love for this cigar and recommend it often. 4 5 1 September 7, 2016 Michael S.
No. 1 Great cigar if you're looking to impress your buddies during a poker game definetly wanna set aside some time to smoke this bad boy 4 5 1 September 7, 2016 Trey K.
No. 1 I'm a huge Montechristo fan and that's because everything they make is good. The No. 1 is no exception. GREAT flavor and a long smoke which is one thing I love the most about MC. Very fun smoke 4 5 1 September 7, 2016 Anthony P.
No. 1 Boring cigar. Everyone has had them but most don't come back for seconds 3 5 1 September 4, 2016 Zach B.
No. 1 This is definitely one of my favorites now . Got some from my local shop and loved it from the first puff 5 5 1 September 3, 2016 Luis Z.
No. 1 My all-time favorite. Consistent all the way through with great draw perfect burn and a great luxurious taste all the way to the finish 5 5 1 September 3, 2016 George A.
No. 1 Great draw with sweet tobacco taste. Retrohale and you get undertones of almonds and oak. Leaf construction was good unraveled a bit towards the end. 4 5 1 September 2, 2016 Severo V.
No. 1 I'm a big fan of this silky looking cigar. Will continue to smoke over and over. Nice 5 5 1 September 1, 2016 DANIEL T.
No. 1 Great and improves with age. Rich flavorful hint of cedar & cocao. Nice smoke with or without congac. Holds up well good solid performer. 4 5 1 August 31, 2016 DANIEL H.
No. 1 Nice wrapper Slight hints of Wood with faint coffe creme and cocoa would smoke this at a golf course or a gifting cigar to hand out to those you don't like. 3 5 1 August 31, 2016 Irving G.
No. 1 All time favorite brand of cigars. Have not had one bad montecristo. White series is still my all time favorite but no. 1 is still a great mild to strong smoke. If you don't have montecristo in your humidor you're doing it wrong! 5 5 1 August 31, 2016 Kevin D.
No. 1 This is a really good cigar from montecristo. While I enjoy the white vintage Connecticut more this was still a very good smoke 4 5 1 August 30, 2016 Dan S.
No. 1 Loved this cigar. Not as good as the original but close. I noticed leather and wood as well as a slight white pepper. 4 5 1 August 30, 2016 Rob J.
No. 1 Enjoyed this cigar with a nice IPA and I was not disappointed at all. Great draw and good strength. Give it a go you'll enjoy the smoke. 3 5 1 August 29, 2016 Daniel S.
No. 1 One of the best cigars I ever had. A must have in my humidor at all times. 5 5 1 August 29, 2016 Kanorris S.
No. 1 Not at all saying this monte isnt a good solid smoke but for the money you can get better. try an Ashton RP or AB instead. 4 5 1 August 29, 2016 Jake H.
No. 1 I really enjoyed this well made cigar. The flavor was great with a smooth and creamy taste. One I love to have on the golf course. 4 5 1 August 29, 2016 Zachary D.
No. 1 Finally has the Montecristo No. 1 and I must what a fantastic cigar! Just plain smooth with very nice flavors. I highly recommend trying one...or a box! 4 5 1 August 29, 2016 Christopher H.
No. 1 The length is perfect for how long I sit outside for after work and relax. 4 5 1 August 29, 2016 Jon M.
No. 1 My favorite Monte Cristo cigar my go to cigar for an everyday smoke still have some in my humidor 5 5 1 August 28, 2016 Dominic C.
No. 1 Had a Montecristo no. 1 last Thursday night at the lounge. Never tried one before and the lounge owner recommended it to me. On first light the drawl was a bit snug but after rolling it around in my fingers it finally opened up aboutt 5 drawls In. After that it was amazing with flawless flavor and excellent burn line. Definitely going to get a few more to rest in my humidor. 4 5 1 August 28, 2016 James H.
No. 1 Montecristos never disappoint always consistent. Great flavor and even burn. I always make sure to have a few number 1 and number 2 on hand in my humidor 5 5 1 August 27, 2016 MIKE C.
No. 1 Very mild cigar love to smoke these don't have an after taste just a good smoke 4 5 1 August 27, 2016 Andrew G.
No. 1 Very nice smooth draw even burn. Lots of smoke. Great everyday smoke and excellent 1st smoke for your friends 4 5 1 August 27, 2016 Kenneth M.
No. 1 Burned like champ long ash and all that. I've avoided buying these in the past because I assumed they were just riding on the name. But this was worth the price and then some. 4 5 1 August 26, 2016 robert n.
No. 1 Had my first one the other day and I must say I was impressed. Will be getting some of these for the humidor. 5 5 1 August 25, 2016 Tome E.
No. 1 Got gifted a few of these woody wonders. It's been a while since I've last smoked one of these. But I do remember a wonderfully creamy wood flavor throughout the entire stick. With a very light vanilla in the backroad that would leave me wanting more. Keep these at 65% RH for as long as possible and let these mellow out and blow you away. 4 5 1 August 23, 2016 Brandyn S.
No. 1 There is a reason it is called the number one. Perfect cigar just don't try to inhale just enjoy the taste 4 5 1 August 23, 2016 Shawn G.
No. 1 Pretty mediocre at the beginning is best in the middle however. Not something I would recommend to anyone used to smoking milds this is definitely a full body experience. 3 5 1 August 21, 2016 Liam F.
No. 1 Good cigar good drawl good one hour smoke really like the flavor well worth the money 3 5 1 August 21, 2016 Scott H.
No. 1 Not my favorite stick I've ever smoked but I may try it again. It burned well but I had to touch it up a couple of times. 3 5 1 August 20, 2016 Justin M.
No. 1 Great draw very flavorful must recommend must try. Highly highly recommend. You must try with a nice burbon 5 5 1 August 20, 2016 Michael I.
