All Brands  ›  Cigars  ›  Handmade Cigars  ›  Cigar Samplers  ›  Mystery 5-Pack
MYS5PK
3.6097560975609757 41
Mystery 5-Pack I do not even remember the brand assortment but if all mystery samplers were this good I would buy a lot more mystery samplers. 4 5 1
Mystery 5-Pack I got two mystery fives with a couple of premium 10 packs I purchased. I got 2 Fuentes 4 Nat Sherman’s an Upman a Davidoff and two I’ve never heard of. I have to admit I was happy with my mystery 5’s. 4 5 1
Mystery 5-Pack The cigars I received were actually better quality cigars than I thought I would get. The only reason I know this is because I had smoked them before. I won't be able to smoke the 5 I received in this sampler because they all arrived cracked and dry as a bone... all 5 are worthless. Very disappointed with JR cigars... 2 5 1
Mystery 5-Pack Great cigars. They have a great flavor. I am not disappointed in this purchase. If the mystery pack comes back I will not hesitate to purchase another one. 5 5 1
Mystery 5-Pack No mystery here. Nice cigar for a daily. They are always a little better if you hold in your humidor for a month or two. 4 5 1
Mystery 5-Pack I love these lil smokes. Was a nice little surprise. I want more. Good burn nice flavor 5 5 1
Mystery 5-Pack Better than I expected. The draw was a little tough but the flavor more than made up for it. All In all I was pleasantly surprised. 4 5 1
Mystery 5-Pack ...a mystery why I didn't pay attention to the reviews. Definitely nothing special here. 3 5 1
Mystery 5-Pack Sounded like a great deal. What arrived was some really cheap throw aways. 1 5 1
Mystery 5-Pack I recently purchased 2 of the mystery 5 packs hoping I would get a variety of cigars. Instead I got 10 Black Lion cigars which I wouldn't classify as Premium. Also very bland cigars (big cigarette). Will be pawning off on cigar moochers. 2 5 1
Mystery 5-Pack Great taste but the wrap keep coming off. Had you hold it from completely unwrapping 3 5 1
Mystery 5-Pack I have bought these Mystery 5 packs before and I guess sooner or later you get a DUDD!!! This one was TERRIBLE. Normally you get a variety this time All five the same Bering Gold #1 a Swissher International cigar. POOR Draw terrible taste. The only thing I could say good is that all the cigars were equally bad. At least the 2 I tried. The rest will take up room in my humidor for a long time. Buyer Beware. I wonder if JR will make this right somehow?? 1 5 1
Mystery 5-Pack Very good! It's a fun deal to have! Great price for great smokes! 4 5 1
Mystery 5-Pack You just never know what you will get but be sure it's good bargains. Love it cheap. 5 5 1
Mystery 5-Pack Full flavor smooth draw not a bad smoke Will get again. For the price you can not go wrong 4 5 1
Mystery 5-Pack I’m a little disappointed in this pack, which contained 5 of the same cigar. I received 5 JR Edicion Limitade cigars. I was hoping I would receive different variety reading the reviews. Probably won’t recommend this to anyone. 2 5 1
Mystery 5-Pack I cant rate the way these taste but I was very surprised that 5 quality cigars came in this sampler San Lotano oval maduro , Alec Bradly Habano, and 3 other name brands that I have not tried. These came as a freebie when I bought my daily Camachos and Romeos and the shipping was fast. All of these will rest for a month minimum but I can not see me complaining about the mystery 5 pack. Im am really loving JRs so I will give everything a high rating as I know my regulars will be great and ones I have smoked in this mystery pack are really good cigars 5 5 1
Mystery 5-Pack I do not even remember the brand assortment but if all mystery samplers were this good I would buy a lot more mystery samplers. 4 5 1
Mystery 5-Pack I got two mystery fives with a couple of premium 10 packs I purchased. I got 2 Fuentes 4 Nat Sherman’s an Upman a Davidoff and two I’ve never heard of. I have to admit I was happy with my mystery 5’s. 4 5 1
Mystery 5-Pack The cigars I received were actually better quality cigars than I thought I would get. The only reason I know this is because I had smoked them before. I won't be able to smoke the 5 I received in this sampler because they all arrived cracked and dry as a bone... all 5 are worthless. Very disappointed with JR cigars... 2 5 1
Mystery 5-Pack Great cigars. They have a great flavor. I am not disappointed in this purchase. If the mystery pack comes back I will not hesitate to purchase another one. 5 5 1
Mystery 5-Pack No mystery here. Nice cigar for a daily. They are always a little better if you hold in your humidor for a month or two. 4 5 1
