PUR3
InStock
4.511111111111111
45
Rothschild
The draw has been consistently hard and the flavor is burnt and bitter. Not what they were back in the 1980's to 2000's. Very inconsistent. Some maybe 20% work out then... what happened?
2
5
1
June 1, 2018
JOHN S.
Rothschild
I don't why I sample other cigars. I've tried a bunch from Rocky Patel Monte Cristo Partagas Macanudo and JR Alternatives and I always come back to this cigar as my all time favorite. Even the morning after taste is delicious as opposed the the RP cigars I tried that left me wondering if a cat had crapped in my mouth in the middle of the night. They're a good size for when you don't want to spend two hours smoking a stogie. Now I like a bold flavored cigar which is why my top two are this cigar and the Partagas Black. The JR Alternatives of this cigar are good too.
5
5
1
January 29, 2018
NATHAN M.
Rothschild
Very big white clouds of smoke pour from this cigar. Smooth sweet taste comes from that dark Connecticut broadleaf wrapper. Easy smoker nice 30 minute cigar at 4.5
4
5
1
May 27, 2017
John D.
Rothschild
Whenever I'm in need of a good easy burn my faithful fallback cigar.
5
5
1
February 23, 2017
ROBERT C.
Rothschild
This cigar should be the first cigar a new smoker tries. It is that good of a cigar where a newbie will be hooked for life. Not strong good aroma and nice looking in the hand. Been smoking cigars for 30 years so this is an experienced opinion. This cigar is good.
4
5
1
July 22, 2016
RICHARD D.
Rothschild
This is one of my go-to's. Always consistent and always the same quality. Never dry never cracked never smolders out. Just a great little stick!
5
5
1
July 8, 2016
jon h.
Rothschild
Great cigar but I have noticed what seems like short fill at the clipped end. Seems like this has been the case over the past year or so.
4
5
1
June 3, 2016
FREDERICK U.
Rothschild
This is my go to cigar for about the last 15 yers
5
5
1
May 27, 2016
Warren P.
Rothschild
I usually buy this at the a local cigar shop but these were the wonderfully consistent with those. its just a enjoyable one hour smoke!!
5
5
1
May 8, 2016
ROBERT C.
Rothschild
For me this is the cigar I compare all others too.
5
5
1
April 23, 2016
Warren P.
Rothschild
A very enjoyable smoke right to the very end.
5
5
1
March 5, 2016
Brian J.
Rothschild
Good smoke. Have always enjoyed a good punch and with JRs prices it has become a true favorite
5
5
1
November 7, 2015
Timothy H.
Rothschild
My old favorite. Waiting for a sale to buy a box of 50.
5
5
1
August 28, 2015
RODNEY M.
Rothschild
Good draw every stick is the same the build is fantactic !!! Awesome flavor have not had a bad one yet
5
5
1
June 9, 2015
jason a.
Rothschild
My first ever punch. Wow now I know why the picky smokers smoke punch. From the first puff to the nub that burns your fingers it is consistent with flavor burn draw
5
5
1
March 29, 2019
Ronald B.
Rothschild
My first ever punch. Wow now I know why the picky smokers smoke punch. From the first puff to the nub that burns your fingers it is consistent with flavor burn draw
5
5
1
March 29, 2019
Ronald B.
Rothschild
My first ever punch. Wow now I know why the picky smokers smoke punch. From the first puff to the nub that burns your fingers it is consistent with flavor burn draw
5
5
1
March 29, 2019
Ronald B.
Rothschild
Great cigar.
5
5
1
August 13, 2019
Wayne T.
Rothschild
Purchased through a 30% off deal, glad I did. Very consistent smoke, burns slowly and evenly. Nice draw. Mostly a medium strength. Will reorder in future.
5
5
1
December 13, 2019
AMatt
Rothschild
That’s right, the are always the same. That is to say consistent, consistently great, consistently well made, consistently an excellent smoke. And I consistently search for and acquire when on sale.
5
5
1
December 20, 2019
Woody L.
Rothschild
The draw has been consistently hard and the flavor is burnt and bitter. Not what they were back in the 1980's to 2000's. Very inconsistent. Some maybe 20% work out then... what happened?
2
5
1
June 1, 2018
John S.
Rothschild
I don't why I sample other cigars. I've tried a bunch from Rocky Patel Monte Cristo Partagas Macanudo and JR Alternatives and I always come back to this cigar as my all time favorite. Even the morning after taste is delicious as opposed the the RP cigars I tried that left me wondering if a cat had crapped in my mouth in the middle of the night. They're a good size for when you don't want to spend two hours smoking a stogie. Now I like a bold flavored cigar which is why my top two are this cigar and the Partagas Black. The JR Alternatives of this cigar are good too.