No. 1 This one is my favorite for a lighter stick. The flavor is not overwhelming and it has a wonderful aroma profile over the entirety of the stick 5 5 1 August 20, 2016 Richard G.
No. 1 I usually smoke larger ring cigars...I had a little trouble with the draw at first...but what a tremendous cigar...I've smoked cuban Monte's when I was in Canada...But the no. 1 takes the cake...just amazing...and a lot cheaper than Toronto's price for Cubans...I could not recommend this cigar any more...It literally made my night to smoke this tremendous cigar. 4 5 1 August 20, 2016 GREGORY N.
No. 1 Very good smoke. Has a nice lighter flavor and good draw with good consistency. A+ 4 5 1 August 19, 2016 ANTHONY G.
No. 1 Drawl was a little tight but still good smoke output. Flavors are traditional monte light core with syrup sweetness. Great burn and burn time 4 5 1 August 18, 2016 Adam R.
No. 1 Five star cigar all together always perfect the flavor hits the pallet like a golf club always wonderful to smoke 5 5 1 August 17, 2016 Cyle K.
No. 1 Great quality smoke love the blend the build quality is amazing good with a coffee in the morning. 5 5 1 August 16, 2016 Chris P.
No. 1 Not a bad stick but not my cup of tea. Draw was good nice slow and even burn. Kinda left a harsh feeling. Flavor was cool 3 5 1 August 16, 2016 Gary K.
No. 1 Doesn't compare to the habano version but still a great smoke. Not overwhelming but packs in a bunch of flavour. Burn was decent. 3 5 1 August 16, 2016 Sharon R.
No. 1 Easy draw lasted long. Flavor wasn't my favorite but it was still decent definitely a good try 4 5 1 August 16, 2016 Stephen A.
No. 1 This is a great cigar! Smooth with perfect construction draw and burn. Mild with great flavor and complexity that builds as you smoke. I picked up hints of leather and roasted nuts with slight spice towards the second half. All around enjoyable smoke! 5 5 1 August 15, 2016 CHRISTOPHER T.
No. 1 This is one I make sure to keep in my humidor. Sometimes you just want a classic 4 5 1 August 14, 2016 Shon W.
No. 1 Highly recommend any of the monte line. Over the top quality for not a bad price. 5 5 1 August 13, 2016 Kyle C.
No. 1 This is your typical monte. It has great flavor good construction and it finished well. If you like this brand you will like this cigar. I like a long ash though and I didn't achieve that with this cigar 5 5 1 August 12, 2016 Jesse A.
No. 1 I just love this cigar. The aroma the taste the feel. You can just relax just sniffing the wrapper. 5 5 1 August 12, 2016 Robert G.
No. 1 By far one of the best cigars I've ever had. I've always been a fan of the montecristo brand and love it. 4 5 1 August 11, 2016 William S.
No. 1 I normally don't like brands that take Cuban names but I love monties. You must smoke one and they are usually so good 5 5 1 August 11, 2016 Paul H.
No. 1 A great stick all around. Hard to beat this one from start to finish. Always keep a few in the humidor. 4 5 1 August 11, 2016 NICHOLAS V.
No. 1 It was a great smoke for the afternoon and had a nice quality and taste to it and I am content 5 5 1 August 10, 2016 Ryan M.
No. 1 Montecristo hmmm well to be honest I did not like this cigar much at all. The smoke was too harsh on the opening and first third. I thought it would calm down past that point but it didn't. I've had other montecristo cigars and have felt he same towards those. Lot of people like these but I honestly believe these are hyped 3 5 1 August 10, 2016 Alicia J.
No. 1 This has always been a consistent stick great to wind down the day with. I would recommend this to anyone looking for an affordable smoke 3 5 1 August 9, 2016 Spencer H.
No. 1 I love Montecristos and this one does not disappoint! Fantastic stick for special occasions. Share this with true fans of the brand. 5 5 1 August 9, 2016 Brandon P.
No. 1 A good basic cigar. All day any day smoke. Smoke is thick and even draw. 4 5 1 August 9, 2016 jim f.
No. 1 Smooth mild cigar that is well constructed by a name that you can trust! 5 5 1 August 9, 2016 CHRIS C.
No. 1 The montecristo is an average cigar. Smooth consistant draw smooth flavor and good burn. It also has a decent aroma. 4 5 1 August 9, 2016 Kevin P.
No. 1 This is my go to cigar. Not to heavy not to light just right bud 3 5 1 August 8, 2016 Travis L.
No. 1 A super enjoyable cigar with a solid flavor profile. Perfect for a fall afternoon with a drink out on the porch before the winter months hit. Has a nice slow burn so you can truly enjoy with no need to rush. I still have a couple in my stock which I have been saving for a relaxing session. 3 5 1 August 8, 2016 Matt D.
No. 1 One of my favorited longs very smooth draw haven't had them in a while but ordering some now! 5 5 1 August 7, 2016 Joseph P.
No. 1 Great casual smoke. Gave one to my dad and he loved it. Quality product 4 5 1 August 7, 2016 Sean A.
No. 1 Flawless construction with a great sharp burn and nice smoke output. Flavor wise it turned out to be a little bland and simple. 4 5 1 August 6, 2016 Brenton H.
No. 1 Just had a birthday and this cigar was the best gift I received... 5 5 1 August 5, 2016 Edward R.
No. 1 This is a phenomenal cigar it was named No.1 for a reason. This is a cigar that your must own great pull great everything! Buy it! 5 5 1 August 5, 2016 Andrei M.
No. 1 Another great stogie from a reputable company. Very smooth and creamy as are almost all montes. You definitely get what you pay for from a name like this. 4 5 1 August 5, 2016 Dana D.
No. 1 As a special occasion smoker this is good. Be careful with the strength of your smokes. Beginners like me should stick with mild to medium smokes. My favorite smokes Cohiba Corona. Overall a good smoke but a little on the pricey side. Special occasion cigar! 4 5 1 August 5, 2016 Josh J.
