4.278846153846154 104
Toro I bought 20 of these and almost everyone had a problem they either burned poorly or would just suck air. Worst cigars I have had. I don't write reviews but I think monte cristo should work on fewer lines and get those right. 1 5 1
Toro Got a pack of these on sale as an impulse item and glad that I did. Great mild flavor. First one tunneled like mad but after a week in the humidor the rest were great. Just wish everything from these guys wasn't so expensive. 5 5 1
Toro Such a smooth and mild cigar. So mellow you can retrohale the whole cigar. Definitely one of my favorite Montecristo cigars. 5 5 1
Toro Always keep a few of these around. To me is another option to the romeo y Juliette reserve. 4 5 1
Toro I don't think it was really him being afraid of being killed as well as city administration as I have no idea why you need a 4 5 1
Toro Great cigar. Montecristo always provides a great smoke. You just can't go wrong when you pick up one from this brand 5 5 1
Toro I love Montecristos and this one is no exception. Excellent construction and a great medium smoke. I highly recommend it 5 5 1
Toro Normally I overlook most Altadis brands but this was recommended by a friend and I'm glad I gave it a shot. Not nearly as mild as the traditional Monte offerings and definitely an interesting smoke. 4 5 1
Toro The montecristo classic is a mild to medium bodied smoke similar to the white series but with a little more flavor and body. There is a bit of black pepper kick on the retro. Typically solid construction with a perfect draw always 4 5 1
Toro What can I say? Great taste. Great draw and an all around excellent smoke. I buy these time after time and I'm never disappointed. 5 5 1
Toro This cigar was very good. I bought a box of these from Jr. I liked every one of them. The burn was even. The draw was perfect. 4 5 1
Toro A very mild and mellow smoke. Very well constructed and near perfect draw. Lacks in my opinion in what I want for flavor but still a great mild smoke 4 5 1
Toro Nothing but perfection as usual. This stick is truly a classic and worth every penny spent. Excellent and consistent draw from beginning to end. Single malt scotch in one hand and this beauty in the other. 4 5 1
Toro It's called a classic for a reason. Exceptional flavors and very well constructed. Burns well and finishes nicely. Highly recommended. 5 5 1
Toro Easy smoking mild bodied and smooth smoke. Well made but a bit pricey for the overall experience. 3 5 1
Toro Nice smooth flavor Consistancy throughout. Goes great with with a nice after dinner drink. 5 5 1
Toro If you're hankering for a classic Montecristo cigar and have an hour and a half this is what you want. 4 5 1
Toro This is the smoke that got Monti started in the us give it a shot with its woody finish and med full body sure to perk you uo 5 5 1
Toro The Monte classic toro is worthy of the classic name. Classic Monte construction classic Monte aroma overall classic Monte quality. This are a humidor staple. 5 5 1
Toro Classic is an understatement. These are iconic smokes. Everyone loves these and when I show my humidor these are the top choice. 5 5 1
Toro This is a slight tick up in strength and flavor over the regular Montecristo white. Creamy smooth with a nice spice on the retro hale with a hint of sweetness as well 4 5 1
Toro This may very well be my new go to smoke. Just tried these about two weeks ago and will definitely be buying a box!! 4 5 1
Toro The name fits because it's a classic. Consistent and great flavor. Always a good choice. 5 5 1
Toro While these are a pretty good smoke there was really nothing that impressed me about them. They weren't bad and I wouldn't turn one down but I wouldn't personally buy any 3 5 1
Toro Montecristo Classic Toro Cigars are really a true classic in the cigar industry. The Montecristo line is known far and wide for their extreme quality and construction. Delightful flavor bursts from this cigar. Tasty try them. 4 5 1
Toro Pretty good. Flavor was good. Not as strong as I usually like but still good. 4 5 1
