Punch Rothschild · 4.5 × 50 JRPUR3
Bundle of 20
No, I don't want instant checkout
Dark Brown / Maduro
Customers also bought
Thanks for taking the time to submit your review. Once it has been approved, it will appear on this page.
Submit a review
3 out of 3 found this review helpful.
Nice but don't taste like Punch Rothchild
Chas_NJ on 01/09/17
I recvd these Jlate Dec 2016. I am very familiar with the Punch "regular" (lowest cost) cigars, specifically the Rothchild maduro and London Club maduro. This particular cigar does NOT taste like the Punch Rothchild, if that's your objective, skip this one. But it's not a bad cigar, nice rich flavor. The wrapper has an odd taste to it but not so bad that I wanted to return it, just an odd taste. I won't buy this again but as I said, it's not a bad cigar, I will just try others. J&R Alternatives are worth the money, especially the Nicaraguans, all are nice, densely rolled (like a premium) and rich tasting
1 out of 1 found this review helpful.
DarkKnight on 02/24/17
Not bad at all considering. It's a much better cigar than the Hoyo counterpart and not as bold but more of a medium/bold. The cigar itself is very close to what Punch is supposed to be and can easily be mistaken for Punch. I found the draw to be consistent for all the sticks, the construction is firm and I have been able to finish them all down to the nub where it's just short of burning my lips. For the price you can't go wrong.
A good smoke
natemoore on 01/28/18
The real Punch Rothschild maduro is my absolute favorite cigar. I'm not sure these taste like them, but they're a good smoke. Good taste, good aroma, good morning after flavor. I like these better than some of the Rocky Patel cigars I tried with this same order.
Good Smoke on 03/18/17
Compared to the Puch Rothschild Maduro this smoke is a little over the top. A little more intense flavor (maybe a little too much pepper) than the Punch, but the aroma is spot on the original. If you can get past that this is a good affordable smoke.
JR Alternative Punch Rothchild
Trout King on 05/28/18
Call me cheap, but I did not get to retire at age 56 buying pricey cigars. The JR Alternative Punch Rothschild is a fine cigar, and for the price, you can't go wrong. I smoke one of them with a couple of beers and I feel like a million bucks. They are worth it!
Ffb44@att.net on 01/03/17
Last order was not the same as all of my previous orders of this cigar. Different ring size, length, and taste. I am reordering to try again . Loved all my previous orders, but this one is not up to my taste preference.
Sfoglio on 10/23/16
Cheap cigar. But flavor is top notch. I had a 20 pack of these and the burn isn't always the best. Some are perfect. Others have veins in them that make it burn uneven. But the flavor is perfect! I'll continue to buy them!
Great consistent smoke
Big Papa on 05/18/18
Just received these cigars. Wonderful! Regularly smoke Brick house mighty mighty . Slow consistent burn. Slightly spicy on the tounge. Great value. Would pay another dollar per cigar for a 6 x 60 version (hint hint). Was worried about construction at this price, but held together like a $12 smoke.