No. 1 Very good cigar good flavor good burn I will be buying more of these in the future 4 5 1 August 4, 2016 Jason B.
No. 1 The monticristo no.1 is one of my go to cigars. If you havent tried it buy a box now! 4 5 1 August 4, 2016 Ezekiel V.
No. 1 This is a clear attempt to mimic the Legandary Cuban Montecristo #1. But it is very light on tastes terrible with a Connecticut wrapper and Dominican filler. 4 5 1 August 3, 2016 Cynthia R.
No. 1 Got this stick in a sampler enjoyed it with a Russels Reserve 10yr. Had a good draw most the way through. 4 5 1 August 3, 2016 Christopher R.
No. 1 It tasted a little like the package had left residue on the rapper at first kind of like plastic but towards the end it had a little peppery taste. It did start to unwrap towards the end of the cigar how ever. I probably won't smoke this again 3 5 1 August 3, 2016 Cole A.
No. 1 I find that I do not enjoy smaller gauge cigars however this cigar was wonderful. It was creamy and smooth with a slight roasted nutty flavor. The burn was excellent and the smoke plentiful for the most part. It was firm but not overly tight. all in all a pleasure to smoke 4 5 1 August 3, 2016 Lauren M.
No. 1 hands down a great smoke i put the monte christo in the top of my picks 5 5 1 August 1, 2016 Jason W.
No. 1 What can I say Montecriso cigars are some of the finest out there. This is my go to stick when I need a cigar fix. 5 5 1 August 1, 2016 Alan K.
No. 1 This is one of my favorite brands. This is sure to please your taste buds. 5 5 1 July 31, 2016 Kevin R.
No. 1 Very nice cigar one of my regular smokes. Pairs well with a nice red wine. 4 5 1 July 30, 2016 oando A.
No. 1 Still among my favorite cigars year after year. A great smoke. Box to box consistant very few bad drawing cigars. 4 5 1 July 30, 2016 Joe R.
No. 1 The classic fall back. This is the all around cigar for your everyday smoke. Nothing bold or amazing. I keep at least a few around just to have it on hand 3 5 1 July 28, 2016 Ross M.
No. 1 A king among men. Solid smoke never disappoints. I am always looking for a deal on these and when I find it I get it! 5 5 1 July 28, 2016 JASON G.
No. 1 This is one of my favorites. Great taste and smoke. Draw is perfect.last about1hr and 15 minutes. Stars off with a mild pepper and earthy and get leather. 5 5 1 July 25, 2016 Jason L.
No. 1 The montecristo #1 is one I can smoke any time. I think every one needs to try one. 3 5 1 July 25, 2016 Travis A.
No. 1 Great smoke. Good draw. Even burn. One of my favorites. I would definitely recommend to my friends. 5 5 1 July 23, 2016 RALPH H.
No. 1 One of the best monte's. This is an enjoyable smoke. Worth giving it a try. 4 5 1 July 23, 2016 Clay A.
No. 1 One of my favorites. Very mild smooth smoking cigar. Wonderful flavor and aroma. Consistent draw. Highly recommend. 4 5 1 July 23, 2016 Steve T.
No. 1 This is a solid cigar and I always enjoy montes. This is not my favorite size for this cigar but I am always surprised by how good it is. 4 5 1 July 22, 2016 DAVID P.
No. 1 Great cigar draw was a litte slow. had a very good flavor. I would most likely get another one. A must try 3 5 1 July 22, 2016 Joseph c.
No. 1 This is a highly favorable cigar in my book. Great draw and a great flavor. Mild start with a bolder finish 5 5 1 July 22, 2016 JAMES C.
No. 1 Just tried my first one! Great cigar great flavor. Read the reviews on this cigar and they were right. 4 5 1 July 21, 2016 Matt C.
No. 1 The most famous of the many famous Havana brands started only in 1935 and still going strong so that must mean there doing something right! Everyone who smokes has had one of these at some point in time. 3 5 1 July 20, 2016 Edwin R.
No. 1 This thing isn't called No. 1 for nothing. Perfect for an outing with the boys on the boats. Couple brews and a couple cigars. It's lit 5 5 1 July 20, 2016 Mason P.
No. 1 Weed tingling sensation all throughout my mouth when I get into the second third but the third third is when you get some nice coffee flavors 2 5 1 July 19, 2016 Cameron O.
No. 1 I love this cigar because it's long and burns like it should. Go try one of these and you will be happy 5 5 1 July 19, 2016 Eric K.
No. 1 This cigar is top of the line cigar with a great taste/flavor. The cigar is def worth the price you pay for it. 4 5 1 July 19, 2016 Eddie R.
No. 1 Very nice smoke. Cool light to the mouth wonderful nutty flavor with a dash of sweet. Easy pull 4 5 1 July 18, 2016 Alex F.
No. 1 These need to sit for a good 6 months at least from purchasing as the first one was harsh and bitter. But after 6 months in the humidor it smoked nice and smooth with a sweet chocolate and cream flavor. 4 5 1 July 18, 2016 Jason H.
No. 1 This monte is a awesome smoke I really like the flavores it had and a kick but draw but still like my drews 5 5 1 July 17, 2016 Chris S.
No. 1 Light and smooth. Exactly what you'd expect from Monte. Draw was fantastic. A few unwrapped a little near the finish but it was manageable. 4 5 1 July 17, 2016 Greg S.
No. 1 One of my all time favorite monte varieties and it has a nice price point at jr 5 5 1 July 17, 2016 Ryan W.
No. 1 I smoked it and it wasn't as good as I hoped it would be. It was a good cigar but not as good and Thomas cigar 4 5 1 July 16, 2016 Charles A.
No. 1 The No.1 lives up to what it's name is. A light airy draw folds into a smooth nutty flavor. 3 5 1 July 15, 2016 Algimantas H.