Toro Nice cigar good but not my style. I have had much better for a much lower price. 5 5 1
Toro Rhis is a stick I always come back to. Its a good cedar expresso cocoa tasting sticl that never ever dissapoints 5 5 1
Toro Again a Montecristo is always an excellent choice. I prefer a longer cigar but when I tried this one it was very good just didn't last long enough 5 5 1
Toro The classic is my favorite combination of flavors in the Montecristo line. Smooth draw with a nice combination of earthy and spicy flavors. Starts smooth and burns even all the way. Holds up great to my heavy wet bit. 4 5 1
Toro One of the first cigars I ever smoked and even today I still enjoy this one. Very mild but not without flavor. Great for beginners or old pros 4 5 1
Toro The classic montecristo Toro is the perfect gift for a special occasion but the truth is these are great smokes anytime I love them in the morning with coffee 4 5 1
Toro Can't beat the classic! It's an all around great smoke full of glavorsband questions like why haven't I been smoking this the whole time kinda questions 5 5 1
Toro Really good cigar smoke these at least once a month or so. Got these from jr cigars great smoke great price and shipping was fast 5 5 1
Toro Another great one from the montecristo line.. none of the montecristos I have ever smoked has been a bad cigar and this one is great also.. happy smoking!!! 4 5 1
Toro Very very nice cogars. Can't beat Monte at all and never will. Buy these and buy them now bc you will love them. 5 5 1
Toro You can pretty much never go wrong with anything produced by monte cristo! I would recommend to anyone 4 5 1
Toro Very bland. Felt like im smoking nothing. It is made so well and looks like it would be nice and flavorful. But not 3 5 1
Toro Good cigar to smoke but wasn't over pleased with the flavor. Had a nice slow even burn. The flavor was very mild as if I was smoking air. 4 5 1
Toro Without a doubt one of my favorite smokes a staple if you will. The consistency of Montecrisro Classics I've had through the years is unparalleled. 5 5 1
Toro Nice.. relaxing smoke just the right size to unwind after a hard day no worries when you get a montecristo in your hand no complaints 4 5 1
Toro Enjoyed this to the nub today. Great flavor. Thick plumes of smoke. Great taste. I am going to have to get more. My local B&M is Casa de Montecristo so no problem getting more. 4 5 1
Toro I Was Given One Of These While Fly Fishing. I Enjoyed It. It Is A Classic Darker Tobacco Smoke. I Put The Nub In My pipe 4 5 1
Toro Not too sure about this cigar. Had a few burn problems and the taste seemed a little strong to me. 3 5 1
Toro Found it on the mild side. Did have a good burn and nice long ash. No touch ups. Lasted an hour an 20 minutes. I am a slow smoker. I prefer medium to full. But it did taste good. Just not strong enough for my everyday after lunch stick. I do recommend buying a 5 pack. 4 5 1
Toro Classic is just that. Classic flavor and classic smoke. Such a great cigar for the orice. You cant go wrong with a monte 5 5 1
Toro this cigar has a lot of the old school cigar flavors. very enjoyable very rustic 4 5 1
Toro I love montecristo but for some reason this cigar which I have smoked twice and both times the draw was stiff and the cigar unraveled 3/4ths in. But the flavor is incredible 3 5 1
Toro A very nice quality smoke. Pretty mellow and mild. A good morning cigar. 4 5 1
Toro Pretty good smoke. Medium to full. Good draw and construction. Even burn and no issues. Enjoyed it all the to the end 5 5 1
Toro Part of a sampler. Had with a not too hoppy IPA before golf. Easy to smoke. Good draw. Flavor was sweet creamy tobacco. Really good. 5 5 1
Toro Excellent cigar- second to whites only 5 5 1
Toro Surprisingly inconsistent in all regards: Construction Flavor Draw Appearence etc... 2 5 1
Toro The Montecristo Classic series is my guilty pleasure. I don't often burn 15 to 20 dollar cigars but these are the exception to that rule. Excellent in every category. I will never turn one down. 5 5 1
Toro Another quality smoke from Montecristo! There persuit of quality and blending keep me a fan. 4 5 1
