Our in-house cigar gurus are at it again. They've picked 6 of their most dependable go-to smokes and created honest cigar reviews for each. They've also put together an out-of-this-world Expert Picks Sampler for November that'll give you the chance to try each of their premium cigar picks firsthand. And it's only $24.95! That's a savings of 45% off the regular retail price. Each sampler includes 1 of each of the following cigars:

Get the Expert Picks

Retail Price$45.20

JR Price$24.95

You Save$20.25

Crowned Heads La Imperiosa Magicos

Magicos ·4.5 ×52 ·Oscuro

“Carve your own path” is a favorite saying from the guys over at Crowned Heads, who’ve recently released La Imperiosa. Based on the original limited Las Calaveras cigar, La Imperiosa is special; it hits all marks for me. It’s flavorful, complex, and constructed perfectly. Choose this cigar if you want to know what smoking a home run is like.

Perdomo Reserve 10th Anniversary Champagne Robusto

Robusto ·5 ×54 ·Natural

George Costanza dressed according to mood. Well, I pick my smokes according to mood, and even though I love full-bodied cigars, I sometimes want a lighter, milder smoke. In those moments I grab a Perdomo Champagne. Flavors of light coffee and peanuts blend flawlessly with the Nicaraguan filler that kicks up the strength to a perfect medium. Never harsh and always a perfect burn; it’s my “Morning Mist.”

Villainy Cold Case

Cold Case ·6 ×54 ·EMS

 Buy a box, get 5 Villainy Cold Case cigars, valued at $27.50, absolutely free!

After being informed that no Villainy size was being named after his favorite characters—Dr. Octopus and Two-Face—Angry Joe went on a raging rampage. While he was still licking his wounds, I found joy in deciding via coin toss which of the two remaining samples to smoke. So I savored a peppery cigar matching my nemesis’s face color - the Villainy Cold Case.

El Rey del Mundo Reserva Nicaragua Principale

Principale ·6.25 ×54 ·EMS

 Buy a box, get a 7 Cigars, valued at $39.28, absolutely free!

I have enjoyed ERdM cigars since a coworker gave me one over 10 years ago. When the Reserva Nicaragua was released, I found that I enjoyed them just as much. And now there’s a new offering, the Principale, a nod to one of the most popular JR sizes. It delivers a sweet spiciness withtouches of mocha and nuts. Definitely a must-try.

My Father No. 1 Robusto

No. 1 Robusto ·5.25 ×52 ·EMS

After just a few puffs, you’ll realize his father Don Pepin taught him well! The My Father No.1 is a very solidly packed 5.25 × 52 Robusto fashioned by Jamie Garcia to honor his famous dad. Upon pre-light inspection, I knew I was in for a special treat. The stunning reddish brown Habano Rosado wrapper was fragrant and gleaming with oil. However, there is more to a premium cigar than just beauty, and the No.1 really delivers the goods!

Hearty notes of earth, dark roast coffee and assorted spice greeted my palate with every puff. These succulent flavors intensify as the smoke matures, and the final third presented succulent notes of cinnamon and buttery caramel, making it almost impossible to retire. Two thumbs up on this full-bodied gem!

Aging Room Havao Treble

Treble ·6 ×50 ·EMS

The popular Aging Room Haváo Connecticut has been launched in six sizes, I chose the Treble for my review. The seamless and silky to the feel golden brown Ecuador Connecticut wrapper made my mouth water even before I ignited up my trusty torch. Honestly, I usually opt for a more a high-octane type of smoke, but several puffs in, the Habano Criollo binder and filler offered an abundance of flavor that even a fancier of full bodied cigars( like myself) would enjoy. This 6 x 50 starts with a blast of pepper letting you know, although mild, this stick ain’t no lightweight! The zesty intro quickly gives way to a tapestry of warm succulent flavors that include vanilla, coffee bean, cream, wood, and pepper. The final third is as tasty as it starts, and the fragrant sweet aroma is a heavenly bonus.