No. 1 Usually too expensive for me to enjoy on a regular basis. Every so often I indulge in the finest...great draw and flavor. Everyone wants one when I have one lit. Have to enjoy in private 4 5 1 July 15, 2016 JOHN O.
No. 1 What can't enough about this smoke! It is an all around fantastic cigar! I would recommend to all! 5 5 1 July 14, 2016 Rick R.
No. 1 My dad's favorite. Great stick that burns smooth. Some say it's an old man cigar but you'll love it regardless. 5 5 1 July 14, 2016 Jeff J.
No. 1 Monticristo is the bomb. Try it and you won't be disappointed! If you are wanting to taste greatness invent in a box of these. 5 5 1 July 13, 2016 Jim G.
No. 1 Was given this by a friend in a blind trade. While ive heard great things annoy Montecristo I was not overly impressed. Between the mild strength and the Connecticut wrapper it just want my flavor preference. A good choice for those new to the hobby 4 5 1 July 13, 2016 Gregory F.
No. 1 Great for hanging with the guys sitting by a fire. Great flavor and burns evenly. I recommend this cigar! 4 5 1 July 12, 2016 Buddy M.
No. 1 Truly a well rounded choice. Great flavors smooth draw and definitely one of my go tos 4 5 1 July 12, 2016 Devon D.
No. 1 It's a good smoke but there are better out there in the price range. 3 5 1 July 12, 2016 JOSEPH M.
No. 1 The Montecristo no. 1 is just what you would expect from this brand! This cigar is pretty top notch and well worth the money. I highly recommend to try it 4 5 1 July 12, 2016 Miguel M.
No. 1 The montecristo number one is my favorite cigar. Best of the best will order again 4 5 1 July 12, 2016 IOANNIS L.
No. 1 Very good smoke! Mild and easy anytime. I'm partial to Dominican cigars but this one is worth it every time 4 5 1 July 10, 2016 Steve B.
No. 1 Good cigar I had no problems with the draw or burn. No relights or touch ups needed. Great tobacco flavor. 4 5 1 July 10, 2016 Eric B.
No. 1 Good draw. Even burn. Go to cigar when kicking back with a glass of scotch. 5 5 1 July 10, 2016 Thomas L.
No. 1 This medium bodied cigar is a favorite of mine. A little on the pricey side but delivers a consistent smoke with a touch of cocoa and spice. You may be able to find the same smoke in a lesser priced cigar. 4 5 1 July 9, 2016 PETER R.
No. 1 Montecristo is like the king of cigars well built nice even draw. A+ 5 5 1 July 9, 2016 Allen L.
No. 1 I personally Love Montes. They are a medium body cigar yet full of flavor. I think this is an aromatic cigar and could taste hints of coffee and vanilla. A Great and safe choice to have around when you have buddies over. I think if this is your first cigar or if you're a connoisseur you will love this cigar. Love it! 4 5 1 July 8, 2016 Michael M.
No. 1 Worth a try but I have experienced construction issues. Definitely not worth the money at a brick and mortar 2 5 1 July 8, 2016 William M.
No. 1 I love Montecristo!! Can never go wrong with Montecito and this one does not dissapoint. I would highly recommend this stick to everyone. 5 5 1 July 8, 2016 Kenneth H.
No. 1 Mild flavor and has a little spice to it. Relatively good cigar usually one that I have gotten in sample packs 3 5 1 July 8, 2016 Austen K.
No. 1 One of my favorite cigars! Great flavor and consitincy. Always a few in my humidor. 5 5 1 July 8, 2016 Eric C.
No. 1 Great smoke. I haven't had a single cigar from this company that I didn't like. This is one of the lower end Montecristo's but still is a great buy 4 5 1 July 7, 2016 Austin B.
No. 1 One of my favorite tasting cigars. A great draw lots of smoke. A great flavor and a great price 5 5 1 July 7, 2016 Joseph L.
No. 1 Very flavorful and a great moist wrapper a little more affordable than the limited with big silver ring on it. Great value 5 5 1 July 7, 2016 Doug H.
No. 1 Excellent cigar that makes a great afternoon smoke. A must try cigar that won't disappoint. Great draw throughout with plenty of lush clouds of smoke. 4 5 1 July 7, 2016 Joe B.
No. 1 Not too bad at all. Very basic cigar with some nice accents throughout the length. Nice oily wrapper and average draw. 4 5 1 July 7, 2016 Ron F.
No. 1 I find it takes me a long time to smoke so if you have time then this is the one. It's a smooth draw and has a spicy type of taste to it. It doesn't leave a bad aftertaste it actually smells really good too. 5 5 1 July 6, 2016 Amanda B.
No. 1 The montecristo no 1 has a mild creamy flavor. The stick has a great burn. This is a consistent cigar for anyone who wants a solid humidor filler. 4 5 1 July 5, 2016 Billy V.
No. 1 It's been a while but I remember these being on the hot side. Inconsistent draws with a harsh ashtray aftertaste. 3 5 1 July 5, 2016 James C.
No. 1 I finally got around to smoking a sample pack with these in it. I won it on this site. 4 5 1 July 3, 2016 Tom O.
No. 1 Great body and pull. Draw was good as well as the construction. Would reccomend highly 4 5 1 July 3, 2016 Spencer M.
No. 1 I have smoked a few of these I have some that are over-year-old looking forward to smoking those will smoke again 4 5 1 July 2, 2016 Douglas J.
No. 1 The no.1 is by far one of my top 3 cigars. The flavor is superb while not being over powering. The aroma it gives off while burning is enjoyable and the burn is even and smooth. I love these cigars! 4 5 1 July 2, 2016 Blake H.
No. 1 Classic Monte. Full flavor billows of smoke. No. 3 is still and always will be my favorite though. Unless you can get your hands on some authentic Habanos. Well worth the price though. 5 5 1 July 2, 2016 Brian R.