Mystery 5-Pack I love these lil smokes. Was a nice little surprise. I want more. Good burn nice flavor 5 5 1
Mystery 5-Pack Better than I expected. The draw was a little tough but the flavor more than made up for it. All In all I was pleasantly surprised. 4 5 1
Mystery 5-Pack ...a mystery why I didn't pay attention to the reviews. Definitely nothing special here. 3 5 1
Mystery 5-Pack Sounded like a great deal. What arrived was some really cheap throw aways. 1 5 1
Mystery 5-Pack I recently purchased 2 of the mystery 5 packs hoping I would get a variety of cigars. Instead I got 10 Black Lion cigars which I wouldn't classify as Premium. Also very bland cigars (big cigarette). Will be pawning off on cigar moochers. 2 5 1
Mystery 5-Pack Great taste but the wrap keep coming off. Had you hold it from completely unwrapping 3 5 1
Mystery 5-Pack I have bought these Mystery 5 packs before and I guess sooner or later you get a DUDD!!! This one was TERRIBLE. Normally you get a variety this time All five the same Bering Gold #1 a Swissher International cigar. POOR Draw terrible taste. The only thing I could say good is that all the cigars were equally bad. At least the 2 I tried. The rest will take up room in my humidor for a long time. Buyer Beware. I wonder if JR will make this right somehow?? 1 5 1
Mystery 5-Pack Very good! It's a fun deal to have! Great price for great smokes! 4 5 1
Mystery 5-Pack You just never know what you will get but be sure it's good bargains. Love it cheap. 5 5 1
Mystery 5-Pack Full flavor smooth draw not a bad smoke Will get again. For the price you can not go wrong 4 5 1
Mystery 5-Pack I placed an order at JR which was a bargain with free shipping. That night a deal started of a free 5 cigar sampler with $ 75 purchase. Next morning I call JR and explained the situation. The agent was courteous and pleasant. With no hassles I was told they would send me this sampler. And I received 5 good cigars. An Illusione 888 candela and 888 maduro. A Perla del Mar maduro. A Cornelius and Anthony " The Gent " and a Room 101 Farce. The 888s are Churchills and the others robustos. I have not smoked any of these before and look forward to trying them. JR has great special deals every week. I shop around at about 20 cigar websites and JR was my choice to order from. 5 5 1
Mystery 5-Pack Completely did not expect anything special when I got the "Mystery 5-Pack". Was guessing it wold be stuff they were trying to clear from the shelf. Man, was it a surprise! A very nice assortment of brands, some I have heard of others, not so, but will be ordering in the future. I can't speak for anyone else, but I will grab the mystery cigars the next time I get a chance. 5 5 1
Mystery 5-Pack Have smoked 3 out of the 5 and so far all are very harsh and unflavorful. Will not buy again. 2 5 1
Mystery 5-Pack Description states: "... Boneshaker, Ether, Maria Mancini, La Finca, José Martí, Mayorga, or other customer favorites..." I ordered 4 of these and did not get one of the listed brands. I guess they really mean other customer favorites. I was really hoping for one Maria Mancini out of 20. 2 5 1
Mystery 5-Pack Very good smokes.will buy again,great bargine 5 5 1
Mystery 5-Pack A little strong but good 5 5 1
Mystery 5-Pack Excellent variety in this 5-pack of both taste and size. Great deal for the cost too! 5 5 1
Mystery 5-Pack Always happy with threse 5 5 1
Mystery 5-Pack I received a La Galera Maduro Toro El Lector ($7.15), a San Pedro de Macoris Sun Grown Perla ($4.75), a H. Upmann Special Selection Maduro Rothschilde ($8.15), a Marsh Wheeling Deluxe Light ($1.70), and an Alec Bradley Project 40 Toro ($5.65). Total retail value of $27.40. But unless you are combing the B&Ms, you probably won't be able to pick up singles of these cigars. So I'm happy with the selection I got. I will most likely order again, depending on how these cigars taste. 5 5 1

Cigar Samplers

Mystery 5-Pack MYS5PK

This mystery collection includes a pack of 5 assorted variety grab bag cigars from some pretty cool manufacturers. We're not going to tell you which cigars you will get because that will take away all the fun, but we will tell you that they are worth way more than you're paying! Includes: 5 Assorted Variety Grab Bag Cigars (brands and sizes will vary)
Read more

Various

Various

Various

Various

Various

Pack of 5

Retail Price
$25.00
JR Price
$7.99
You Save
$17.01
InStock

Only $1.60 a cigar!

Customers also bought

Some reviewers may have received JR Insider loyalty program points for their reviews. Click here to learn more about JR Insider.