Toro These cigars start on the weak side but work to a great finish . 4 5 1
Toro My golf buddy who is a Montecristo nut gave me one of these. Well made and smooth flavor. I prefer a more full bodied smoke but enjoyed this gem a lot. Again I am all about flavor and this delivered. 4 5 1
Toro I dont usually smoke montes. But this one i can do given the chance. Not too many monties i restock up on. This could be one. 4 5 1
Toro The montecristo classic series in toro...what can I say other than it would be my daily smoke.if it weren't for the price. When they go on sale I'm all over these bad boys! 5 5 1
Toro Monte Cristo classic toro is that one smoke that never lets me down. Very nice draw. Always buy these by the box 4 5 1
Toro Truly is a classic cigar. Medium to mild body. Beautifully crafted cigar. Great draw. Highly recommended 5 5 1
Toro The classic is just that. Great construction with flawless wrapper. Toro is a big smoke so better have time to smoke it. Lots of smoke. Give it a try if you haven't already. 5 5 1
Toro Great cigar love everything Monte Cristo does. Great construction and nice even burn. Very consistent and a long smoke time too. 5 5 1
Toro Everything that I expect and hope for in a Monte. Wonderful construction and draw. The dry tasting induced visions of the upcoming experience. Smooth flavorful smoke from head to nub. A completely enjoyable experience. 5 5 1
Toro Same as the other monticristo not a fan of them. But you gotta try them all once right. Always looking forward to expand my realm. 3 5 1
Toro If I had unlimited money I would always have a few boxes of these in my humidor 5 5 1
Toro This classic is so great I would recommend this one to anyone and everyone its so good reminds me of Pringles once you pop you just cant stop 5 5 1
Toro This cigar is without a doubt one of my favorites. It is consistently smooth and not overbearing. I recommend this stick to anyone. 4 5 1
Toro This is one of those cigars that you need to have in your box at all times this is the after dinner smoke would be your dinner go. When friends come over this is the one you always want to give them if you have some extras but never want to give them because you love it so much. Start smooth Burns well has nice undertones a good flavors all the way through all the way to the nub is why I would like to say I love this cigar and will always love the cigar. 5 5 1
Toro Should be referred to as is so smooth and yet has flavors I usually associate with bit stronger smokes...try ot 3 5 1
Toro Smooth and mellow flavor. Good draw and burn. There rolled just like youed expect. Thumbs up 4 5 1
Toro Absolutely great cigar. Always remember this one especially it being Montecristo and having it as one of my first cigars 5 5 1
Toro This is a timeless classic. Great smoke. Just smoked one sitting around the fire and I loved it 5 5 1
Toro Very well constructed. Smokes real well. Has even burn. Little loose on the draw but still fine 3 5 1
Toro A loverly cigar. It has a wonderful smooth flavor. Really well made with a nice draw. I would like this to be my every day cigar if it was a little cheaper. 5 5 1
Toro A solid smoke from Montecristo. Pretty smooth draw nice amount of smoke. A balanced medium flavor. 4 5 1
Toro This is mild-medium bodied cigar. Flavor notes: wood earth pepper/spiciness. This is a very mellow stick. Excellent burn and flavorful. Must have in rotation. 3 5 1
Toro Nice smooth flavor Consistancy throughout. Goes great with with a nice after dinner drink. 5 5 1
Toro A long tasty smoke with toast nuts and barley flavors. Was a little dry and one dimensional and could use more transitions 4 5 1
Toro I absolutely loved the flavor of this stick. The cold draw was excellent and paired well with my IPA. 4 5 1
Toro The Monte classic is a good well rounded smoke with a lot going on in the flavor department. Well made good draw. A good evening smoke with a glass of whiskey. 4 5 1
Toro Montecristo classic is a typical Montecristo cigars Well made great wrapper burn finish and finish well Taste is disappointing 4 5 1