No. 1 Found this to be a solid tasty smoke. Nice construction. Good draw. Consistent. I would recommend it and smoke it again myself. 4 5 1 June 30, 2016 Richard W.
No. 1 I was impressed with the structure and was excited to try it however it wasn't what I expected. Hard to get a good puff and tasted a little woodsy 3 5 1 June 30, 2016 Benny L.
No. 1 Best cigar I've had I love it great tatste great smoke in general try it out 5 5 1 June 30, 2016 Gregory J.
No. 1 This is a decent mild cigar light cedar notes. The construction and draw are impeccable. 4 5 1 June 29, 2016 Joseph G.
No. 1 I go with Monte every so often. For me sometimes they are too strong. I prefer a milder cigar 4 5 1 June 29, 2016 MICHAEL D.
No. 1 Smooth smoke enjoyed from start to finish only knock received a couple close to stall which took away from it overall 3 5 1 June 29, 2016 Darnell S.
No. 1 Montecristo is one of the best. Always reliable always enjoyable. A nice evening cigar with a good beverage. 4 5 1 June 29, 2016 DANIEL T.
No. 1 Just tried one of these bad boys the other night. A fine smoke though I enjoy a little bigger gauge. Draw was nice and a consistent burn. Extinguished once during the smoke but I think I was paying more attention to my cocktail at the time. Would happily enjoy another anytime. 4 5 1 June 28, 2016 Bryan C.
No. 1 Probably one of the lightest flavor dominicans I have ever smoked. Another great cigar for the newcomer. Very easy smooth draw 4 5 1 June 28, 2016 JOHN C.
No. 1 This is a really smooth cigar. I would very highly recommend for everyone to try. Also has a nice aroma 4 5 1 June 28, 2016 Rebecca P.
No. 1 Not as good as montecristo no 2 but not a bad cigar at all. Great flavor and draw had no issues at all burned even and didn't go out while I was smoking it 4 5 1 June 27, 2016 Timothy L.
No. 1 Probably one of the best cigars I have smoked. Was consistent through out the whole cigar with a change in flavor halfway through. Premium cigar at decent price 4 5 1 June 27, 2016 Sebastian E.
No. 1 One of my favorite smokes!! I really enjoy every time I buy full flavored to the last puff for me very enjoyable with a cold beer 5 5 1 June 27, 2016 William L.
No. 1 I think one of the best montecristo I have smoked thus far. The smoke was rich and thick. Favors were very good draw and construction was excellent. I will be buying more soon. 5 5 1 June 26, 2016 Greg G.
No. 1 A buds of mine gave me one of these when I first started smoking cigars and I was pleasantly surprised and thought if all the cigars I smoked were this good then I found my new favorite hobby! 4 5 1 June 26, 2016 Matthew A.
No. 1 Taking a long leisurely drive with the top down then this is the smoke for you. 4 5 1 June 26, 2016 David J.
No. 1 Great cigar for morning or before dinner. Mild to medium body and mild strength. Takes a little over an hour to smoke 4 5 1 June 26, 2016 Richard T.
No. 1 Montecristo number 1. That sums it up pretty well. This cigar is one of the best I've had if you're looking for a good medium to full bodied flavor. Nice thick smoke billows as you'll notice hints of leather and almonds. 5 5 1 June 25, 2016 PHILLIP S.
No. 1 A medium to full bodied cigar that lacks a nice peppery spice and floral bouquet. 5 5 1 June 25, 2016 ANGELO D.
No. 1 I love these. Cannot ask for a better smoke. Flavor is mid to strong. Not too light. 4 5 1 June 25, 2016 Norman M.
No. 1 Always did like a montecristo and this was good buy. Love the flavor and size of these sticks 5 5 1 June 25, 2016 Lane B.
No. 1 Decent cigar for the price. Would smoke again. However I thought it took too lon go smoke but that could just be a personal preference. All insoles good 2 5 1 June 23, 2016 Maxwell B.
No. 1 Monti has been a long time favorite of mine. This cigar is amazing and hits the spot after a long hard day of work. Got a great deal on an auction. 4 5 1 June 23, 2016 john m.
No. 1 This isn't a number one for no reason. This cigar is first in its class . Long lasting consistent burn with a enjoyable flavor. 5 5 1 June 22, 2016 Dan B.
No. 1 Love this cigar. Medium side. Beautiful creamy smoke. Solid construction. Nice easy smooth finish. If you enjoy a good smoke. Pairs nicely with everything. 4 5 1 June 21, 2016 Sergio G.
No. 1 I love this cigar! I need to get a box of these. Just an all around great smoke and a great experience. 4 5 1 June 20, 2016 Dean S.
No. 1 This cigar is an excellent Construction as well as a perfect draw. Flavors can be described as medium body low to medium strength and a mild transition about halfway through coming from rich leather transitioning to a sweet cinnamon Earth. Great Smoke great price 4 5 1 June 20, 2016 Adam G.
No. 1 Classic. I have two boxes on the way. Always keep these bad boys around. Goes great with bourbon. 5 5 1 June 19, 2016 Thomas H.
No. 1 The Montecristo No1 smokes well. It was a great cigar but it wouldn't stay lit towards the end. 4 5 1 June 19, 2016 Matthew T.
No. 1 One of my favorite smokes good draw a d great smooth flavor. Def should give this a try! 4 5 1 June 17, 2016 Richie R.
No. 1 Great morning smoke. Mild to medium. Nice cedar and alittle spice. Definetely a good way to start a day 3 5 1 June 17, 2016 Luis C.
No. 1 I'm a big fan of this cigar personally I'd rather smoke a Monte White but this all around a solid cigar. 3 5 1 June 16, 2016 Connor V.
No. 1 Has good flavor every time but would start to unravel halfway through not very often but still happened a few times 3 5 1 June 16, 2016 Dalton R.
