Round ToroExcellent cigar. AAA+551
March 27, 2022
James M.
Round ToroGreat smoke, and a nice, smooth draw. Quality for a reasonably priced cigar.551
May 6, 2022
Tom S.
Round ToroNice cigar!451
May 21, 2022
MW T.
Round ToroI love Olivia cigars and this one is probably my favorite551
June 1, 2022
S. M.
Round ToroA good cigar, nowhere near as good as the box pressed versions. With that being said I believe and have hope that some time in the humi will unlock that hidden potential this stick seems to have.351
June 15, 2022
Otilio C.
Round ToroJust as good as the box pressed version!551
June 20, 2022
Jason P.
Round ToroI brobably tried all of Olivia cigars, that they make, an i like them all" some are just a little better then others!! But that's just me, too each their own!!551
July 25, 2022
Robert W.
Round ToroGood cigar. Construction is solid and burnis even.451
August 21, 2022
SCOTT L.
Round ToroWow is all I can say. These have great flavor and burn pretty consistently. I have shared with others and they think the same also. Great cigars!!!551
September 1, 2022
Ski3672
Round ToroJust as I suspected, after 5 months in the humi this stick went from good to very good. Still not as good as the original but if you’re a fan of the Melanio as I am it’s a must try. Box worthy451
October 24, 2022
Otilio C.
Round ToroGreat smoke after about 5 months or so on humi.451
October 24, 2022
Tilo
Round ToroThese cigars are top notch quality. They have a smooth draw, with a nice flavor blend, and stay lit until the very end.551
February 28, 2023
Tom S.
Round ToroA perfect cigar! I've smoked almost all formats of the melanio and this is my favorite. The round shape with melanio fillers is simply incredible, a must try!551
April 23, 2023
Jeffrey H.
Round ToroGreat smoke at a bargain! And another great JR experience!451
May 9, 2023
Shawn H.
Round ToroI have to say that I like good cheap cigars and mostly a robusto. But, I decided to buy a box at 40% off and I have smoked just one of these so far. Checking all the rating boxes at 5 stars seems mechanical to me but I couldn't think of anything I didn't like about it. I smoke 3 - 4 cigars a day so my palate is somewhat oblique but this smoke was flavorful and I smoked it down to a small nub. It had a full draw and burned even and consistently all the way. Will ration these to make 'em last.551
June 1, 2023
Hal M.
Round ToroI ordered a box of Round Toro Oliva Melanio JR 50th Anniversary and instead received JR Ultimate 50th Anniversary which is an entirely different product. I reached out to customer service via email and have been ignored.151
July 6, 2023
Don A.
Round ToroThis is one of my favorite cigars. Consistency with every stick and solid construction. It is hard not to grab for these every time so they don't last long in my humidor. Gets a perfect score from me.551
July 31, 2023
Jim
Round ToroDraw is so easy. Getting the quantity in the box sure was great. Love the taste of the smoke. Great product.551
August 1, 2023
John M.
Round ToroAbsolutely loved everything about this cigar, beautiful pick for anyone looking to get an above-average experience for a steal!551
January 18, 2024
Peter P.
Round ToroBeautiful cigar and packaging, decent flavor and burn. Only one concen they don't come in an individual cellophane like most other cigars, just a box.451
March 19, 2024
Emil. A.
Round ToroBeautiful cigar, Construction and packaging! (would prefer to have individual cellophane though for protection).
Decent flavor and draw, with that said I personally think regular Oliva V is tastier cigar for the price...451
March 27, 2024
Emil A.
Round ToroCan't go wrong with these! Well priced for a great smoke551
March 27, 2024
Jeff G.
Round ToroNice draw good consistency very good flavor551
March 31, 2024
Michael W.
Round ToroThis is full of flavor. Strong notes of coffee and chocolate. The only issue I had a few of these was the wrapper cracked one I took the band off. I don’t think it was user error. Otherwise amazing cigar. Highly recommended.551
May 4, 2024
Shadow6227
Round ToroDelightful smoke from start to finish. Really well made and enjoyable medium bodied smoke.451
December 21, 2024
Matt B.
Round ToroGreat cigar. Huge fan of Melanio and this one doesn’t disappoint. Great draw, flavors, & nice long ash. The box deal is good & ages amazing!551
March 7, 2025
Dave
Oliva Melanio JR 50th Anniversary
Round Toro
6 × 50
OSVJR50
Melanio JR 50th Anniversary cigars are the latest brand to release a blend that was created exclusively to honor our yearlong 50th Anniversary celebration. Another first for Oliva, this unique offering from Oliva’s flagship brand, is the very first Melanio rolled in a classic round press as opposed to a box pressed shape. The first thing you’ll notice about this celebratory cigar is its stunning Ecuadorian wrapper that boasts very tight seems and a nice oily sheen. This eye-catching leaf embraces a core of fully aged Nicaraguan binder and long filler tobaccos all grown on the famed Oliva Family farms throughout the c...ountry. Melanio is no stranger to top ratings, as the original Melanio Serie V was honored as the #1 Cigar of 2014, and most recently it was voted as the #8 Cigar of 2020, so its safe to say that this Melanio, made for yours truly, is destined for the same greatness. Light this top-notch 6 x 50 Toro and you’ll be greeted by a slow burning medium-to-full bodied smoke with rich, luxurious flavors of black pepper, toast, leather, cinnamon, and spice, that’s truly worthy of the iconic Melanio name. This is a very limited release, so order a box of 10 today, so that you don’t miss out on these once-in- a lifetime gems from Oliva.