Toro These are good smokes smooth an mild they burn perfectly perfect for sitting by a fire with a beer 5 5 1
Toro The classico series by Montecristo is a great smoke. Really good and creamy smoke. Perfect. 5 5 1
Toro Very basic but very good Montecristo so smooth especially if you like more of the mild cigars 4 5 1
Toro One of my go to cigars. It has never failed me with burn construction and in flavor. A must for any cigar smoker 5 5 1
Toro I'm not too much into the Connecticut Shade wrappers. Once in a while I'll go for one. Montes are perfectly rolled excellent draw and very consistent. Flavor is quite pleasant strength is medium side of mild. Creamy nutty and fresh cedar flavors. Hints of light fruit with a dash of white pepper. 4 5 1
Toro Well how can you go wrong with a classic. This is a great smoke start to finish 4 5 1
Toro I have never had any issues with any montecristo. This is no exception. Great flavor. 5 5 1
Toro Classic for a good reason. I'm a big Monte white fan and the classic plays off of it very well but with a little less cream and more cedar/wood. Not my favorite monte but it is a must have for fans. 4 5 1
Toro Good cigar smokes well nothing special but worth a try. Other montecristos are better. 4 5 1
Toro An outstanding cigar with lots of life and hints of leather spice and cedar. Great until the very end 5 5 1
Toro Everyone's favorite Monte. This is were is all started. Deep rich and complex flavor the Monte is known for. Excell entry draw ash smoke and enjoyable finish. Enjoy this smoke. 5 5 1
Toro Very good cigar flavor is classic cristo and great make. Would reccommend to any level of smoker 5 5 1
Toro This is called the Montecristo Classic for a reason. It's their oldest blend. It's the one that started it all. This is a must have !!! 5 5 1
Toro Small draw problems. Had stick in the end but removed it and it was fine good burn construction 4 5 1
Toro A good cigar by most any measure a little pricey and I just doesn't quite deliver anything special in my opinion. I will not deny that it is very good but not unique by any stretch 4 5 1
Toro Montecristo classic toro is a pretty good cigar. A little spicy finish and good flavor. Wonderul 5 5 1
Toro Monte is a great smoke. Well balanced flavor draw and burn. Can't go wrong with a classic like this 4 5 1
Toro A very good and great class of cigars it's mild sweet a great blend of tobacco 5 5 1
Toro The absolute definition of why Montecristo is a top name in the business and why they are so well known. The cigar smokes and burns great. 4 5 1
Toro Was a solid cigar for the price. Didn't love it but would def smoke it again. A tad spicy for my taste but still good 4 5 1
Toro Background: I’ve been a JR customer for over 30 yrs. I prefer a milder Dominican, and have a number of of reliable old favorites, like H Upman, Macanudo, Don Diego and Montecristo. I recently ordered a box of the Montecristo Classic toros. To be brief, this is the most disappointing box of cigars I have ever bought. The cigars are flabby; they are much too loosely rolled and they get soggy when smoked. The flavor is consequently dismal. I can’t believe that MC even put their label on these things, some of the most unpleasant cigars I have ever smoked! Iwon’t be buying anything else from Altadis anytime soon.... 1 5 1
Toro Good draw well-constructed, good even burn to the end with a mild mellow flavor. 5 5 1

Montecristo Classic

Toro 6 × 52 MXCT_1

When you smoke the popular Montecristo Classic Toro, you will realize that larger ring mellow to medium cigars just don’t get any better than this. The classic line adheres to an ageless recipe of using only the highest-grade Connecticut shade wrappers and specially aged Dominican binder and filler tobaccos. When you light up a Montecristo Classic Toro, you are in for a very special treat!  Sold in single cigars. 
Read more



Connecticut Shade

Dominican Republic

Dominican Republic

Dominican Republic




JR Price

Customers also bought

Some reviewers may have received JR Insider loyalty program points for their reviews. Click here to learn more about JR Insider.