No. 1 Consistently bland. I had a hard time getting a solid draw out of the stick and didn't have much taste. Many better Montes made. 3 5 1 June 16, 2016 Kyle W.
No. 1 Montecristo is one of my favorite brands and this cigar is no exception. nice flavor and easy to draw even my wife enjoys it with me. 4 5 1 June 15, 2016 Jon Y.
No. 1 A very good smoke. The draw was a little tough but an overall great stick. 3 5 1 June 15, 2016 Denver S.
No. 1 Excellent product's name speaks for it self know if you needed pick one up try it and you'll see exactly what I mean we 4 5 1 June 15, 2016 Brian R.
No. 1 Good Dominican blend although hard to hold a candle to the Cuban version of number 2. Good smoke overall 4 5 1 June 14, 2016 Robert Z.
No. 1 Good cigar ...... Exactly what I was looking for can't complain with this stick at all 4 5 1 June 14, 2016 Jets K.
No. 1 Burned pretty evenly but then followed a vein and the cigar was toast. I would like to try another. 4 5 1 June 14, 2016 Filip P.
No. 1 Light cream flavor makes this cigar an elegant choice. Beautiful construction and nice draw make this a go to for braking in a newbie to good cigars. 4 5 1 June 13, 2016 Jimmy W.
No. 1 Good smoke had a smooth draw easy to pull the wrapper was nice and combined with a smooth flavor makes for a good smoke. 4 5 1 June 12, 2016 Stephen H.
No. 1 Had this cigar at the Porterhouse in NJ. Recommended by a friend. Enjoyed thoroughly with a nice beer and some food. 4 5 1 June 11, 2016 Miles R.
No. 1 This was not one of my favorite montes but it's an all around good medium to strong cigar that's pretty consistent 4 5 1 June 11, 2016 David N.
No. 1 My favorite brand. Never disappointed. The construction was excellent burned even and cool. The wonderful Montecristo flavor and smell were dead on. A real finger burner 4 5 1 June 10, 2016 D. 2.
No. 1 Good long smoke thats hard to draw at first. Once it is halfway smoked it is easier and the taste really comes out. I would recommend this cigar 3 5 1 June 10, 2016 Tyler M.
No. 1 Full consistent draw throughout. Wonder flavor. You won't be disappointed with this cigar. Well worth it. 4 5 1 June 10, 2016 JENNIFER P.
No. 1 One of my favorite cigars I've had in a long time. Definitely save this one for a special event. Not a cigar to go to waste that's for sure! 4 5 1 June 10, 2016 Seth J.
No. 1 This is a nice smoke for the price I bought it for went right into my humidor and smoke them every once in a while 5 5 1 June 9, 2016 Mike P.
No. 1 You can never go wrong with this brand. If you haven't tried it yet you're missing out. 5 5 1 June 9, 2016 SHAWN C.
No. 1 What a great smoke. Very smooth easy draw stays well lit. Would recommend. You can't beat the price for the money wstcher 5 5 1 June 9, 2016 Davis M.
No. 1 Good cigar for the money. Can't ever go wrong with a Montecristo. Overall a good deal. 4 5 1 June 9, 2016 Tyler H.
No. 1 This is one of my favorites! Great draw and has a super nice smooth taste. Pour a whiskey with it and you're set to relax! 4 5 1 June 8, 2016 Seth R.
No. 1 Everything was perfect! Not much flavor for my taste. Big what flavor that was there was great! 4 5 1 June 8, 2016 Nicholas H.
No. 1 One of the most enjoyable cigar smoking experiences I have ever had. 4 5 1 June 7, 2016 Colby J.
No. 1 Many of my friends love this one; yet it's not for me. Long lasting but the flavor isn't my first choice. Worth trying though 3 5 1 June 7, 2016 Thomas B.
No. 1 Their quality is consistent. Good smoke I would definitely recommend it to a friends do smoke again. 5 5 1 June 7, 2016 Steve A.
No. 1 Montecristo is a brand one can trust...even though it's not my favorite in the bunch the no 1 has a great draw and great construction. Pairs well with lunch time coffee break. 3 5 1 June 7, 2016 Michael A.
No. 1 It was a nice smoke. I expected more flavor than I received but overall enjoyable 3 5 1 June 6, 2016 Joe N.
No. 1 Nice smoke. Draw was a little loose but overall good construction. Great stick. A go to smoke. 4 5 1 June 6, 2016 Russell D.
No. 1 What's not to like about this fine stick? Perfect draw with a great mild to medium body. There's no putting this badboy out for later. 4 5 1 June 6, 2016 ShaRon B.
No. 1 Heard great things..... That's where it ends for me turned out mediocre at best. Much rather have a macanudo after dinner. 3 5 1 June 6, 2016 Matthew H.
No. 1 The Montecristo #1 was my first Lonsdale cigar and the one I use as the gold standard for this style. 4 5 1 June 5, 2016 NATHAN A.
No. 1 I have smoked Montechristo for some time now. The #1 are one of the few I have never gotten a bad one. With an easy draw and smooth taste it is always a wonderful smoke. 4 5 1 June 5, 2016 Ross M.
No. 1 Good construction draw wasnt the best. Wasnt as flavorful as i was hoping but burned well. 4 5 1 June 5, 2016 Steven T.
No. 1 I find the no. 1 to be a simpler thinner version of their (in my own opinion) overrated Espada. 4 5 1 June 5, 2016 Josh C.
No. 1 One of my favorite cigars. I like the short story. Great for a quick smoke. I prefer this cigar when smoking. Great price great quality 4 5 1 June 5, 2016 Jake S.
No. 1 One of my go-to cigars. Great draw and flavor. Low maintenance. I bought this one for my brother for his graduation and he loved it as well! 4 5 1 June 5, 2016 Thomas S.
No. 1 Highly recommend smoking this I enjoyed it with a glass of scotch and it was perfect. A great fast and a smooth draw 4 5 1 June 5, 2016 TJ D.