5
5
1
January 29, 2018
Nathan M.
Rothschild
Very big white clouds of smoke pour from this cigar. Smooth sweet taste comes from that dark Connecticut broadleaf wrapper. Easy smoker nice 30 minute cigar at 4.5
4
5
1
May 27, 2017
John D.
Rothschild
Whenever I'm in need of a good easy burn my faithful fallback cigar.
5
5
1
February 23, 2017
Robert C.
Rothschild
This cigar should be the first cigar a new smoker tries. It is that good of a cigar where a newbie will be hooked for life. Not strong good aroma and nice looking in the hand. Been smoking cigars for 30 years so this is an experienced opinion. This cigar is good.
4
5
1
July 22, 2016
Richard D.
Rothschild
This is one of my go-to's. Always consistent and always the same quality. Never dry never cracked never smolders out. Just a great little stick!
5
5
1
July 8, 2016
Jon H.
Rothschild
Great cigar but I have noticed what seems like short fill at the clipped end. Seems like this has been the case over the past year or so.
4
5
1
June 3, 2016
Frederick U.
Rothschild
This is my go to cigar for about the last 15 yers
5
5
1
May 27, 2016
Warren P.
Rothschild
I usually buy this at the a local cigar shop but these were the wonderfully consistent with those. its just a enjoyable one hour smoke!!
5
5
1
May 8, 2016
Robert C.
Rothschild
For me this is the cigar I compare all others too.
5
5
1
April 23, 2016
Warren P.
Rothschild
A very enjoyable smoke right to the very end.
5
5
1
March 5, 2016
Brian J.
Rothschild
Good smoke. Have always enjoyed a good punch and with JRs prices it has become a true favorite
5
5
1
November 7, 2015
Timothy H.
Rothschild
My old favorite. Waiting for a sale to buy a box of 50.
5
5
1
August 28, 2015
Rodney M.
Rothschild
Good draw every stick is the same the build is fantactic !!! Awesome flavor have not had a bad one yet
5
5
1
June 9, 2015
Jason A.
Rothschild
Consistent quality with construction, draw and burn. Medium strength. For its size, the cigar last a long time. A nice one hour smoke that I highly recommend. Reasonable pricing, especially with occasional JR discount pricing. Thanks JR
5
5
1
March 17, 2020
AMatt
Rothschild
Annoyingly, Rothschilds are now coming exclusively individually wrapped in cellophane. The cigars are perceptively smaller.
3
5
1
March 25, 2020
QUINCY R.
Rothschild
Excellent cigar and came very fresh not dried out
5
5
1
April 3, 2020
RAY A.
Rothschild
Very happy
5
5
1
June 8, 2020
STEVEN B.
Rothschild
I would review them but I have not received them!
I have not received a response to my request for a current status as to when I will receive them!
1
5
1
December 12, 2020
Louis E.
Rothschild
This is my go to cigar while golfing. Great smoke
5
5
1
January 20, 2021
Bill W.
Rothschild
Favorite cigar
5
5
1
January 21, 2021
Carroll P.
Rothschild
When did Punch start using Connecticut Broadleaf as there wrapper and binder? This is not the same cigar as in the past. I have noticed the manufacture uses Connecticut in the majority of their line.
2
5
1
February 27, 2021
LEE G.
Rothschild
This has been my go-to cigar for many years. Lately though their construction has been slightly inconsistent. I find that many out of each box, about 1/3 of them have really packed hard spots and cannot be smoked. This also affects the draw, making it difficult and detracts from the enjoyment of the cigar. But overall I enjoy them and will probably continue to do so until I find a cigar that is comparable and if they're more consistently easier to smoke I will switch brands for my every day cigar.
5
5
1
April 2, 2021
BRUCE L.
Rothschild
Just as I remembered from the late 1990’s, still a great smoke with a glass of bourbon neat.
5
5
1
June 24, 2021
Luis B.
Rothschild
Very nice for a quick smoke I enjoyed them
4
5
1
July 2, 2021
Louis
Punch
Rothschild 4.50 × 50 PUR3
Tangier than the EMS and a tad smoother than the Oscuro, the famous Punch Rothschild Maduro has always found its niche with the most discriminating of smokers. This solid dark Connecticut Broadleaf has been a huge seller since the Nixon administration! Packaged in boxes of 50.
Read more
4.50
50
Parejo
Connecticut Broadleaf
Connecticut Shade
Dominican Republic/Honduras/Nicaragua
Honduras
Medium - Full
Maduro
Retail Price
$299.50
JR Price
$236.99
You Save
$62.51
Buy a box and get 5 cigars & lighter free!
Customers also bought
Some reviewers may have received JR Insider loyalty program points for their reviews.
Click here to learn more about JR Insider.