No. 1 This cigar is Montecritso quality and flavor all the way this cigar is a definite good buy. The flavor construction and quality are always high end on these! 5 5 1 June 4, 2016 Nathan M.
No. 1 This is one of my favorite go to cigars pears well with a good Cabernet. Highly recommend this. 1 5 1 June 4, 2016 Kim Y.
No. 1 A great cigar. Expected For a cigar that costs as much as these. Well constructed and complex flavor profile. If you do some searching you can find just as good of a cigar for much less rather than paying for the name 4 5 1 June 4, 2016 Ryan S.
No. 1 A great cigar from one of the great makers. Well constructed. Good consistency. Good burn. Good woody flavor. 4 5 1 June 3, 2016 David C.
No. 1 This is a classic. Always consistent. One of those cigars that if you like the first puff you will like it all the way through ... not much flavor change. A little on the mild side for me but solid smoke. 4 5 1 June 3, 2016 Gabe G.
No. 1 As a special occasion smoker this is good. Be careful with the strength of your smokes. Beginners like me should stick with mild to medium smokes. My favorite smokes Cohiba Corona. 4 5 1 June 3, 2016 Nicholas B.
No. 1 Great mild-medium range smoke. Amazing light flavor. Good draw. I would recommend this to anyone. 4 5 1 June 2, 2016 Brett H.
No. 1 Found this cigar to be a classic and consistent smoke. The draw was steady throughout and the flavor was well balanced. 4 5 1 May 31, 2016 Tom M.
No. 1 Coffee notes. Like a cappuccino. Creamy texture. Leathery finish. Cool burn down to almost the nub. 4 5 1 May 30, 2016 Robert T.
No. 1 Was a solid cigar. Their wasn't much in the flavor dept but not bad either. I have another in the humidor so ill smoke it soon and see if my opinion changes 3 5 1 May 30, 2016 Jason T.
No. 1 Really good on the cold draw. Stays consistent throughout the whole smoke. Great construction that makes for an even and full burn. Pairs well with my favorite IPA. I would really recommend this cigar for anyone who likes a good smoke has the time to smoke it and loves hoppy beer. 3 5 1 May 29, 2016 Samuel B.
No. 1 This cigar is a true classic. Excellent all around smoke. You need to set aside some time to smoke this one. 5 5 1 May 29, 2016 BRIAN H.
No. 1 This cigar didn't do much for me. Construction was just ok and it seemed to lack on body and flavor. 3 5 1 May 28, 2016 MATTHEW S.
No. 1 I love this smoke. Great consistency great flavor. In the world of cigars this is a bit of an old school smoke but you can't go wrong ever with this line. 4 5 1 May 26, 2016 Nathaniel F.
No. 1 respect the mildness DON'T SMOKE MORE THAN TWO THIRDS OF LEAVE AT LEST ONE THIRD AND SMOKE NO MORE ENJOYABLE MOST OF ALL 3 5 1 May 26, 2016 David S.
No. 1 Are you kidding me this cigat needs no review. By far one of the top 5 cigars on the market. You can't review a cigar of the quality of this stick. If you know cigars if you like cigars if you need cigars you should have won 5 5 1 May 26, 2016 Wayne O.
No. 1 My go to cigar. Great cigar for around twelve dollars. Great for all occasions Have a case at all times 5 5 1 May 25, 2016 Kyle I.
No. 1 Excellent smoke. Even better with your favorite beverage. Good burn. Nice earthy and wood flavors. 5 5 1 May 25, 2016 David C.
No. 1 A must for any real cigar admirer one hasn't truly smoke until one of these best smokes on the market. 5 5 1 May 25, 2016 Earl M.
No. 1 Decent taste. Good draw not as good as other montes I've tried . Good on a nice cool day. 4 5 1 May 25, 2016 Nicole S.
No. 1 It's a quick burn but if you like smaller gauge cigars it's worth a shot 3 5 1 May 24, 2016 Herb P.
No. 1 It was a good smoke not a very full flavored cigar but nice even draw and burned well 4 5 1 May 24, 2016 David S.
No. 1 The Montecristo #1 is a great cigar for the begging smoker. I really don't know much about cigars but I do love this one. 3 5 1 May 24, 2016 Scott T.
No. 1 This cigar was a smooth smoke from start to finish. I good blend of spice and earthy tones. Don't rush this smoke take your time you won't regret it. 3 5 1 May 24, 2016 Steven C.
No. 1 Great smoke two of the three I've smoked had an unevenness to the burn but nothing to crazy. Flavor is excellent (I'm still relatively new to this so I don't use words like creamy etc) construction of the stock was great drew like a champ. Overall I would recommend! 4 5 1 May 23, 2016 Cody m.
No. 1 I purchased these cigars when I was in the Dominicn republic these have a very rich flavor of Tabaco and the draw on them is very smooth and is completed with a burn less nose exhale. Very well made cigar 5 5 1 May 23, 2016 Jake F.
No. 1 I suggest aging after purchasing. This cigar is truly like fine wine. Smooth perfect draw great medium body taste with some cocoa. Try it! 5 5 1 May 23, 2016 Chris H.
No. 1 I'm just not a non Maduro wrapper smoker but I am not a fan of this cigar 3 5 1 May 22, 2016 Anthony B.
No. 1 If you're looking for a smooth mellow cigar with a easy to draw this well constructed Montecristo is for you. A easy full draw cigar very mellow on the palate. Sweet taste of satisfaction. 5 5 1 May 22, 2016 RON D.
No. 1 I really think this is a 5 star cigar. A classic in my opinion. Good tastes throughout and a really reliable smoke. Coffee and vanilla. Sometimes a bit small of a gauge for my liking but this smoke is sophisticated. 4 5 1 May 21, 2016 Bobby J.
No. 1 Pretty mild cigar with uninspiring flavors to me but i like a bit more full flavored smoke. Good construction and burn throughout 4 5 1 May 21, 2016 Donn B.
No. 1 Great stick better have time to enjoy this one it will last you awhile 4 5 1 May 20, 2016 Jason G.
No. 1 Had this given to me at a wedding a couple of weeks ago and had to come looking for it here and buy some for my humidor. Great flavor good draw even burn 5 5 1 May 20, 2016 Shaun M.
No. 1 Excellent cigar nice flavor enjoyed it will stick to my usual brand though mine is a milder flavor that is my honest opinion 4 5 1 May 18, 2016 antonietta m.
No. 1 Really nice smooth draw and the flavor is just brilliant! After my first try i immediately went back and bought a whole box! Very comfortable good smoke! 4 5 1 May 18, 2016 Jeff C.
No. 1 One of my favorite cigars better to buy them on auction then to pay full price very consistent good with a nice scotch or bourbonIt doesn't have a Pepperidge strong taste like other cigars 4 5 1 May 18, 2016 VINCENT D.
No. 1 This specific cigar is smooth with a great taste I will recommend it to everyone who likes cigars 3 5 1 May 17, 2016 Mandy R.
No. 1 Enjoyable smoke. Smooth draw with mild flavor and no runs. I would definitely accept as a gift or buy on sale! 4 5 1 May 17, 2016 WILLIAM F.
No. 1 Monte no.2 is the reference. Construction is A- Taste is smoky and peppery leather. Very consistent smoke. Not as good as no.2 but could be no. 3 4 5 1 May 16, 2016 Stephen C.
No. 1 I personally did not care for this monteCristo it did not have a good flavor 1 5 1 May 15, 2016 Adam J.
No. 1 Montecristo is by far one of my favorite companies in the cigar game. I have yet to be disappointed by any of their line up. 5 5 1 May 14, 2016 Michael F.
No. 1 It's was a tight draw with a harsh flavor I didn't really care for it at all but that's just me 3 5 1 May 14, 2016 Jeremy H.
No. 1 This one was great for a novice. My uncle gifted me one and it was a good experience with a cigar I wouldn't have bought otherwise. 4 5 1 May 12, 2016 Connor H.
No. 1 You can never go wrong with a Monte Cristo this is a great stick I like to have around when company comes around someone who enjoys smoking a nice cigar 5 5 1 May 11, 2016 Jay R.
No. 1 Great draw and consistent stick. The burn was even through out the smoke. I truly enjoyed this smoke 4 5 1 May 10, 2016 Christian T.
No. 1 Not a bad smoke. Very smooth and consistent draw. Well constructed. Paired very well with a 12 year old Scotch. Lasted just long enough but not too long. 4 5 1 May 10, 2016 DAVID P.
No. 1 Definitely a reason it's their # 1. Monte hit this right on the mark. 4 5 1 May 8, 2016 Christopher J.
No. 1 I rated this cigar 4 stars overall. Nothing spectacular but definitely satisfying. Good stick. Go buy it. 4 5 1 May 8, 2016 Randis S.
No. 1 an oldie but goodie. Can't go wrong with the montecristo's. Great construction and flavors. 4 5 1 May 8, 2016 Kevin D.
No. 1 My only issue was relighting it. Other than that it's a excellent and smooth smoke. 4 5 1 May 7, 2016 Dan D.
No. 1 Good cigar. Very flavorful and well constructed. Not my favorite. I prefer the classic series or te vintage. However I would still smoke this montecristo again 5 5 1 May 7, 2016 Joel G.
No. 1 Overall this is a good cigar but not my favorite I'm partial to macs and this just isn't that but again still a good cigar 3 5 1 May 7, 2016 Kurt C.
No. 1 Good draw. Taste is good but fades out at the end. You find yourself asking what happened. Good cigar for the price but not great. 4 5 1 May 6, 2016 John M.
No. 1 Love this cigar smoke at least 1 to 2 of these a week good cigar for the money 4 5 1 May 6, 2016 Jeremy R.
No. 1 One truly amazing smoke my wife even approved this smell it's amazing and tasty 4 5 1 May 6, 2016 Branden L.
No. 1 The first third to halfway was pretty mediocre- tough draw. It got much better through the second half. Overall pretty decent but you need time for this. 4 5 1 May 5, 2016 Joel S.
No. 1 Great cigar as with most of montecisto's cigars. Always a go to cigar for a great smoke. 5 5 1 May 5, 2016 Thomas S.
No. 1 I love montes so I might be biased but any monte is worth your time and the #1 is no different. Smooth good burn and always in my tupperdor lol 5 5 1 May 5, 2016 Eric P.
No. 1 Great mild cigar for any occasion good flavor good smoke it's one of the best mild cigars 5 5 1 May 4, 2016 Brian R.
No. 1 Excellent cigar. Medium smoke. It is a must get. No to expensive for the cigar 3 5 1 May 4, 2016 Erik B.
No. 1 A mellow smoke that I think pairs great with a sunrise and a serious cup of Joe looking out over the water. Mild and smooth. Fairly loose and soft upon burning with a few touch ups normally required. A bit nutty and creamy. With a touch of cedar. Not at all a bad cigar. And normally at a nice price. 3 5 1 May 4, 2016 Kenneth L.
No. 1 Eh it's alright not great for the money but not bad. You should try one and find out 3 5 1 May 4, 2016 Chris S.
No. 1 I really enjoy smoking this cigar it has a pretty good draw. And a nice flavor. Probably smoke one a couple times a month 4 5 1 May 3, 2016 Joseph C.
No. 1 A classic smoke from one of the biggest names in the business! Very good cigar that you can just enjoy no bs 4 5 1 May 3, 2016 Nick V.
No. 1 A very consistent stick. Mostly smooth earthy notes. Some nuttiness and a little bitterness. Great for beginners 4 5